4 ms·
People should be allowed to unionize but I'll oppose it at every front. Because mass power means mass power that can be turned against me. 2016 taught me someth
by renewiltord 6y ago
People should be allowed to unionize but I'll oppose it at every front. Because mass power means mass power that can be turned against me. 2016 taught me something. There are a large contingent of anti-immigrants out there. Should you allow the creation of a mob, a day will come when the populists will take control of it.
In moments, the mob can break generations of integration. The best defence against it is prevention of its formation.
No, should you gain any appreciable fraction of power to unionize, I think there's a lot of my money I would throw into the opposite effort. No populist mobs. Never again. No group should have that power.
- madeofpalk 6y agoThe problem is there already is a single "mob of power", and that’s the employer. If your employer decides it’s anti-immigrant, that’s bad for you. Unions are an attempt to create a "mob" to counter the "mob" of the employer.
- renewiltord 6y agoThis part is true. The employer does have more power than most employees. However, the employer isn't permitted the kind of cross-company monopsony that unions are permitted to form. Employers would like to try this and have done so (Apple+Google famous anti-poach being an example). Anti-poaching agreements are illegal and when they take place they've been slapped down. However, unions have no such restriction. A Google union would affiliate itself with a Facebook union and those with a Kickstarter union and those with a Random Startup union and before you know it you can't go anywhere without being subject to the wisdom common to Google+Facebook. This makes sense to the union: increased power comes with increased size. If my employer decides they're anti-immigrant I will go elsewhere and be paid just as well. They will lose.
- Apocryphon 6y ago> However, the employer isn't permitted the kind of cross-company monopsony that unions are permitted to form. Sure they are. That's just called industry practice. Multiple corporations can decide that certain policies towards workers all favor them, even without a formalized agreement (clandestine or not). They can even all choose to enshrine these policies through lobbying groups and PACs.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- postingpals 6y agoI was planning to argue with this, but I only feel sorry that you see something as historically useful as unionising in such a light.
- renewiltord 6y agoThanks for sharing your position in any case. Historic anti-immigrant stances by America's biggest unions are close to why I feel this way.
- AshWolfy 6y agoWhat about unions like the UFW which were among the greatest champions of immigrant rights in the US. The accepted line in unions these days is anti immigration efforts divide workers
- renewiltord 6y agoThat's right. These days. Could change again. But they could demonstrate immutable faith by adopting a clause like what I mention here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25284296 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25284296 If they are pro immigrant it shouldn't be much of a problem.
- AshWolfy 6y agoWell you could get involved in the labor movement to make sure that doesnt happen, after all unions are democratic. Unions turning against immigration is very unlikely, even relatively conservative unions like the teamsters are on board now today being pro immigration is being pro union and being anti immigration is being anti union
- renewiltord 6y agoWhat is your opinion as to the likelihood of your union adopting the poison pill that I mentioned above? Do you personally find it convincing that unions that are anti-xenophobic should have poison pills that protect against them becoming vehicles for xenophobia?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AshWolfy 6y agoMobs are a fact of life, you can either live in denial, or you can try and make things better
- renewiltord 6y agoWell, right now all tech worker organization is crappy right now. The mob dissipates its energy in online rage about whiteboard interviews and hatred of foreigners. That kind of mob I like. Oderunt et metuunt, as one might most hope for. And they are powerless in their rage. With sufficient work they can be kept like that. Either at peace or powerlessly angry.
- AshWolfy 6y agoMaybe so, but the mob im organizing with is groups like no tech for ice which have stopped companies from contracting with ICE. Or the kickstarter union which secured good terms for workers laid off during covid
- renewiltord 6y agoCongratulations and good luck to you.
- Ar-Curunir 6y agolol so every individual should stand alone, while the employer (Google in this case, but mega corps in general) will bend the government to steamroll your rights.