4 ms·
Stupid question: Why do they decommission it instead of fixing it? It seems that it would be more work to build a new one.
by dheera 6y ago
Stupid question: Why do they decommission it instead of fixing it? It seems that it would be more work to build a new one.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- scollet 6y agoNot stupid. Also wondering this. Maybe it would be cheaper to use more efficient materials and engineering as well as perform another geo survey.
- petschge 6y agoReason 1: because they were afraid of it failing catastrophically just like what happened this morning. One person was on site (director of telescope operations Angel), but imagine what would have happened if a work crew was up in the structure working on cables during such a failure. Reason 2: They are not going to build a new one. NSF has tried to get rid of AO for a long time now.
- dheera 6y agoRe: Reason 1 Well sure, but a hypothetical new structure is also going to require cables, just hopefully a more reliable construction. So why not keep the dish for now, and consider rebuilding the cables in a more modern fashion, and with redundant cables?
- petschge 6y agoThe cables were (originally) redundant. There are actually replacement cables on the way from Germany right now. But after the one main cable failed earlier this year they noticed that all cables are MUCH weaker than previously thought. So there was (even before the collapse) no way of replacing the existing cables with the replacements. And yes that probably implies that they should have swapped out all cables years ago. But they didn't have the funding.
- dheera 6y ago> no way of replacing How did they build the cables in the first place? Couldn't they just snip the cables with a helicopter or unmanned drone with a flying chopsaw and string new ones as if it was a brand new construction? Basically I'm not understanding how it is impossible to replace something but it is evidently possible to build that something.
- kaikai 6y agoBeing unable to fix something you’re able to build isn’t unusual to anyone who has built a large and complicated structure. They had two different engineering firms look at it, and neither of them saw a safe path forward. It’s possible that repairing it was physically possible, but would have put people in harms way while they were, for example, detaching cables on an already unstable structure.
- dheera 6y agoAre there not unmanned solutions to the problem? Drones with flying abrasive chopsaws? Literally strap a Dewalt circular saw onto a big enough drone with the power button taped down? Use a drone to attach a dynamite to the cable? It seems weird to me that the government can figure out how to remotely bomb a town but can't figure out how to remotely do a little snippy snip snip on a cable.
- bigbubba 6y agoFlying buzzsaws seems unlikely to work, but I don't think snipping the old cables would even be the hard[est] part. Installing new cables would almost certainly require workers to be present on the center platform, and it obviously wasn't safe for anybody to be there.
- Twisell 6y agoAlso this video can help realize the amazing scale of this thing: https://youtube.com/watch?feature=emb_title&v=QZAWqk-wrzc https://youtube.com/watch?feature=emb_title&v=QZAWqk-wrzc This was basically a whole building suspended into the air. Science or magic? Amazing engineering to be sure (but maybe not built with maintenance and security in mind)
- acqq 6y agoI'd like to know more about why "NSF has tried to get rid of AO for a long time now." Anybody knows something interesting and specific? What I was able to find was the Washington Post 2007 article, where it's mentioned that: "states with major observatories, such as New Mexico and West Virginia, have senators famous for their power over purse strings, some of whom are already gearing up to fight proposed cuts. By contrast, Puerto Rico, a commonwealth of the United States, has no senators. And its representative in the House" "does not have a vote." and "The cash crunch stems from a "senior review" completed last November at NSF." and ""The ambitions of the astronomy community for new things was far outstripping the capacity of the federal budget to cover them," said Wayne van Citters, NSF's astronomy division director, who organized the independent review" https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/09/08/AR2007090801654.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/0...