7 ms·
Does anyone have any idea how many daily "official" lotteries are drawn worldwide? I'd guess something on the order of 1,000 maybe? (One per country, plus a bu
by crazygringo 6y ago
Does anyone have any idea how many daily "official" lotteries are drawn worldwide?
I'd guess something on the order of 1,000 maybe? (One per country, plus a bunch more for individual states within countries?)
I know they vary in numbers of positions and values, but I am kind of curious roughly how often you can expect a sequence of consecutive numbers (increasing or decreasing) to be chosen anywhere worldwide.
As an initial guess, if it's 5 balls drawn from 50, a thousand times a day, then it's something like a ~13% chance to happen somewhere yearly.
So since this is international news, and not the kind of thing that gets reported every year... it doesn't seem implausibly unlikely, no? (It's not like it's a once-in-a-millenia or once-in-earth's-lifetime kind of thing.)
- kbenson 6y agoDoes someone mind posting the math on this? I'm getting something like 775% chance it would happen yearly, but that seems too likely, and I think I screwed mine up somewhere, and wouldn't mind seeing where I made some wrong assumption in how to compute the probabilities.
- mrosett 6y agoProbability it happens is 1 in 50c5 (the number of ways to choose 5 balls out of 50.) So probability it doesn't happen is 1-1/50c5. Probability it never happens in a year is that number raised to (3651000). That gives 85%, so there's a 1-.85 = 15% chance that it does happen each year: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=%281-1%2F%2850choose5%29%29%5E%281000*365%29 https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=%281-1%2F%2850choose5%...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- brandmeyer 6y agoThis analysis is spot-on under the assumption of 1000 lotteries per day, although your asterisks are getting trashed by the markdown. To the other folks ending up with some wild results, there is a basic checksum on probability: If you compute the probability of an event happening at greater than 100% you've borked something up. Bug: They drew 5 balls from one pool of 50 with an independent draw from another smaller pool of 20, so you need ~~50 ncr 6~~ (50 ncr 5) * 20, not 50 ncr 5. Nit: I would rephrase your answer that there is a 0.85% chance that it happens one or more times in any given year. There remains a (vanishingly small) chance that it happened on every single random draw during the year.
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoWait. Why is it 50c5? If you want to know how many ways you can roll triples with 3 dice, it isn't 6c3, right? There's 6 possible triple dice combinations and there are 6^3 possible dice combinations, so it's 6/(6^3). If you wanted to know the odds of rolling 3 dice in order, you could roll: 1, 2, 3 OR 2, 3, 4 OR 3, 4, 5 OR 4, 5, 6 - which is 4/(6^3) - which is not 6c3. Why is it different with the lottery? Or did I get the dice wrong? Or are you calculating that the balls can be drawn in any order?
- brandmeyer 6y agoBalls drawn in any order, without replacement. The probability of guessing all 6 balls in a single lottery is 1 in (50 ncr 6). So, the probability of losing is 1 - 1/(50 ncr 6). The probability of losing every time is (1 - 1/(50 ncr 6)^(n_games), where n_games = 365 * 1000. Therefore, the probability of winning at least one game is (1 - (1 - 1/(50 ncr 6)^(n_games)).
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoGot it. 50c6 is the total combinations. But there's more than 1 combination of 6 ascending balls, right? Why is it 1 in (50c6) instead of 45 in (50c6)?
- brandmeyer 6y agoOh, sure. There's a number of different suspect or convenient sequences out there. All of the evenly-spaced sequences could be considered suspicious if you go broadly enough. A detail I tried to add back in up-thread: The sixth ball is from a separate pool of 20 balls. So 50c5 * 20 is the total number of possible draws, and there are 14 directly in-order sequences. But the main point was the methodology. (1 - (1 - chance_of_sequence)^(n_draws)).
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoThanks! Why are there only 14 in-order sequences?? Couldn't there be 1 2 3 4 5 6 AND 2 3 4 5 6 7 AND 3 4 5... Doesn't this give you 45?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- smallnamespace 6y agoThat seems right, 1 * 1/49 * 1/47 * 1/46 * 1/45 * 5! * 1000 * 365 gets about 8 occurrences per year.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoThere are two very different questions: 1. How often does this happen? This is a question about expected value, and the answer could be anything zero or above. 2. What are the chances that this will happen within a year? This is a question about probability, and the answer must lie between zero and one. There is no such thing as "a 775% chance it would happen yearly".
- smallnamespace 6y agoThose two questions are closely related here by a very simple transformation: if the expected number of occurrences is N over many independent tries, then probability of 0 occurrences is approximately 1-e^(-N), or 99.96% if N=7.75. Note that for N close to 0, 1-N is also a good approximation to 1-e^(-N). For large N, it's generally more convenient to talk about the expectation rather than the probability of 0 hits—I'm sure many readers implicitly converted 775% to the expectation in their heads.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> I'm sure many readers implicitly converted 775% to the expectation in their heads. Most people cannot do this correctly; the most obvious interpretation of a "775% chance" is that it represents a 25% chance of seven occurrences and a 75% chance of eight occurrences, with no other possibilities. The problem gets even worse when you have expectations less than one. If the expected number of occurrences is 80%, what are the odds of getting any occurrences at all? They're less than 80% as long as it's possible to have more than one occurrence.
- listenallyall 6y agoyou skipped 1/48
- crazygringo 6y agoSure, sorry. I'd used: 2*(1/49)*(1/48)*(1/47)*(1/46)*365*1000*(45/50) = 12.9% The initial "2" term is for consecutive numbers going both directions, and the final (45/50) term is to account for the fact that if you start with 4 or less and decreasing, or 46 or greater and increasing, you'll run out of numbers. Edit: but if the numbers don't have to be drawn in order (e.g. 8-5-9-6-7 is OK), then the odds are much higher still: 2*(4/49)*(3/48)*(2/47)*(1/46)*365*1000 = 344.5% (With the initial "2" term accounting for 4 consecutive numbers on either side of the initial pick -- though I'm not sure I've got that entirely right?) Then it would happen three to four times a year. Even with a 6th ball drawn separately out of 20, that's still a 17% chance happening somewhere in the world in a year, given 1,000 daily draws.
- bweitzman 6y agoFYI 0.129 = 1 / 7.75. I think you and person you're responding to are doing the same calculations, but inverted.
- kbenson 6y agoOh. I assumed consecutive numbers, but not necessarily consecutive on each pull. That is, 1,2,3,4,5 is no different than 2,3,4,5,1 in my calculations, which makes the possible ways got get consecutive numbers at the end quite a bit higher. Still not positive I got it right, but at least I know it shouldn't match your results, as they are for slightly different things. :) Edit: What I did was take all the possible combinations of 5 balls (5!) by the number of different sets that could be drawn (50-5, based on lowest number), over the total possible draws (50!). I think perhaps what that does it not account for overlap between sets (1-5 and 2-6), inflating the number somewhat, which is why it's a bit more than twice the probability than you got for any possible sequence of 5.
- ALittleLight 6y agoUnless I'm doing something wrong here - just typing some javascript into the console gives me... function rn() { return parseInt(Math.random() * 100); } function drawing(){ let result = [rn(), rn(), rn(), rn(), rn()]; return result.sort(); }; function sequential(arr){ for(let i = 0; i < arr.length-1; i++){ if(arr[i] + 1 != arr[i+1]){ return false } } return true } let counter = 0; for (let i = 0; i < 10000000; i ++){ if (sequential(drawing())){ counter ++; } }; console.log(counter); 16 Mathematically, it seems like you'd need to draw one of five numbers from the range, then one of four numbers, then one of three... so the likelihood would be 5/100 * 4/100 * 3/100 * 2/100 * 1/100 = 0.000000012. Although those odds don't seem to line up with the javascript I posted.
- OJFord 6y ago> I'm getting something like 775% chance it would happen yearly, but that seems too likely, In probability, when you roam outside of the 0-1 (or 0-100%) range, you can guarantee with 775% certainty that something went wrong somewhere. ;)
- robbintt 6y agoThat’s not necessarily accurate if you are already operating in probability per year in this case. It just means 7.75 occurrences per time.
- rubidium 6y agoNope. Bad maths. Average of 7.75 per year !== >100% of it happening at least once in one year. There’s still some chance it doesn’t happen in one year.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- OJFord 6y agoYou can have an expected value E[X] = 7.75 You cannot have a probability P[X ≥ 1] >1. There is no 'probability per year' (if it were meaningful year would have to be <1 for a >1 result anyway) - that time frame is built into 'X', it's 'inside' the probability.
- free_rms 6y agoBut OP didn't use either of those terms, they used "775% chance per year", which you can interpret colloquially as a speaker of English. It's been clear throughout this thread what was meant.
- a1369209993 6y ago> "chance per year", which you can interpret Probably something like reciprocal half-life; 775% / yr is about 1 / 1.5 month ie, happens about once every month and a half.
- RobRivera 6y agoProbability is a 0-1 range
- brlewis 6y agoLumping all world lotteries together introduces a lot of handwaving, so let's start with what we know and work forward. According to the article, this event happened for South Africa Powerball, where 5 numbers are chosen out of 45, and 1 number chosen out of 20: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_African_National_Lottery#PowerBall https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_African_National_Lottery... That same Wikipedia page does some of the math for us: The chance of one combination being chosen is 1/42,375,200. So if we count all possible sequential combinations, N, we'll know that the chance of a single winning combination being sequential is N/42,375,200. Say the powerball comes out as any number 6 <= M <= 20. There are 6 ways the numbers 1-45 could be picked such that M is part of the sequence. That's 90 ways total. If the powerball is 5, there are only 5 ways, same continuing down to a powerball of 1 where there's only 1 combination of numbers 1-45 where it could be part of the sequence. 90 + 5 + 4 + 3 + 2 + 1 brings us to 105 as our N. So this single event had a probability of 105/42,375,200, or 1/403,573. This means that for similar lotteries one would expect to see a sequence after about 200,000 picks. EDIT: If you only count events where the powerball is the high number, as happened this time, N goes down to 15, making the odds 1/2,825,013, so one would expect such a sequence after about 1.4 million picks.
- ouid 6y agothere are 6 balls drawn in the example, which would drop that number down to .26%, which would be once every 400 years. I didn't check the rest of your math though.
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoCool, as a rough approximation, it is close to (1/50)^6, right? But couldn't the first ball be any ball? That doesn't really matter. So wouldn't it just be 1/50^5 for 6 balls? And wouldn't the odds really be: p = (1/49 * 1/48 * 1/47 * 1/46 * 1/45) for the balls to be drawn in order in one lottery? The odds for them not to be drawn in order are then: 1 - p. If there are 1000 lotteries per day, the odds it doesn't happen in a year are: ynp = (1-p)^(365 * 1000). The yearly probability would be: 1-ynp. If the balls can be drawn in any order, but they have to end as 6 ascending balls - then I think the probability is much higher, right?
- naniwaduni 6y ago> Cool, as a rough approximation, it is close to (1/50)^6, right? But couldn't the first ball be any ball? That doesn't really matter. So wouldn't it just be 1/50^5 for 6 balls? It's very, very far, between non-replacement (~1.36x), order (5!=120x), the fact that final ball is out of 20 instead of out of 50 (2.5x), and the number of possible sequences which would be notable (at least 16x, but actually probably a fair bit more because recognizable patterns are pretty broad). The upshot of which is that estimating at 50^6 is off by multiple orders of magnitude...
- jonahx 6y ago> Cool, as a rough approximation, it is close to (1/50)^6, right? No. 50^6 is about 938x bigger than (50 choose 6), which is the correct chance of picking 6 of 50 numbers. > And wouldn't the odds really be: p = (1/49 * 1/48 * 1/47 * 1/46 * 1/45) for the balls to be drawn in order in one lottery? This is not correct either. There are 45 sequential possibilities of winning numbers: 1-2-3-4-5-6, 2-3-4-5-6-7, ... 45-46-47-48-49-50. So "45 / (50 choose 6)", about 647 times more likely than that calculation for p. Of course, if you start adding in other striking patterns like 2-4-6-8-10-12, the chance of a "fishy" draw becomes more and more likely.
- BMSmnqXAE4yfe1 6y agoThere are 6 numbers, so it's not a 5 out of 50 lottery. 5 out of 50 means every 42000th tickets wins, which is a very high number, and can only be used in a lottery with small prizes. Of course, there are many lotteries for small prizes, for example there are millions of rounds of roulette plays occurring daily, and of course it's pretty often to have 2,3,4,5 and 6 occurring in sequence on some roulette table somewhere during a day. The phrase "1000 a year" relates to large national lotteries, where probabilities are much much smaller, it's about 1/250mln for US megamillions lottery, for example. So for 1000 of 1/10mln lotteries this will happen once every 273 years. I would say the probability of a foul play is high enough to warrant an investigation.
- Widdershin 6y agoIf someone was going to rig the outcome, why would they make it such a conspicuous number?
- BMSmnqXAE4yfe1 6y agotrue ... might be an innocent mistake too.
- jamesrcole 6y agomistake? As far as I can see, it could only be either intentional or the result of randomness.
- jtbayly 6y agoIt could also be an attempt to rig gone bad
- jamesrcole 6y agoSure. I’d call that the result of an intentional action, but maybe that’s just personal preference.
- 6y ago
- tyingq 6y ago"Does anyone have any idea how many daily "official" lotteries are drawn worldwide?" https://www.gamblingsites.org/blog/how-many-different-lotteries-are-in-the-world/ https://www.gamblingsites.org/blog/how-many-different-lotter... Looks like a reasonable analysis. Their total is 180.
- Freak_NL 6y agoAre those lotteries with daily drawings though? They seem to list lotteries, but not specifically those with daily drawings.
- BlackFingolfin 6y agoAt least those I know in Europe and US are weekly...
- a1369209993 6y agoAssuming for simplicity that it's 6d50; you'd get 6 numbers ascending or decending: You have: 50^6 / (50*2) / (1000/day) You want: yr * 427.79832 about once every 4 centuries.
- naniwaduni 6y agoIt turns out 50^6 is much, much bigger than C(50,5)*20 (as the article implies), by about 400x.
- sturmeh 6y agoIf it's 5 specific numbers drawn from a pool of 50 in any order, we're talking 2118760 combinations of numbers that can be drawn, i.e. a 0.0000472% chance. For 5 drawn in a specific order from a pool of 50, we're talking about 254251200 ways 5 numbers can be drawn, with a 0.0000004% chance. In this case it was actually 6 numbers, which is about 10x less likely to match a combination (orderless) and 50x less likely to match a permutation (with order).
- im3w1l 6y agoThe chance for six ascending balls in a single drawing. First definition. Let's count a sequence as ascending if the sorted set of drawn balls is ascending. E.g. 18,15,14,19,16 with a powerball of 17 would be counted as ascending. I found that it was easiest to start with the odd one out and work from there. The powerball can be chosen in 20 ways. If the powerball is 1, then the sequence must start at 1 (1 combination). If it is 2, then the sequence can start with either 1 or 2 (2 combinations), 3 means 3 combinations, 4 means 4 combinations. For 5 and above, there are 5 combinations (the upper part of the range has no similar issue, since the normal balls go all the way to 50). We get a total of 85 combinations. Now every combination of the 5 normal balls can be permuted in 5! ways, so we have 85 * 5! = 10200 ascending draws. The total number of possible draws are 50 * 49 * 48 * 47 * 46 * 20 = 5085024000. So the probability of an ascending draw is 10200 / 5085024000 ~= 2 in a million.
- hatsunearu 6y agoRandom but there was an incident where the lottery number was identical to last weeks', just out of sheer luck.
- mrb 6y agoThey draw 6 balls out of 50. There are C(50,6) = 15,890,700 possible draws (C(n,k) = binomial coefficient) 45 of the draws are made of 6 consecutive numbers (1-2-3-4-5-6, then 2-3-4-5-6-7, etc, until 45-46-47-48-49-50) A single draw has a 45 out of 15,890,700 chances of being 6 consecutive numbers A single draw has a probability of 1-(45/15,890,700) of NOT being 6 consecutive numbers Assuming 1000 draws (lotteries) per day, in a year we expect probability (1-(45/15,890,700))^(1000*365) = 36% that none of the lotteries draw 6 consecutive numbers So there is a 64% probability that at least one lottery will draw 6 consecutive numbers in a year. If there are 1000 draws per week (instead of per day) the probability is still 17% that this will happen in a year. So this South African draw is kinda expected.
- dheera 6y agoNot to mention the reverse consecutive numbers, the same numbers, the +=2 numbers, the -=2 numbers, the prime numbers, and all the other sequences that people would find "suspicious" because "omgfwow that could never happen"
- computerphage 6y agoThese six numbers could've been drawn in any order.
- Freak_NL 6y ago5-10-15-20-25-30, 1-2-3-11-22-33; yeah there are a bunch more that people would find suspicious.
- listenallyall 6y agoWithout going into detail about why your math is flawed, which it is -- a basic viability check would be to consider: if there was a 64% probability of some event happening each year, don't you think in your lifetime you'd have seen quite a few instances of that thing happening?
- endtime 6y ago