4 ms·
The article is very passionate, and as a resident of the US, I don't have a lot of context here. Just wanted to dump out some of what I found when looking deepe
by andrewla 6y ago
The article is very passionate, and as a resident of the US, I don't have a lot of context here. Just wanted to dump out some of what I found when looking deeper into this.
Apparently 10 major unions have called for a strike for somewhere between 11-13 points of demands [1][2][3], though all sources seem to say "12 point charter of demands". Here are the 13, the first and the last are sometimes included and sometimes not:
0 (possibly just a preamble?): Urgent measures for containing price-rise through universalisation of public distribution system and banning speculative trade in commodity market
1 Containing unemployment through concrete measures for employment generation
2 Strict enforcement of all basic labour laws without any exception or exemption and stringent punitive measures for violation of labour laws.
3 Universal social security cover for all workers
4 Minimum wages of not less than Rs 15,000/- per month with provisions of indexation
5 Assured enhanced pension not less than Rs.3,000/- p.m. for the entire working population
6 Stoppage of disinvestment in Central/State PSUs
7 Stoppage of contractorisation in permanent perennial work and payment of same wage and benefits for contract workers as regular workers for same and similar work
8 Removal of all ceilings on payment and eligibility of bonus, provident fund; increase the quantum of gratuity.
9 Compulsory registration of trade unions within a period of 45 days from the date of submitting application; and immediate ratification of ILO Conventions C 87 and C 98
10 Stoppage of Pro Employer Labour Law Amendments
11 Stoppage of FDI in Railways, Insurance and Defence
12 (some documents omit this one) In addition to these the central trade unions are also demanding the withdrawal of the Land Acquisition amendment bill/ordinance.
It appears that there are 11 central unions [4], and all but one have called for a strike [5], at least as of January 2020, though it's unclear if that is still the situation.
[1] http://citucentre.org/389-12-point-charter-of-demands-of-joint-trade-union-movement http://citucentre.org/389-12-point-charter-of-demands-of-joi... has 11 points, but maybe the introduction is a 12th?
[2] https://www.jornalet.com/documents/12-demandas.pdf https://www.jornalet.com/documents/12-demandas.pdf has 12
[3] http://citucentre.org/component/k2/75-12-point-charter-of-demands http://citucentre.org/component/k2/75-12-point-charter-of-de... has 13 lines
[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trade_unions_in_India https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trade_unions_in_India
[5] https://www.business-standard.com/article/economy-policy/why-labour-unions-have-called-for-a-nationwide-strike-on-wednesday-120010700459_1.html https://www.business-standard.com/article/economy-policy/why...
- DishankZala 6y agoFor a resident of US and who doesn't have much context in the ground reality, your beautiful articulation of demand of FDI stoppage and others, seems a deliberate attempt a spreading misinformation. Now even hacker news is not a tool in left idealogy.
- yorwba 6y ago> your beautiful articulation of demand of FDI stoppage and others, seems a deliberate attempt a spreading misinformation. It's just copy-pasted from the sources they link, not their own "beautiful articulation". Accusing other users of deliberately attempting to spread misinformation is against the HN guidelines, by the way.
- andrewla 6y agoAs the other reply noted, I'm just copying and pasting from the other sources. I'm not even sure what "FDI stoppage" is -- I've only just started looking at the issues here, and for what it's worth, I'd love to hear more about what FDI is, and why some people want it stopped, and why you feel that it is problematic. I can search to get more information here, and I've been working my way through the list trying to figure out exactly what the context is for each demand, but having someone provide context inline here would make for a more interesting discussion.
- manquer 6y agoSadly even a cursory google search is now construed as astroturfing. The ability of people to do basic research or recognize
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoSadly, at least one person construes a google search as astroturfing. Currently that one person is downvoted, though, so... maybe it's not so bleak as you think.