3 ms·
What alternative would you propose? You can't just remove Boeing as a company: they have tens of thousands of existing aircraft in the field that need to be mai
by pdonis 6y ago
What alternative would you propose? You can't just remove Boeing as a company: they have tens of thousands of existing aircraft in the field that need to be maintained, and a large number of people who were not at fault in all of this whose jobs would be eliminated. So how do you hold the proper people accountable without doing so much collateral damage that the cost of that outweighs the benefits?
Also, responsibility doesn't just like with Boeing; the FAA certified the 737 MAX, and the rules that allowed that to happen were written by lawmakers and bureaucrats over a period of decades. How do you hold all of them accountable? Many, if not most, of those people aren't even actively working any more.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoThe alternative is obvious - corporate manslaughter charges, aimed at management that knew plane was unsafe and pushed on regardless. > " collateral damage so cost of that outweighs the benefits" Do we have a system a justice or do we not? You seem to suggest some people are above the law. Let's see, could that possibly lead to corruption and abuse of power?
- pdonis 6y ago> You seem to suggest some people are above the law. I'm suggesting no such thing. I'm simply pointing out that "justice" is not as simple as you are making it sound.
- pdonis 6y ago> The alternative is obvious - corporate manslaughter charges, aimed at management that knew plane was unsafe and pushed on regardless. And the obvious defense to that is that the FAA certified the plane. Then what?
- dnautics 6y ago737 max should be permanently decertified, boeing should take all associated losses. FAA officials should be charged with manslaughter.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoFAA officials should face consequences, but boeing purposefully misled the regulator and got away scott-free.
- pdonis 6y ago> FAA officials should face consequences And their obvious defense is that they were acting entirely in accordance with statutes passed by Congress and regulations approved by the statutory process for doing that. Then what?
- josefx 6y agoCertification was almost entirely done by Boeing in-house, with the design specs. it forwarded to the FAA not reflecting the final state of the system.
- redis_mlc 6y ago> the FAA certified the plane. That's not how it works: - the mfg. and ODM FAA reps submit certification paperwork to the FAA. The FAA doesn't employ an airline design team to review the schematics, etc. - if the paperwork matches FAA regulations, then it's certified. They don't open inspection plates or walk around with a flash light and verify anything unless they have a particular reason to do so. The FAA regulates the airline industry by receiving, storing and reviewing paperwork. However, the submitted paperwork misrepresented how MCAS worked, stating that it met FAA requirements when the nose-down rate was actually about 4x what was documented, and was continuous rather than occurring once or twice.