3 ms·
Make phones that self-destruct all data if the device is handed over. It should be hardcoded to do so and that should not be an editable setting by the user. T
by dheera 6y ago
Make phones that self-destruct all data if the device is handed over. It should be hardcoded to do so and that should not be an editable setting by the user.
The primary reason for this would be against thieves, but it would work against courts as well, and the user wouldn't have a choice.
- colejohnson66 6y agoAgain. Destruction of evidence is a crime. Even if it’s not a choice for the user, the usage of such a feature would be a crime. And also again: the law and the courts don’t care about technicalities, no matter your opinion on that matter. People here are choosing to make things harder for themselves by coming up with ideas to skirt the law, but it doesn’t work and will only make the police go harder on you. The law (and precedent) is not on your side in this battle.
- gowld 6y agoAre you sure? This is a nuanced issue. Ehat counts as "usage". Intentionally destroying evidence is a crime, but broadly automatically destroying data before you have any knowledge of an allegation is not. (Otherwise, thinks lke GDPR would be illegal in the US)
- colejohnson66 6y agoWe’re talking about depositions, so the knowledge of an investigation followed by destruction of the data (whether intention or not) by handing the device over would be a crime. I can’t hand my phone over to the police and remote wipe it with iCloud, for example. Destruction when handing to a mugger is still ok.
- dheera 6y agoWell it wouldn't be the user destroying data. Judge: "Hand over that phone right now" You: "Sure, I can hand it over, but all data will then get wiped by the device automatically due to Google/Apple/Samsung's anti-theft design and I don't have a choice" After that it's upto the Judge whether to proceed with the handover or not. It will be the judge who destroyed the data if so.
- inetknght 6y agoLet me know how that goes for you if you ever have the unfortunate opportunity to try it.
- colejohnson66 6y agoAs I said before: technicalities don’t work. You’re not getting out of this. If you told the judge that, he’d change his order to hand over the data in a different way. Have fun sitting down with the police while they copy all of the data off by hand while you show them each item.
- astrange 6y agoJudges don't appreciate clever tricks of any kind, and neither does the law. Anything you think of that sounds like a clever trick is not something you should actually try.
- dheera 6y agoNo, it wouldn't even be my trick. It would be a feature of the design of the phone and I, the user, would not even have a choice in that implementation. The primary motive of that design would be against thieves, but it would incidentally happen to work on judges as well. The owners of the phones would have no choice.
- colejohnson66 6y agoIt doesn’t matter. Judges don’t care and they have very broad authority to get what they want. You’re not getting off on a technicality. It’s that simple.
- dheera 6y agoWell I wouldn't have a choice, so it wouldn't matter. They can get angry at the phone manufacturer instead of me.
- 6y ago