3 ms·
So you seem to be essentially saying, you think we know pretty much everything already, so it's not productive to continue checking? Both sides of that are com
by crazygringo 6y ago
So you seem to be essentially saying, you think we know pretty much everything already, so it's not productive to continue checking?
Both sides of that are completely false. We have gigantic gaps in basic nutrition knowledge, and the idea that we have a strong idea of all existing important correlations is similarly completely and utterly incorrect.
The idea that flip-flopping is due to a "vast marketing machine" is also completely disingenuous. I'm not talking about pop science articles, I'm talking about disagreement between scientists.
I seriously don't know where people get this idea that human nutrition is this advanced science where we know most of the answers. I can only assume it's wishful thinking? It would be nice if we did... but we really don't. And there's a good reason for it, which is that it's incredibly difficult to ethically perform decades-long controlled experiments with nutrition in people to provide definitive scientific answers, for the obvious reasons.
- hansvm 6y ago> So you seem to be essentially saying, you think we know pretty much everything already Not in the slightest. I've explicitly said we have "a reasonable understanding of nutrition" and not even vaguely implied that we know everything. Am I misunderstanding you that poorly too, and is that why we seem to be in such disagreement?