4 ms·
Maybe a bit off topic, but readability, readable, instapaper, etc - weren't user-defined style sheets supposed to address at least some of the issues these serv
by mgkimsal 16y ago
Maybe a bit off topic, but readability, readable, instapaper, etc - weren't user-defined style sheets supposed to address at least some of the issues these services are addressing? I ask because it seems that sometimes we get decent tech ideas (the idea behind CSS is good at least) but then we settle for half-baked implementations and don't pursue good user tooling. CSS specifically - no browsers have good ways of defining/saving/using custom stylesheets, yet this (IIRC) was a selling point of CSS back in the day. Had we had better browser support for this, we may have had a much different web than we do today.
As it is, people think it's really cool when there's those stupid 3 font size icons at the top of a page and they can 'resize' the page's fonts between 9, 11 and 13 point fonts (w00t!)
- tastefulwords 16y agoCouldn't agree more. If user defined style-sheets worked (and if content and presentation were truly separated) the web would be a much better place. When I was developing Readable, btw, I pretty much thought of it as a better implementation of user-defined styles. The text-parsing and main body text extraction is just my way of getting around the problem of content/presentation.
- mgkimsal 16y agoBTW, this wasn't a bash at you at all (if you took it that way). More a lament that we ended up in this chicken-and-egg situation. No point in making user-css tools because there's so much inline style and mixing, and no point in moving towards building sites with user-defined CSS in mind because there's no good support in browsers.
- tastefulwords 16y agoDon't worry, I didn't take it in a bad way. And I do, actually, completely agree with you; I thought that my comment made that clear -- but I do appreciate you making sure I didn't take offense; that kind of courtesy is rare. Back to our issue, though: if, tomorrow, browsers all got good enough at user-css that Readable wouldn't be needed anymore, I would gladly convert it into a one-page tutorial explaining to people how to set up their user-css :)
- mgkimsal 16y agoYeah, I was probably writing back more to assure anyone else reading it that I wasn't bashing you :) Thanks for some great work, by the way!
- tastefulwords 16y agoYou are most welcome. It was -- and still is -- my pleasure.
- ajays 16y agoAwww..... group hug! :-)
- orionlogic 16y agoMost of those services provide additional utility which CSS doesn't provide: strip out content from other site distractions. But yes, sites should offer more reading options and usability tools to users. Or may be browsers?