4 ms·
This is getting really far off topic, but the solution is clearly to make speeding fines a "dollars per mile per hour, per hour" system. It should scale continu
by whatshisface 6y ago
This is getting really far off topic, but the solution is clearly to make speeding fines a "dollars per mile per hour, per hour" system. It should scale continuously both with speed over the limit and with time spent speeding. Programmers who focus on discrete systems are too prone to forget about real analysis. ;)
- mumbisChungo 6y agoThis is clearly not the solution, unless it is accompanied by changes to speed limits in North America- which itself introduces a bunch of complexity and negative side-effects.
- whatshisface 6y agoIt won't solve speed limits as a civic policy issue, but it does solve the specific thing the question was posed to ask: the morass of trouble created by trying to write discrete rules for continuous phenomena.
- radley 6y agoThe point is to immediately stop them from speeding and causing a big problem. Why is the world would you track them for miles or hours?? The ticket is merely an incentive to not do it in the future.
- waterhouse 6y agoSo, on a 65mph highway, driving at 66mph for an hour has the same fine as driving at 125mph for one minute? (Minus speedup and slowdown time.) Don't think a linear scale would make sense. I'm not sure if any scale would make sense, though. The true thing to be fined for should be "driving unsafely", of course, whether that means driving too fast, braking suddenly, swerving, changing lanes without warning, etc. The thing is, the unsafety of all those things depends in very large part on the cars around you and sometimes on the road. (Driving at 100mph on a straight, flat freeway with no cars nearby is safer than weaving between a bunch of 65-70mph cars to maintain a speed of 80mph.) But it would be really hard to come up with an objective algorithm to calculate how unsafe a rule violation is, and even harder to implement it without a vast array of cameras. So ... they implement an enforceable set of rules even if it's not a good one. (On a related note, it bothers me that driving with more than some arbitrary blood alcohol level is illegal, but driving after e.g. staying awake all night is not, even though the latter is worse[1]. Likely this is partly because checking BAC can be done fairly directly with cheap equipment, while checking how recently someone slept is... I dunno, there might be ways to mostly do that with good equipment, but I assume it's currently impractical.) [1] "Being awake for at least 24 hours is equal to having a blood alcohol content of 0.10%. This is higher than the legal limit (0.08% BAC) in all states." https://www.cdc.gov/sleep/about_sleep/drowsy_driving.html https://www.cdc.gov/sleep/about_sleep/drowsy_driving.html
- willhslade 6y agoMomentum based tickets. The heavier your vehicle, total passengers and load, the higher the fine.