6 ms·
Fuck grades. They were already a problem in universities and this is their final and worst form. University systems have the major problem that a significant
by colechristensen 6y ago
Fuck grades.
They were already a problem in universities and this is their final and worst form.
University systems have the major problem that a significant portion of students are only there for a degree, and their participation is playing the game in order to get that piece of paper, and the GPA number rating them.
The core of this problem is the question “will this be on the exam?”
Testing of course can be an important part of learning, but making that the metric by which you decide to hand out degrees substantially damages the value of testing as a teaching tool, and damages the value of a university as a place for research and learning.
Another way needs to be found to sort students into degree worthiness.
Raising humans for the first quarter of their lives in a dystopian police state is not what anybody should strive for. We need to figure out how to measure people less.
- schoolornot 6y agoGot a BS/MS in CompSci in my twenties when I was immature as a person, now doing online classes for a non-tech major. As an "adult student" the system seems 10x more broken than it was when I was a high school graduate. Being young and tuition-free it was easy to grind through the material just worrying about the next test in the next class. Now, here I am as a tricenarian trying to relax and understand hundreds of pages of anatomy material while everyone else seems to just binge seems so asinine. After 75 pages of reading, exams continue to be a black box. Here I am paying for instruction and the professors can't be bothered to tell me what's important to know for the career let alone the test. I got one teacher to chat off the record and he basically said to "get through it." What a disservice to students. Why are there still weeding-out classes? How many doctors, surgeons, programmers, engineers would there be in the world if it wasn't for these classes? The Montessori education system and the like seem so superior. College should be pass/fail.
- csa 6y agoI agree with a lot of your comment, and I basically think large swathes of education are just fundamentally broken for a variety of unfortunate reasons. That said, I would like to answer this question: > Why are there still weeding-out classes? In majors that are oversubscribed (e.g., pre-med, CS, etc.), these classes weed out the people who like the idea of the major/career more than the actual work involved. Good weeder courses (and I think that these exist) allow later classes in the major path to be more focused on the capable and motivated learners rather than baby-sitting the less-capable and less-motivated. There are two reasons why this is desirable: 1. There is no way that a department could get through the same amount of material if they had to accommodate the less motivated and less capable in all of the courses. 2. Your department will get a reputation in the field for having students who are capable of X, Y, and Z. Typically, if someone can't make it in the weeder classes at their school and they still want to enter that career path, then maybe it's better to go to a less competitive school. This sounds elitist, and maybe it is, but that's the workaround in our current system.
- jdmichal 6y ago> 1. There is no way that a department could get through the same amount of material if they had to accommodate the less motivated and less capable in all of the courses. This is the high-school-ification of university, and it's part of the problem. This is not mandatory learning / babysitting. Just stop accommodating them. Every class just moves at the pace it needs to move at, and if they can't keep up, so be it.
- jdmichal 6y agoFor my own notes into posterity, on further reflection, maybe the schools aren't accommodating. Maybe weed-out classes are hard because they're just moving at the pace they need to move at. But since they tend to be foundational classes, they have a lot of area to cover and so move relatively fast.
- csa 6y agoThis summary captures the intent of my comment accurately. I will add that the follow up classes can also move more aggressively since the weaker students have been culled by the required weeder course.
- Balgair 6y agoIt sounds like you are in a pre-med class? My SO once TA'd for a pre-med class. Holy hell, the students were something else as compared to other disciplines. They literally would not leave my SO's office until they had argued up their grades on every assignment. My SO had to get security to escort them out, I am not joking. If they forgot, say, to multiply by 2 and then got the answer wrong, they still argued for full credit despite the very clear error. There was no shame whatsoever. We figured the other Profs and TAs just didn't want to deal with them, so the pre-meds learned to just wait out the graders to get their grades. To be clear, this was maybe ~15% of the class, but still a lot of students. The Prof was no help with this either and just advised to pass them along. What a mess. I understand that med school admissions is about as cut-throat as it gets, but my lord! It's these pressure cookers that lead to MD burnout and mis-selection. After all those shameless hours in undergrad, then med school hell, you finally get to practice on people just looking for their preferred opioid. Sorry to hear about the mess you are in, but you are right, it's systemic.
- labcomputer 6y agoI experienced the same thing while TAing physics for biosciences for a few semesters (which was 90% pre-meds), though I never had to call security. One apparently needs close to a 4.0 GPA, plus many extracurricular volunteer hours to qualify for medical school, plus glowing letters of recommendation. I also overheard a number of stories about pre-med students intentionally sabotaging other students by misleading them to think that private group tutoring sessions (to study for the MCAT) had been canceled. That experience helped form my beliefs about the driver high cost of medical care in the US. Specifically, that there is no shortage of people who are willing and qualified to be medical doctors, but that doctors and medical schools collude to artificially limit the supply of credentialed medical doctors as a means to increase doctor salaries. As you alluded to, I think it also creates an adverse selection problem, where the people who become doctors are mostly not those with excellent diagnosis skills or bedside manor or ethics, but those who are the most cutthroat and desperate to get into a high-paying career.
- 908B64B197 6y ago> I also overheard a number of stories about pre-med students intentionally sabotaging other students by misleading them to think that private group tutoring sessions (to study for the MCAT) had been canceled. These aren't rumors. Pre-meds hate other pre-meds and are conditioned to play a zero sum game against one another. We then expect them to completely flip their attitude and become teams players. Collaborate with other medical professionals (former pre-meds), nurses and social workers. No wonder healthcare is so dysfunctional.
- Melting_Harps 6y ago> I got one teacher to chat off the record and he basically said to "get through it." What a disservice to students. Why are there still weeding-out classes? How many doctors, surgeons, programmers, engineers would there be in the world if it wasn't for these classes? The Montessori education system and the like seem so superior. College should be pass/fail. Honestly, that's typical of most Biology lower division courses. The theory goes 'if you cannot pass this, you have no chance of the MCAT.' which may be true but some of us had no desire to be a physician. Someone replied to such an absurd structure explained to me that's 'how the system works.' Many of us that finally passed would not have anything directly to do with medicine and would AT BEST be considered ancillary service status to Medicine, and we were not amused. I personally will only take Industry-centric certifications, and I will never consider going back for anything degree related. Google really is making the smartest move out of all the FAANG corps in that regard, by placing grater value on their own rather than degrees. With that said, that's really what its there to do, isolate those who can commit to high loads of dated and rather antiqued (my near College credit HS Biology graded us on Kingdoms as Domains were already well established in the University lectures I attended) rote learning the best and 'thining the heard' for the upper-divisions which were super-capped when I was in University as all fields in Biology were impacted. I at least thought now with Online learning being the default for so many it's sad to see the tech still hasn't solved this problem of mainly distribution/class seats. I think it's one of the 2 elite schools in the UK (Cambridge or Oxford) that have an actual in-person skill assessment for your final rather than a test and most of your grade depends on that. My Inorganic Chemistry professor said his final exams were always the most preferable, albeit impractical, way to go about it. As a regular at his office hour lectures, I wish I had the pleasure of seeing what that may have been like. > My SO once TA'd for a pre-med class. Holy hell, the students were something else as compared to other disciplines. Been there, seen that as a Biology major just trying to get my foot in the door to get a graded paper during office hours. It's really sad now that I think about it as an adult that left the Industry long ago, you have no idea the weight on those kids shoulders to make it pass the openly touted 'filter' process, be it self-imposed or from their family. Its a sad reality how few end up using it all in these 2 horrible job markets for young inexperienced graduates. My heart goes out to anyone who has to graduate in this Market, 2008 was bad but I think this may end up being worse as automation wasn't as big of threat as it was in 2008 as it is now in 2020 with COVID. PS: Also, its well known amongst Biology majors that adderall abuse doesn't just start in Medschool, its a well established habit by undergrad possibly even the HS level for some.
- foota 6y agoFwiw I went to a no-name state school and found university to be invaluable. Classes, schoolwork, and exams gave me something to focus on and build the skills that I use routinely today. I believe my school was fairly balanced wrt the reasonableness of work expected and exams, but was overall a fairly typical education. I guess some people will benefit more than others from the enforced structure.
- Ninjinka 6y agoI didn't see anything in his comment that implied university wasn't valuable.
- interestica 6y agoWhat's most insane to me with a degree system: Everyone who has the same 'degree' could have had wildly different classes. What's the point? Maybe we need to dial it back to more of a 'certificate' based approach? Instead of the letters-beside-your-name, list the completed certificates. And this also gives the opportunity to better upgrade skills in the specific problem area. And maybe it can encourage more interdisciplinary study.
- colechristensen 6y agoI don’t agree with this approach, the biggest value of a university degree is teaching someone how to think and learn in combination with some domain knowledge. Unless you are going for higher degrees, the specialization isn’t of prime importance. i.e. what one engineer/scientist/scholar learns within their field in undergrad compared to another is really not so important for their ability to do things related to that degree. You don’t need to be exclusively prepared for your exact job. We have accreditation boards to determine what is required for a common base.
- interestica 6y agoMaybe I wasn't totally clear, but I think we actually agree. To me, a focus on 'credit-based' system is about acknowledging that the boundaries of those domains are growing and changing. Gaining knowledge and expertise in one area can inform your work in another. The idea would be to broaden abilities, not focus on being 'exclusively prepared'. > the biggest value of a university degree is teaching someone how to think and learn in combination with some domain knowledge. I would add also: 'how to work', 'how to learn' and 'who to know'. By 'certs' I didn't just mean tech specializations. Courses can be about broader topics. A course on politics can be absolutely beneficial to an engineer. A more modular approach could also encourage lifelong learning rather than the "checkbox" that a degree satisfies. >We have accreditation boards to determine what is required for a common base. That's the problem. Those boards/requirements vary based on Universities and available instructors and resources. Yet, everyone comes out with the same degree.
- Analemma_ 6y ago> University systems have the major problem that a significant portion of students are only there for a degree, and their participation is playing the game in order to get that piece of paper, and the GPA number rating them. In defense of the students, they're just following the incentive gradient in front of them. For all the romantic notions about how college should be optimized for exploration and "real learning", only a small percentage of people actually want that. And that's fine! Not everyone needs to be that sort of person; you should be able to have a reasonably comfortable career even if you aren't. But the world is set up right now such that, without a university degree, you fall through the cracks and it's game over. In lots of high-earning jobs, a degree is either de jure required (law, medicine), or de facto required as most major employers won't look at you without one (finance, most tech stuff). So universities become degree mills because that's what the market demands, and students are only there so they can get a job afterward. To fix the universities, you have to fix the incentives.
- colechristensen 6y agoOh absolutely, little blame can be fairly put on students, though everyone participates in the system and deserves some (and eventually everyone responsible was a student themselves at one time). > To fix the universities, you have to fix the incentives Who better than the universities to drive change? That is sort of their fundamental purpose is it not? If you need to lead a university around with a carrot, it really has failed to be much of a university.
- jessaustin 6y agoIf we needed any more proof of how badly our universities have and continue to fail in their educational mission, the current year has provided it. There's no reason college students need to be on campus in a time of pandemic. Many schools have opened in order to "support sports" and for other asinine reasons, and then closed almost immediately. [0] Educational institutions that actually value education have cancelled athletic seasons completely. [0] https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2020/11/the-colleges-with-no-coronavirus/ https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2020/11/the-colle...
- 6y ago
- stevesearer 6y agoOne professor of mine let us bring books and notes into our written exams knowing that if you didn't actually do any of the readings or take any notes, those resources wouldn't really help you anyway. But if you had adequately prepared, the books and notes could really help you craft an excellent written response. In this scenario, it took the focus off memorizing things and instead focused on understanding the content and being able to communicate something worth reading.
- colechristensen 6y agoIn my engineering education my favorite and most productive learning came from the professor who assigned graded homework and provided fully worked solutions to the given problems before when the problems were assigned. You had to do them, you were completely able to just copy the solution, and when you were working on something you got immediate feedback as to whether you were doing it well. If you wanted to learn you could, if you didn’t you wouldn’t. The lack of a week or two of lag between solving a problem and figuring out if you had done it correctly really made a difference.
- DavidPeiffer 6y agoThrough a number of classes I took online and in person with online homework, the immediate feedback was the one thing I really appreciated. Statics is very much a class where the same basic concepts are applied tons of times in different ways, and you kind of need to see and do a lot of problems to get good. My professor had us do online homework with unlimited attempts, but we had to submit our hand written work as well. Even though that class was entirely online, I felt very confident applying what I learned on projects. The immediate feedback was 10x better than having the week or two of lag, and 9x better than having the answer on the back of the book because I never ran out of problems to try.
- gen220 6y agoI was a TA for the department head in CS, and he gave us free reign to handle grading and such however we felt was best. More important things to do, I guess :) We had Homework, Quizzes, and Tests, 33.33 each. Homework was graded like you said. Quizzes and Tests were open notes but on a relatively tight timescale. If people missed a homework, they could turn it in late for some linearly scaled penalty. If they missed a quiz or test question, they could come in and demonstrate/defend a solution off the cuff during office hours for 70% credit or something similarly high. Students loved it. They no longer had to stress about getting an A, and they could instead focus on understanding the material, since that was the easiest way to (eventually) get the points. I will say, though, this strategy was very time consuming for a large class. It also requires the TAs to have mastery of the material, which (shocker) is unfortunately not all that common.
- plif 6y agoYour last sentence nailed it: this is a society problem, not a university problem. It's insane how much emphasis is put on these measures by parents from a very young age. School boards here, and I'm sure many other places, decided to nix grades from March onwards after the pandemic hit. The announcement wasn't made until closer to the end of the term. I remember some parents being furious claiming that their kids "wasted their time" on remote school if a grade wasn't being assigned. I've had this discussion many times, and as a university drop out, my opinion has always been similar to yours. One thing I've learned is that debating the merits of the higher education system is right up there with religion and politics in terms of topics to avoid at a dinner party. People take great pride in their educations (read: pieces of paper). They can take great offense to the institutions and systems that produced those pieces of paper being challenged. These values have been passed on and hardened through generations. This is the first thing that needs to change before there's meaningful reform, and it's going to take time.
- brewdad 6y agoMy son is applying to universities now. Last spring he was taking 5 AP courses out of 8 required classes. The statewide decision to go to pass/fail cost him hugely in his weighted GPA, as he would have aced all 5 classes. Given that he attends a high school that is average at best, it really could have made a difference for him. Fortunately, he navigated the mess that was AP testing last spring and his test scores prove that he knew the material but as a parent who watched my kid work so hard, even through the remote learning portion, it was quite stressful for both of us. Now we wait to hear from the initial wave of applications. The system, as it stands, sucks but it is the system we have. Perhaps the great experiment starting with the class of 2021 may drive changes to make it better.