2 ms·
I would like to see your math on the risk. It's not like human drivers are perfect; for decades, long-haul truckers have been known for drug use just to keep aw
by wpietri 6y ago
I would like to see your math on the risk. It's not like human drivers are perfect; for decades, long-haul truckers have been known for drug use just to keep awake. [1] And trucks break down for all sorts of reasons, so "robot has issues and pulls over" could plausiblly be just another one of those.
I think the economics of remote backup drivers is working for Waymo, so I don't see why it wouldn't work for truck drivers, which are higher value. And for the you-need-somebody-on-site problems, there's already a network of tow and repair services that will surely be willing to send someone out.
Fueling seems similarly surmountable. Semis have very long ranges, and fuel up at specialist facilities that are just off the highway. I don't think it will take much persuasion for truck stops to offer full service fueling on a $500 fill-up. And it's not obvious that security will be worse. An automated truck is going to have a lot of high-quality cameras and be in continuous contact with a staffed operations center. The vehicle may be effectively impossible to steal, and transferring a semi's worth of cargo is not a fast process.
I think it's also important to note that to start it doesn't actually have to be better. It just has to be a) within shouting distance, and b) exciting enough that some exec thinks they'll get a promotion out of it.
[1] e.g. this from 1973 https://genius.com/Jim-croce-speedball-tucker-lyrics https://genius.com/Jim-croce-speedball-tucker-lyrics and this from the Trucking Alliance: https://truckingalliance.org/new-study-supports-projection-of-drug-abuse-in-the-trucking-industry/ https://truckingalliance.org/new-study-supports-projection-o...
- root_axis 6y agoWaymo is an extremely specialized closed system that can't be generalized to the needs of cross-country long haul trucking, if it could we wouldn't be having this conversation. The fueling concerns are pretty trivial from an engineering perspective, the problem is one of infrastructure. Yes, industry could prop up some fueling stations, but nothing approaching the coverage necessary to make it more practical than e.g freight by rail. Security concerns are very real, there is no such thing as "impossible to steal" and the threat of cameras are trivially defeated by way of masks under cover of darkness. Transferring a semi's worth of cargo is only slow if you're not prepared to do it in advance. I also want to reemphasize the shift in psychology associated with removing the human element, criminals are absolutely going to be emboldened by the fact they are dealing with a harmless predictable computer and not a human person that might resist their efforts, cause them injury, or otherwise complicate the risk involved. It's also well known in criminal psychology that people are much more willing to justify criminal behavior they perceive as victimless. Setting aside my practical objections, yes, it's true that it doesn't have to be better to start, but I think there's no chance it gains momentum since there is a lot of up-front cost and complexity for relatively small financial gain vs just e.g. freight by rail.
- wpietri 6y agoYou make a lot of assertions here, but I don't see any data backing them. Fueling stations already exist. The only "infrastructure" needed is an agreement with a couple truck stop chains than when a robot truck pulls in, somebody goes out fill it up. Full-service gas stations are not a radical innovation. I think your security concerns are a fairy tale. I especially suspect you have never loaded or unloaded a semi. A mask might keep a person's face from being seen, but it can't keep the theft from being detected. Trucks generally drive on well-policed, limited-access roads. For this to work, time of trouble to time of police response has to be larger than the time to break into, unload, and load a semi's worth of goods. By the side of the road. At night. Plus you need more time to get a semi, which is not an inconspicuous, far enough away from the scene of the crime, that the cops won't find it. Will people try it? Sure. But I don't see any reason to think it becomes a major issue. Certainly not a dealbreaker, because if I'm wrong and there's a crime wave like this, a bunch of well-funded, powerful groups will be immediately demanding better police response and new laws.