3 ms·
You're right. The Register article says that. The Register article says that because they're parroting Apple's marketing. I don't fault The Register for copying
by dragontamer 6y ago
You're right. The Register article says that. The Register article says that because they're parroting Apple's marketing. I don't fault The Register for copying Apple. I fault Apple for being misleading with their arguments. LPDDR4x is NOT HBM2. HBM2 is a completely different technology.
"High Bandwidth Memory", or HBM2 (since we're on version 2 of that tech now), HBM2 is on the order of 1024-bit lanes per chip-stack. It is extremely misleading for Apple to issue a press-release claiming they have "high bandwidth memory".
HBM2 is the stuff of supercomputers: the Fujitsu A64FX. Ampere A100 GPUs. Etc. etc. That's not the stuff you'd see in a phone or laptop.
> "In other words, this memory is shared between the three different compute engines and their cores. The three don't have their own individual memory resources, which would need data moved into them."
It would be colossally stupid for the iGPU, CPU, and Neural Engine to communicate over RAM. I don't even need to look at the design: they almost certainly share Last-Level Cache. LLC communications are faster than RAM communications.
From the perspective of the iGPU / CPU / Neural Engine, its all the same (because the "cache" pretends to be RAM anyway). But in actuality, the bandwidth and latency characteristics of that communication are almost certainly optimized to be cache-to-cache transfers, without ever leaving the chip.
- kllrnohj 6y ago> HBM2 is the stuff of supercomputers: the Fujitsu A64FX. Ampere A100 GPUs. Etc. etc. That's not the stuff you'd see in a phone or laptop. It also made an appearance on some consumer discreet GPUs, notably the Vega 56, Vega 64, and Radeon VII.
- ogre_codes 6y ago> "High Bandwidth Memory", or HBM2 (since we're on version 2 of that tech now), HBM2 is on the order of 1024-bit lanes per chip-stack. It is extremely misleading for Apple to issue a press-release claiming they have "high bandwidth memory". Considering how few people know what HBM2 is, the idea that Apple is trying to make any claims that their solution uses HBM2 seems weird.
- dragontamer 6y ago> Considering how few people know what HBM2 is, the idea that Apple is trying to make any claims that their solution uses HBM2 seems weird. https://www.apple.com/mac-pro/ https://www.apple.com/mac-pro/ Apple absolutely knows what HBM2 is. They've literally got products with HBM2 in it. Note: LPDDR4x RAM is typically called "Low Power" RAM, in fact, that's exactly what LPDDR4x is for. Its designed to be a low-power consumption ram for extended battery life. It takes a special level of marketing (ie: misleading / misdirection) to buy two chips of "low power" RAM, and try to sell it as "high bandwidth RAM".
- danaris 6y agoWhile I can certainly understand a certain amount of frustration at Apple for using phrasing that has been used as an official marketing term, I also have to say that I don't think too highly of whoever came up with the idea that "HBM" should be an exclusive marketing term in the first place, when it's a very straightforward description of memory that includes, but is not limited to, memory within that specific label. Based on what Apple's doing, it seems perfectly legitimate and reasonable to refer to the memory in the M1 Macs as "high-bandwidth memory", even if its lanes are not 1024 bits wide.
- dragontamer 6y agoWhen Supercomputers and GPUs are pushing 1000GB/s with "high bandwidth memory", its utterly ridiculous to call a 70GB/s solution 'high bandwidth' (128-bits x 4266 MT/s). There's an entire performance tier between normal desktops and supercomputers: the GDDR6 / GDDR6x tier of graphics RAM, pushing 512GB/s (Radeon 6xxx series) and 800GB/s (NVidia RTX 3080). To call 128-bit x 4266MT/s "high bandwidth" is a complete misnomer, no matter how you look at it. Any quad-channel (Threadripper: ~100GB/s) or hex-channel (Xeon ~150GB/s) already crushes it, let alone truly high-bandwidth solutions. And nobody in their right mind calls Threadripper or Xeon "high bandwidth", we call them like they are: quad-channel or hex-channel.