3 ms·
I think this illustrates the problems I have with these ML systems. Technology is supposed to make our lives easier. While surveillance may help catch more "bad
by godelski 6y ago
I think this illustrates the problems I have with these ML systems. Technology is supposed to make our lives easier. While surveillance may help catch more "bad guys" (clearly something we as a society argue over the definition of) it also causes many a lot of anxiety. One has to question if the added incrimination is worth the cost of anxiety to the public. Personally I do not think this is a good trade because even long before all this surveillance technology I felt safe in society. I believe most people did even in the 50's and 60's. So has the added surveillance really helped decrease crime? Or is it just correlated? (I'm not even convinced it is correlated).
As for tests, there is an easier solution to all this. Write your test as if it was a take home. Open notes. You can't stop people from communicating but often these types of exams/assignments it becomes clear who is doing it. In my undergrad all my upper division classes' exams were take home because "I can't test you on anything worthwhile in 2 hours." Honestly, most of us enjoyed these more. We often did the exams in the same room (we had the back of a building that was dedicated as a lounge to the physics students) and no one really cheated. The closest was "hey, I'm stuck on this problem and I know you are finished. Can I just use you as a rubber ducky?" (more like just explaining the problem to the person and the other person saying "uh huh" and no more) It also made me feel like an adult because our professors trusted us. As someone that frequently does poorly in a testing environment I was also surprised that I was able to get much higher scores on these tests despite the added complexity. The simple fact that I could "take a break and come back" was all the piece of mind I needed (or grabbing a beer when I felt frustrated). This also better reflected, in my opinion, what solving difficult problems were like in the real world. I could grab my book, go to the page that I know is helpful, sit and think, take of my shoes, pace, whatever. I was treated like an adult and it felt good.