8 ms·
> One reason that short-term rentals have been cheaper than hotels is because hotels had to collect and pay sales tax while Airbnb didn’t. Seems like this isn’
by arcticbull 6y ago
> One reason that short-term rentals have been cheaper than hotels is because hotels had to collect and pay sales tax while Airbnb didn’t.
Seems like this isn’t a new tax from out of nowhere to disadvantage Airbnb but rather a policy designed to bring Airbnb in line with their peers.
It reads like Airbnb was put at an artificial advantage as compared to hotels because hotels had to charge sales tax. Now everyone does. Seems fair to me. What seems unfair is that they weren’t subject to this the whole time. Honestly surprised it’s not retroactive.
- esc_colon_q 6y agoFixing a bad law is fine, but you can't propagate that back just because you wish you'd thought of the edge cases then. Or at least you shouldn't, if you have any sense of fair play...
- arcticbull 6y agoIn Canada ex post facto laws are prohibited in the charter of rights and freedoms for criminal matters only - and this isn’t an absolute prohibition either. They are permitted for civil matters. It’s an interesting thought exercise, and fairness would in my sole opinion be based on whether they knew they should have been paying the whole time and were getting away with it. It won’t happen, though.
- usrusr 6y agoLegislative changing laws, that should definitely not apply retroactively, even if sometimes this is very painful. Executive fixing application of laws that haven't been applied correctly in the past however is an entirely different story. If laws oblige you to pay taxes you are obliged to pay wether they have been collected or not. Not much different from a crime being a crime wether you are caught or not. Unless of course there's also a law that states an equivalent of "taxes not collected within the first $n $timeunit are waived".
- syshum 6y agoThe problem with that is the AirBnB never owed the tax in the first place. Either the Host does, or the Consumer of the service does, AirBnb would just be collecting and remiting that on behalf of the parties
- Sanzig 6y agoDepends on the jurisdiction, but most wouldn't put this on the consumer. In most jurisdictions, if a merchant neglects to collect sales tax when the sale is made, it's out of their pocket - not the customer.
- DanBC 6y agoTax law is a bit more complicated. Tax law is what's written in statutes, but it's also how the courts interpret the law. This means there's stuff that's clearly lawful, stuff that's clearly unlawful, and then a grey area where reasonable people can interpret the law in different ways and we need the courts to rule. This works well when you have cases that go to court. But some tax authorities prefer a light-touch or right-touch regulatory approach, and so they prefer to persuade people to pay tax that's owed and they leave court cases for the blatant offenders. That means we don't get the case law.
- rootsudo 6y agoEx post facto.
- freeone3000 6y agoIs legal in Canada. I'm honestly surprised it wasn't applied here, because it's clear that tax should have been paid by analogy, even absent a direct law.
- calyth2018 6y agoI disagree. What's being explicitly applied is the federal and provincial sales tax. Airbnb and the hosts were selling a service without collecting the sales tax. Someone was tax evading, and someone owes the CRA back taxes.
- buran77 6y ago> was put at an artificial advantage as compared to That makes up most of the "disruption" lately. Companies discover that they can exploit some legal loophole by claiming "but technology" and get an upper hand over classic competitors. By the time they're forced to follow the same rules, or (less likely) the law is relaxed for everyone else, they already have a healthy head start and can either claim that they're being treated unfairly, or that they're better than everyone else.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoMy reading of that article was that tax liability hasn’t changed at all. The Airbnb hosts were always liable for paying all of their taxes, including whatever sales taxes they were liable for. This change means that Airbnb are now responsible for collecting that sales tax and paying it to the government on behalf of their hosts. Whatever opinion you have about that, it doesn’t seem to be addressing any sort of loophole. It’s not a new tax, it’s just a new regulation for collecting it.
- throwaway201103 6y agoThe biggest and most common "loophole" being "we don't need all the physical infrastructure" Amazon: we don't need to own retail stores or inventory Airbnb: we don't need to own hotel properties and employ managers and housekeepers Uber: we don't need to own cars and employ drivers Are there any examples of tech disruptors that are really displacing classic competitors only on the basis of tax loopholes?
- rob74 6y agoCan't think of any, but it's still fair to say that tax loopholes (and lack of other regulations that the established competitors are subject to, e.g. Taxi licenses) provide an additional advantage...
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoAmazon: We don't need to pay sales tax or look after our warehouse employees AirBnB: We don't need to pay sales tax or look after our hosts Uber: We don't need to pay sales tax or look after our drivers The sales tax problem is only a loophole in some territories. The "look after" part is a problem in all of them.