5 ms·
Developing affordable, gene-based cures for sickle cell and HIV
- DoreenMichele 6y agoIn sub-Saharan Africa, millions of people suffer from sickle cell disease, and an estimated 50% to 90% of children born with the ailment die before the age of five. Bill Gates says he has a plan to cure it. Sickle Cell protects against malaria, which is also a horrible disease. The Gates Foundation hopes to do something about Sickle Cell in the next ten years and hopes to eradicate malaria in the next twenty (see below). I hope they decide this needs to be more of a coordinated effort. The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation has committed nearly $2 billion to antimalaria efforts, and Bill Gates has said he believes the disease can be wiped out by 2040. Malaria today is transmitted in ninety-five countries, accounting for nearly half of the world’s population. Eighty-nine percent of all reported cases are in sub-Saharan Africa https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/can-malaria-be-eradicated https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/can-malaria-be-eradicated
- HarryHirsch 6y agoLast year, a Hb polymerization inhibitor came to market: https://www.fda.gov/drugs/resources-information-approved-drugs/fda-approves-voxelotor-sickle-cell-disease https://www.fda.gov/drugs/resources-information-approved-dru... It's a remarkable breakthrough.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThank you. I searched for an explanation of what it does in layman's terms and found this: None of the currently approved drugs can modify the underlying pathology of the disease. Voxelotor, first of its kind, is an orally administered drug that can alter the underlying disease pathology (by increasing the affinity between Hb and oxygen) and inhibit sickling of red blood cells. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7100618/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7100618/
- waterhouse 6y ago> Sickle Cell protects against malaria I knew being heterozygotic for sickle cell helped. Does having two copies of the gene have a net benefit? ... Wiki seems to say no: "The protective effect of sickle cell trait does not apply to people with sickle cell disease; in fact, they are more vulnerable to malaria, since the most common cause of painful crises in malarial countries is infection with malaria." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sickle_cell_disease#Malaria_prevention https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sickle_cell_disease#Malaria_pr...
- DoreenMichele 6y agoYes, Sickle Cell trait exists in that area because it is protective. Sickle Cell Disease occurs when someone has two copies of the gene and having two copies goes bad places. Maybe I am missing something and the plan here is to leave Sickle Cell trait alone and only subject people with Sickle Cell Disease to what amounts to genetic experimentation. I find that ethically questionable, but perhaps there are people who think that makes sense. To me, fixing this means getting rid of the mutation. The mutation exists because it is protective. If you remove that protection without first removing the reason it exists, I find that also morally questionable. First, eradicate malaria from the region. Then eradicate the trait. You could reduce incidence of the disease dramatically without coming up with Frankensteinian medical experiments by testing everyone for the trait as a condition of getting a marriage license and trying to get carriers to stop breeding with other carriers. It would be a social intervention, not a medical intervention, and it's completely humane. Of course it wouldn't make headlines as being ooh, shiny new tech and some people would no doubt have a cow about it for some reason or other, like "What right do you have to tell me whom I can love?" But as someone with a different homozygous recessive disorder (who also has a child with the same thing), that was more or less my policy after I was diagnosed and was getting a divorce. I didn't wish to risk getting pregnant by a carrier again, so I did what I could to protect myself against that scenario.
- ampdepolymerase 6y agoYou are correct in understanding that the Gates foundation should clarify their timelines. I am not sure why you have been downvoted for this. The economic and health impacts of malaria versus sickle cell diseases ought to be decided by the individual. If the person has no plans to immigrate and if his or her country is stuck in a perpetual resource trap with no ability to combat malaria, then the cure (eradicating sickle cell anemia) may be more harmful than beneficial.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ampdepolymerase 6y agoTo clear up some misunderstandings before HN's web developer crowd gets too excited and starts throwing around scientifically inaccurate speculations: - Accurate and precise CRISPR-based, human non-germline in vivo cell editing at scale still has some ways to go. We are not at the stage (yet) where a couple injections will be able to completely rewrite your genome. Accuracy and precision has room for improvement. In vivo needs more research (the ethics concerns and controversies is a huge barrier for this). And finally scale, which I will address below. - A quick explanation of germline vs non-germline gene editing. Non-germline: change just the genes in the affected area. Germline: change the genes in the sex cells (or their product, the zygote) so that the change will be perpetuated. The Stanford professor's controversial editing of the Chinese twins was germline based. Non-germline is hard because you have many many cells and right now CRISPR is still not perfectly precise. Delivering CRISPR to every part of the organ/afflicted area is still not yet well understood. There was an article on HN a couple days ago on this. It was sensationalised and exaggerated but the point made is largely correct: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25096386 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25096386 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25096982 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25096982 - The technology that finally makes it to market may not be CRISPR at all. With the announcement two days ago by Deepmind, the field of proteomics, and by proxy biology, has been fundamentally changed. The impact to computational biology is akin to ImageNet overshadowing the Lisp/Prolog based expert systems, and their successors' decision trees. History has been written. The repercussions of that blog post is greater for humanity than the moon landing. You often see on HN people complaining how top minds and talent are now working on better ads systems and recognising cat photos instead of real hard tech. The cat photo recognition people just wrote their names in the biology textbooks of the future. Silicon valley loves anti-aging research. That Deep Mind blog post alone possibly added decades to our lifespan than any past effort by Aubrey De Grey et al. or the Methuselah Foundation. Biotech startups might actually be profitable now (hahaha)
- MayeulC 6y agoHere's something I keep wondering: isn't CRISPR part of the bacteria immune system against viruses? What prevents us from directly weaponising it agaist HIV or similar viruses? I guess the external membrane does, and CRISPR thus needs to be present inside of the cells before they become infected? Is the delivery mechanism once again the limiting factor?