3 ms·
> Is it like this across USA? The person you replied to isn't in the USA. That said, broadband costs are inversely correlated with population density, more or
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
> Is it like this across USA?
The person you replied to isn't in the USA.
That said, broadband costs are inversely correlated with population density, more or less. In most (but not all) US cities fast, reliable broadband is easy to come by. Obviously you can find one-off complaints here and there from people who have exceptions, but the general situation isn't as dire as the edge cases.
> I have a 350mb/15mb connection for £50($66)
For comparison, I have 1000Mbps for about the same price in a medium sized US city. I have friends in other US cities who pay more than you for less bandwidth, though. It just depends on the location.
> In the UK...
The challenge with the USA is that we have a lot of land, some of which is very sparsely populated. We have 10 different states that each have more land area than the entire UK. For example, Texas is almost 3 times the size of the UK, but has half the population. It's a challenge to get high speed infrastructure everywhere, and another challenge to keep it updated every decade as speeds advance.
That's where Starlink shines: The sparsely populated areas where running high speed infrastructure to everyone is prohibitively expensive.
- Jugurtha 6y agoGranted, I don't live in a big city (only about 5 million people), and yes, you can get stable internet. But not 1Gbps.. I also move between three or four places and I want consistency. The extreme case I talked about was in the mountains. However, the coverage was good, but the "internet" sucked. It is this that's infuriating. You never know. Sometimes, you have 30Mbps on mobile, sometimes you have 120kbps. If there's no consistency, you can't forecast. You can't rely on something like that. The operations part also sucks. So, given the unreliability and the inability to be consistent, I'll just sprinkle places with StarLink terminals and have one thing fewer to think about.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sandworm101 6y ago>> The challenge with the USA is that we have a lot of land Ya, try being in Canada. Take those problems and multiply them by 10. Then look at the Starlink satellite inclinations. The first 1400, the bulk of the system, won't even get to where I am standing at the minute (54* latitude). Starlink targets at very specific markets. It is not the globe-spanning uber-ISP that many think it to be.
- trothamel 6y agoThat doesn't seem right - the Starlinks go up to 53.8 degrees. That means that you should have quite a few satellites above your horizon, once that first shell is finished. After that, later satellites will be at 70 and 97.6 (retrograde) inclination, so the entire world should be covered upon completion.
- sandworm101 6y agoJust having sats at an inclination is not enough. It is a numbers game. How many are visible at any one moment, and their slant ranges, at a particular spot dictates available bandwidth. Also: the number of hops to the nearest downlink station. This is a massive structure of sat and ground installations. What we are seeing now is a system that goes just north enough to cover london, leaving much of the north un/underserved.
- grecy 6y agoIt's coming, have patience. The beta has already started in Canada, and they are launching more sats every month.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Retric 6y agoLast mile is expensive, but that’s just a question of local population density. Network backbones are relatively cheap making total land area mostly a meaningless limitation. 4x land area increases average distance between cities by ~2x so that doesn’t change much. Thus while truly rural areas are an issue wiring every suburb and midsized town in the US is roughly as difficult as the UK. The difference mostly comes down to corruption as the US government heavily subsidized network deployments, but without any requirement they actually build networks. Add a lot of anticompetitive legislation in the US and things really slowed down. It’s slowly gotten better over time, but many areas still have terrible internet availability. PS: I pay ~66$ per month for 20/20 and live in a 22 story building so density isn’t the issue.
- hirundo 6y ago9Mbps download / 0.84 Mbps upload here in the boondocks of New Mexico. And that's the recent new faster speed. Just got the bill: $110.60 last month, which is normal. I plan to buy Starlink as soon as they'll sell it to me.