6 ms·
I think for plastics the right answer is standardization. I know that's not people want to hear, but I don't think there is any way around it. 1. Ban all singl
by oblio 6y ago
I think for plastics the right answer is standardization. I know that's not people want to hear, but I don't think there is any way around it.
1. Ban all single use plastics that can be replaced somewhat economically with biodegradable materials (with a small price increase, maybe 2-5-10%).
2. Standardize plastic container compositions, shapes and sizes in a huge ISO catalog. EVERY product a company makes/uses has to be from this catalog. Companies can add another category one by going through the standardization process. Marketing can be done by applying biodegradable materials to the exterior.
Basically have a few material compositions:
- high strength/heavy
- medium strength/medium weight
- reduced strength/light
Have a standardized set of sizes:
- 100ml (and US equivalent)
- 250ml
- 330ml
- 500ml
...
Plus a standardized set of shapes for each size.
At the end of the day you'd get:
3 x number of sizes (probably 40-50 sizes?) x number of shapes (probably 10-15 shapes per size?) = 1200 - 2250 categories. And I'm being generous here, I think we should probably keep this total number under 500, ideally under 100, but I don't think such a low number is feasible.
Then charge a deposit for each plastic container and upon container return give this deposit back.
Same thing for glass, actually.
This would make plastic containers reusable, even across brands, and would probably reduce our plastic waste by orders of magnitude.
Heck, the same thing could probably be done for plastic bags.
However, this plan would also reduce plastic consumption (and production, so $$$) by orders of magnitude, so I don't expect it to ever pass a solid lobbying plan.
- peterlk 6y agoI have some friends who have recently started a business based on this model. They don't have a site up yet, but are doing some small scale tests in Colorado. I'm happy to direct anyone who is interested toward them.
- 495636483 6y agoAlso standardize the composition and coloring. That's the major problem with recycling. I say transparent and one opaque variant for photoprotection.
- oblio 6y agoI have included composition in my description ;-) And coloring, well, a part of it would be composition and the rest should IMO temporary marketing coloring on top of the base composition (i.e. paint the bottle with something biodegradable). Color should not be part of the standard as it would make the "support matrix" unsustainable and companies should not be allowed to "pass the buck" back to us consumers.
- eru 6y agoWhat's the problem you are trying to solve here? In general for the kinds of problems that intersect with economics, taxes are more efficient than outright bans.
- oblio 6y agoA) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Pacific_garbage_patch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Pacific_garbage_patch B) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microplastics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microplastics Plastic containers of all types should be reusable and there should also be incentives for reusing them. We don't make a screw, use it to build something and then discard it once we disassemble the thing. For the last point, I'd definitely want to see examples where taxes are more efficient than bans. Everything I've seen and read (and I like to read a lot), points the other way around. So I'd definitely want to read some studies that says that tax increases are better than bans. As a single counterpoint, we've been taxing cigarettes a ton for several decades. Smoking rates have gone down, but only extremely slowly. It took decades. So if you consider partially solving an issue after several decades "efficient", then yeah, taxes are efficient.
- toopok4k3 6y agoSounds like proper sewage processing and landfills would be better and faster solutions to A and B. Then we can also talk about Asia being the primary source of the trash in oceans...
- oblio 6y ago1. People throw trash everywhere. You'll see trash on Mount Everest, you'll see it in a random forest in Eastern Europe. 2. Landfills are not enough. Rich countries just "export" their trash for storage in poor countries. We're just making too much trash, there's no "proper" or "better". Reduce, reuse, recyle. Recycle is mostly a lie. We need reduce and reuse.
- skocznymroczny 6y ago
- alexisread 6y agoThis is great, though I wonder what we would do about laminates. For example, a can of cola has a plastic lining to protect the aluminium from degrading, tetrapak containers are laminates to prevent leakage, counter tops and flatpak furniture tends to be plastic-wrapped chipboard. A lot of these laminates can be replaced, but some are rather harder to. Progressive taxation based on recyclability is an easy win which incentivizes correct packaging (and transport packaging as well) and would be an easier sell. Additional, homogeneous packaging would be taxed less. The branding that goes on the packaging is still open to design, so there's room for differentiation there - a necessary component for adoption. Lastly, standardizing recyclability across the state/county/country would be useful as then tourists etc. can also understand a simple recycling message.
- contingencies 6y agoPoint A: Biostarch PLA wastes huge amounts of energy to convert biodegradeable starch in to nominally biodegradeable PLA. It would be better for everyone to (1) move to non single use plastics; or (2) recycle plastic (very problematic and rarely economical); instead of (3) wasting the energy and CO2 to fabricate biostarch PLA just for the option of throwing it away carelessly. Point B: As I have spent months of time on thermoforming research (just visited 9 machine manufacturers last week and am currently buying a line to produce permanent parts) I will try to raise a few points as to why this plan might also be difficult technically. Many parts are custom produced for specific use cases. Moulds degrade over time and may not produce the same caliber of part early, middle and late run. Some people require different polymers for valid engineering reasons (optical, thermal or structural properties, joining/printing/other post-process compatibility, etc.) Say you have a mould and you use virgin material versus some other material. Polymer selection affects all properties. Thickness affects thermal characteristics and structural properties. Equipment and ambient environment state including thermals, air particulates and humidity, mould state, die state, air pressure, configured cycle time, coolant circuit state, type and care of handling after forming. However, the kicker is food safety (a legal requirement in most markets) - rarely guaranteed outside of purely virgin material (there are exceptions: I believe there is a UK recycler that does it) and food safe material is the dominant single use plastics market.
- oblio 6y agoI know my plan doesn't cover everything and there are a lot of exceptions. But if we don't want to destroy the planet, we have to do something like it. Everyone thinks they're special. Why does Coca Cola have a different bottle shape compared to Pepsi or to Fanta? That makes no sense. We should turn the approach on its head with what is a dangerous material: you should have to prove that what you're doing deserves being made. Have you thought about the consequences of your actions when this product is mass produced, 30 years from now? I doubt many have. The standard catalog could have more axes, such as different material types, mine was just an example. Get 10 world famous materials engineers and have them come out with a catalog that covers the most widespread uses. This doesn't need to be a 100% solution, it needs to cover, say, 95%. The rest of the 5% could be treated as exceptions and you'd have to get a license. Yes, some creativity would be lost. But you could for example, exempt some smaller producers (if your factory makes fewer than 10k units per year, in total, no need for approval, just show us the proof that you're only going to produce that much). But again, plastics have proven to be dangerous materials, in an insidious way. They're not explosives but they do a lot of damage.
- sriku 6y agoThis isn't theoretical any more. My state (tamil nadu/india) has banned plastic bags and cups .. generally what we might think of as single use. You have to take your own bags or (in some shops) buy reusable+degradable cloth bags. There are also grocery shops like "eco indian" to which you take your own containers, fill them up, weigh and pay. That's how we used to do it when I was a kid, but it all went plastic after that. Glad to see it coming back. Covid threw another curve ball but the ban hasn't changed. Next up should be food packaging.
- r00fus 6y agoDamn this sounds so advanced coming from the USA. COVID massively disrupted reusable bag effort here in CA, USA.
- cobbzilla 6y agoI really like the idea of standardization. Even if there are 500 standards, that's much better than an unbounded number. Regulation would certainly force the issue, but one way or another the consumer packaged goods industry (and other industries) need to get their heads around focusing competition around everything BUT packaging. When packaging has become standard, no one competes there any more. If everyone has the mindset that this is expected and OK, just focus competitive efforts elsewhere -- product quality, branding, better ingredients/parts, lower price, whatever. Your packaging design/pollution budget is now free for other opportunities. There is some advantage in selecting the right standard size, but you either know what your industry is doing or you pay a consultant to tell you which one to try next. What you don't do is spend lots more money designing your own custom packaging that may or may not help sales and will never be recycled. And then there is the entire packaging design industry, not a small one, who will not like this at all. Anyone want to play devil's advocate and guess what they might say?
- oblio 6y ago> When packaging has become standard, no one competes there any more. If everyone has the mindset that this is expected and OK, just focus competitive efforts elsewhere -- product quality, branding, better ingredients/parts, lower price, whatever. Your packaging design/pollution budget is now free for other opportunities. They can still brand the packaging. Just use biodegradable, safe glues, paper, paint, etc. to put on top of the actual bottle. Yes, the bottles will be a bit generic, but there's a lot you can do with a bit of creativity. What they're doing is like developers rewriting the Python library 1 billion times because they all want to be special snowflakes. Though rewriting does happen, the vast majority of developers build on top of the standard library, not besides it. > And then there is the entire packaging design industry, not a small one, who will not like this at all. Anyone want to play devil's advocate and guess what they might say? When a few benefit and many lose, that's called corruption. Any proposal will have some people against it, you can't please everyone all the time.
- detritus 6y agoI was discussing this with a friend the other night. I can envisage a future where plastic packaging is all entirely standardised and left as virgin as possible for recycling - no dyes, no printed elements or thin film decoration. Instead, basic (/complex, if you like) low to medium resolution laser-etched graphics and descriptions, and any fancy-ass graphical marketing/advertising visible through whatever spectacles/phone AR is popular.
- Chris2048 6y agoOr perhaps encourage "container for life" storage with refill machines. e.g. purchase a long-lasting detergent container, and refill it at a detergent dispensing machine. Otherwise you'd need to provide an easy way or sorting returned containers (by type) so they go back into circulation. Maybe QR-codes on bottles and "smart bins" that pay you for disposing of them?