3 ms·
There is a fallacy here. Yes, these things are cyclical, but rents are still not crashing to levels affordable to the working class. The bay area is getting the
by asdff 6y ago
There is a fallacy here. Yes, these things are cyclical, but rents are still not crashing to levels affordable to the working class. The bay area is getting the worst of both worlds: a crisis on the streets and, even despite recent decreases, rents unaffordable to normal working people. This is sort of unprecedented uncharted territory beyond the boom and bust cycles up until this point. The people you wrote about in the last paragraph still can't afford to get in, and it's not like there is a lot of work in, say, the restaurant industry right now to finance these side efforts.
- mapgrep 6y agoI wouldn't be surprised if the Bay Area remains on the whole more expensive after this boom than it was before the boom started. I'm pretty sure that's how it has historically worked. I don't profess to know how far things will fall. I will note that historically the busts take time to play out just like the booms do. Dot-com 1 burst around April 2000 but I don't think the rents fully bottomed out for nearly two years. Anyway you're right that things don't come back ever exactly as they were before. I just think more breathing room will open up.
- mepiethree 6y agoIntuitively this makes sense: Moving takes time. My wife and I have talked about moving almost every day since the pandemic started, but haven't done anything about it
- refurb 6y agoI don’t think rents have been “affordable for the working class” in SF since before the city’s revival in the 70’s. That’s why rent control was enacted. SF has always been an expensive city. If you look at historical data, a house was $200k back in the 1980’s, or about $650k today. So cheaper than now but nowhere close to affordable.
- nostrademons 6y agoIt doesn't have to be affordable to the working class, it just has to be affordable enough for a few engineers who saved up a bit in the last boom to take a ~5-year sabbatical. Then fear of falling into the struggling working class motivates them to keep inventing, while a desire to replace all the working-class employees who can no longer afford to live in the city gives them a ready-made market. There's no guarantee that the working class as we know it today (i.e. those who perform repetitive tasks with their hands) will continue to exist. Most of the Bay Area's history has been about automating and replacing progressively higher-level portions of the economy with machines.