4 ms·
I think most people's definition of "free market" is that people can sell or not sell their property or services for whatever price they wish - not that any goo
by Symmetry 16y ago
I think most people's definition of "free market" is that people can sell or not sell their property or services for whatever price they wish - not that any good or service is legal to own or produce. People sometimes, but not always, lump the right not to have your property or labour taken from you under the term "free market" and sometimes just lump not having it taken from you except for monetary taxes (as opposed to taxes in kind or forced labour). Some people also lump freedom of contract under the rubric of "free market".
The generally accepted term for everything, including murder and conspiracy to murder, being legal is "anarchy" and if people still have free markets in this anarchy thats generally referred to as "anarcho-capitalism". Though nothing about having a free market says that murder is legal and probably says that forcing another person to work for you using the threat of violence is illegal. I can certainly see arguing that a free market implies legal prostitution, however, since unmarried sex is legal in most places.
EDIT: And as to Capitalism, well to quote Wikipedia: "There is no consensus on the precise definition of capitalism, nor how the term should be used as an historical category."
- barrkel 16y agoYou keep coming in with this notion of what's legal. That's my very point exactly; what's legal and not is external to the free market itself. It is imposed from without, constraining it, and is not intrinsic to it. Whether contracts for assassination, or prostitution, or raw milk, or cigars from Cuba, etc. are legally traded is a matter of degree, not some self-evident binary choice. All constrain free trade. People arguing for free trade are generally arguing for a particularly scoped subset of "free" trade, but they take as a relatively unexamined assumption that free trade is inherently good. Usually, there is some trade in particular that they would like to pursue, and they fight laws that inhibit it using free trade as a rallying cry, as if it were a self-evident justification. My point is that free trade by itself is not intrinsically desirable, and that we do in fact want all sorts of limits on what people are free to trade in.