4 ms·
We need to adopt similar strategies for getting e.g. green energy production off the ground. Thinking of things like solar panel production.
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
We need to adopt similar strategies for getting e.g. green energy production off the ground. Thinking of things like solar panel production.
- moftz 6y agoExcept there is money to be made in the green energy industry. There's no money to be made building a giant radio telescope. Sometimes corporations have a need for scientific institutions and their patronage helps keep the lights on but I really can't think of any way that can apply to something meant to stare at the stars. What could help is designing a radio telescope that have both scientific use and military use like China's telescope in Argentina. You have one user willing to pay plenty for time on it and another user that is just happy to get some work done.
- jbay808 6y agoAs proof of your point, Arecibo was originally built as a military project with general scientific value as a bonus.
- skuhn 6y agoThere was a brief push by the government to encourage funding of things like Solyndra under Obama, but obviously that didn't all pan out. I think that putting substantial funding into making the US the world leader in climate change related technology is such an obvious slam dunk that it defies belief for me that there seems to be no political will to do it. Argue about the reality of climate change if you must, but the simple facts are that there is finite oil, finite coal, finite natural gas and the extraction and processing of those fuels is an expensive and dirty business. Of course solar, wind, hydro and nuclear don't compete yet -- how about putting in the same R&D money as fossil fuels? And when you make it work, the entire world will buy this tech from you. It could clearly be the US's next economic gold rush, after the Internet and post-WW2 manufacturing (and, I guess, the gold rush). I do wonder if the economic approach is just doomed to be a non-starter, and if the faster way is to frame it as a national security issue. That leads to a number of other problems, but time is clearly of the essence and they know how to spend money over there.
- spiritplumber 6y agoI was asked to do a bit of robotics consulting for Solyndra. I figured that it wasn't going to work out when the guy we talked to took us to a conference room that looked too nice, and admitted that he hadn't been on the production floor in the next building before me and my buddy asked to go check that out. We took the job anyway because it looked interesting, started doing the preliminaries, and when we went to get the test panels a couple weeks later, a FBI lady shooed us away from the parking lot as they were taping the building up. Very weird.
- skuhn 6y agoI think that Solyndra was specifically a terrible choice for the government to make an investment in, but it was exactly the type of industry they should generally be investing in. But I guess at least Seagate got a nice building out of it.
- blackrock 6y agoSeriously? Solyndra was being hailed as the pinnacle of American technology, during Obama’s era. When it closed up shop, people were blaming China, again, for stealing American technology, and putting another good American company out of business. But from your description, it sounds like Solyndra was a scam to part investors and the American government, with their money.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoI think skuhn put this nicely up-thread. There were both successes and misses, and investing is all about taking risks with the understanding not all of them will pan out. Apparently the program was profitable on net.
- skuhn 6y agoYeah, it was a little bit. [1] [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/08/solyndra-what-a-mess/446784/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/08/solyndr...
- 6y ago