4 ms·
Your viewpoint is only sensible if one is neutral or negative toward capitalism and assumes everyone else must be as well. If you think capitalism is a good thi
by chc 16y ago
Your viewpoint is only sensible if one is neutral or negative toward capitalism and assumes everyone else must be as well. If you think capitalism is a good thing, then of course something being at odds with it is problematic.
- m0nty 16y ago"If you think capitalism is a good thing, then of course something being at odds with it is problematic." Something can be problematic but that still doesn't make it a bad idea. It might be a brilliant idea which challenges you to modify your viewpoint - perhaps you end up questioning the particular form of capitalism which you think is good. Perhaps you end up endorsing your former viewpoint and discarding the new idea. hasenj's point is perfectly valid: "If an idea is at odds with capitalism, that doesn't necessarily make it a bad idea" (even if it might be problematic).
- hasenj 16y agoEven if you think it's a great idea; it's still possible to be ok with new good ideas even if they happen to be at odds with capitalism. For instance, I think Open Source is a great idea, but this alone is not good enough reason to think that selling iPhone apps is evil. Acting very cautious and defensive around capitalism makes it look like a holy untouchable ideology; this is what annoys me.
- olalonde 16y agoAgain, Open Source is not at odds with capitalism. Capitalism doesn't mean making money or selling stuff. In fact, charities aren't at odds with capitalism. Did you know that Wikipedia's founder, Jimmy Whales, is a libertarian?
- hasenj 16y agoAh careful. RMS's Free Software is not the same thing as Open Source. Open Source in and of itself is not at odds with capitalism. But Free Software is at odds with some ideas of capitalism. (In my humble opinion anyway, which is really irrelevant to my original point).
- dfox 16y agocan you point out the difference between "free software" and "open source" that causes one being at odds with "some ideas of capitalism", while other is not? Apart from "free software" being connected with RMS's ideology.