3 ms·
Nobody wants to run their own servers. Period. You absolutely, positively will not get widespread adoption of any process that involves Docker, DNS, or anything
by jfengel 6y ago
Nobody wants to run their own servers. Period. You absolutely, positively will not get widespread adoption of any process that involves Docker, DNS, or anything that involves more than a single click. Nobody wants to handle backups, upgrades, or move hardware.
You might, maybe, be able to get a federated system, whereby people could sign up for major providers that all talk to each other. And that could include being your own provider. For most people, that would be no harder than signing up for Facebook.
Now you just need to give them a reason, and no, nebulous "privacy" isn't going to cut it. Nor is "portability". If anything, the easier it is to move your data around, the more it's going to seem like picking one provider over another is a waste of their time.
The whole point of social networking is networking. People want to connect. "Private social networking" is a contradiction in terms. There's little motivation for people to take control of their social networking, and they're happy to put up with the mediocre privacy controls because the vast majority of the time they want to be more public, not less.
- rektide 6y agoRight now all that ops stuff is a pain in the ass, and most everyone does it differently, and when you do do it, you get something that resembles a walled-garden social intra-net platform, but decentralized. I strongly believe it can be cool to run systems again. And that we can be good at it. We are only just emerging operational paradigms that span multiple concerns, where-as historically the panolopy of concerns each needed their own daemon, their own configuration, their own tending, and there was no common operational paradigm. That, finally, is changing. Still more fantasy than real but I do think we are starting to pave some of the cowpaths, & build a realistic, practical, well-trod path for running your own private cloud. What remains is to make that fun. Pretend the ops box is ticked, what now? NextCloud is like the most advanced all-in-one suite you can do for yourself, and it's pretty cool, but it's still kind of this big monolithic jumble of PHP features. It's it's own point of of presence on the web, containing a lot of things. But I don't think it's enough. ActivityPub & federation presents some good interesting grounds we can begin to inter-network on. But it's still just a start. Ultimately I think a lot of computing itself needs to be re-imagined to be networked-by-default, with good underlying general paradigms to build specific systems atop. We have a lot of exploration to go before we start to understand what that looks like. But, with good & sensible paths to home clouds (even just a raspberry pi), I think starting to make our personal computing also networked computing, & then internetworked computing, is what will topple the remote, far-off walled gardens that we commute to to compute on today.