4 ms·
> The research would've been much shorter if Apple would actually provide researchers with debug symbols. I believe they're about to do this: https://www.theve
by CharlesW 6y ago
> The research would've been much shorter if Apple would actually provide researchers with debug symbols.
I believe they're about to do this: https://www.theverge.com/2019/8/8/20756629/apple-iphone-security-research-device-program-vulnerabilities https://www.theverge.com/2019/8/8/20756629/apple-iphone-secu...
- q3k 6y agoThese are just phones that you are officially permitted to attach a root shell and kernel debugger to, like to any other device that's not an iPhone. Researchers have been working around that for years by using private jailbreaks / exploits to get similar levels access, and with checkm8/ktrw you yourself can get similar access to any vulnerable iPhone 7/8/X. No sources or structure layout or symbols, so you're still stuck waddling through megabytes of compiled code to reverse-engineer everything from scratch. It's Apple drumming up absolutely nothing, and from my point of view it's mostly a PR stunt.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> It's Apple drumming up absolutely nothing, and from my point of view it's mostly a PR stunt. Well, I don't think it's quite "nothing". Newer phones don't have access to checkm8, and getting a private jailbreak or exploit working can be non-trivial. And in some cases, researchers may need to avoid reporting that exploit to Apple in order to keep using it. It's a good step. It's just not sufficient, especially given all the other restrictions.
- q3k 6y ago> And in some cases, researchers may need to avoid reporting that exploit to Apple in order to keep using it. And this will continue to happen until Apple just starts selling the damn things to anyone who wants them, instead of trying to gatekeep them to people who are playing by their ridiculous security disclosure rules.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoRight! It would solve so many issues! Put them on an unlisted page of your online store, charge a 50% markup over a normal iPhone, make the boot screen bright red, and do something ugly and obvious with the phone's exterior. Sure, some crazy people who aren't security researchers will probably buy them too and use them as daily drivers (I'd probably be one of them). So what? I don't understand why Apple feels the need to hold this stuff so close to their chest. Everyone in this scenario knows exactly what they're buying.
- CharlesW 6y ago> No sources or structure layout or symbols… Oh, that's a shame. The slide in the referenced tweet says, "advanced debug capabilities", so I'd assumed that's what it meant. I wonder what else that could mean?
- saagarjha 6y agoThe ability to attach a debugger to the kernel. No, really, that’s “advanced” for an iOS device, because normally you don’t get to do anything even close to that. You can’t even debug userspace processes that aren’t ones that you put there yourself (as a developer writing apps) on normal iPhones.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoAnd Google Project Zero won't get them. https://twitter.com/benhawkes/status/1286021329246801921 https://twitter.com/benhawkes/status/1286021329246801921 > It looks like we won't be able to use the Apple "Security Research Device" due to the vulnerability disclosure restrictions, which seem specifically designed to exclude Project Zero and other researchers who use a 90 day policy.
- ASalazarMX 6y agoGoddammit, 90 day policy and reasonable rewards would strengthen their security and gain the trust of their advanced users. For some reason this ridiculous restriction reminds me when Apple sued Samsung because their phones had round corners.
- ethbr0 6y agoApple sued Samsung because Samsung had aspirations of being Apple. Rounded corners are the after-the-strategic-decision legal justification.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoFrankly, I think Apple sued Samsung because Steve Jobs was still CEO at the time, and he sometimes acted emotionally instead of rationally.
- sneak 6y agoAdvanced users that want a secure device require devices that can be reinitialized to a known state without external input. This is no longer possible on any phone, tablet, or computer Apple sells: all require online activation with device-specific info. There is no way to put the device back into a known state offline or without Apple having an opportunity to tamper with it (or be forced to tamper with it).
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> This is no longer possible on any phone, tablet, or computer Apple sells It is still possible on all of their computers, just not their phones or tablets. Intel Macs (which are still being sold in large numbers) can always be wiped and restored from USB without an internet connection, and Apple Silicon Macs can do it if you set the boot-loader to "Reduced Security" mode.