3 ms·
Processors are complex. Architectures are over my head. Is there an intelligent layman's video or article series not just on architectures, but how, at a high l
by unethical_ban 6y ago
Processors are complex. Architectures are over my head. Is there an intelligent layman's video or article series not just on architectures, but how, at a high level, ARM is supposedly so much better than x86 in the long term?
- addicted 6y agoIt’s not just (or even) ARM. It’s Apple. For comparison, the A series chips on iOS devices are years ahead of their competitors on the Android side (largely Qualcomm and Samsung) despite all being on ARM. That being said, it would indeed be good to hear from someone with expertise as to what Apple has accomplished and why others haven’t been able to.
- unethical_ban 6y agoThis is true, and this is an Apple story. But I've seen this attitude on HN a while, including a comment here about AWS' Gravitron processors. It feels like ARM is similar to electric vehicles: Everyone here acts like "of course it's a better, more efficient design" but there are physical forces holding it back. That's just the feeling I get.
- _trampeltier 6y agoAs far, I understand it, the M1 is just very fast with single core, multi core not so much. I guess Intel and AMD focused on multi core performance, and did not mind much about electric power. AMD also pushed primary multi core performance, even most people never need it. We never really heard from Intel, oh what a wonderful low power notebook processor. Also test magazines and youtubers made primary performance benchmarks. Finally the said .. yeah, maybe they need a bit much power, but this processor is super fast, so still 100 points .. nobody asked for a such processor until now.
- altcognito 6y agoIt's not. There are fundamental differences in the hardware implementation of handling the instruction codes independent of actual instruction set. This in some senses is no different than AMD being better at x86 than Intel. My high level understanding is that they integrated a number of components into the chip that typically are external and that they had a trick or two surrounding out of order execution that yielded benefits. Last, they have a more modern manufacturing process and all of this contributes to a significantly better, lower power chip.
- kllrnohj 6y agoARM vs. x86 is mostly irrelevant and far over-focused. The main big factor in why the ARM-based M1 is able to have such great instructions per clock is due to the fixed-length instructions making it easier for Apple to have made a very wide CPU core front-end. Think trying to apply a parallel map to an array vs. a linked-list. It's easier to spawn off 8 jobs in parallels if just getting the right data isn't dependent on previous work. x86's variable-length makes that front-end decoding in parallel more complex. Then thanks to that high IPC, Apple can keep the clock speeds lower while hitting the performance target they are going for. By keeping the clocks low, power is then also low. Nothing all that special or unique there, the power draw at 3ghz on an M1 is right in line with what you'd expect an equivalent x86 CPU at around 3ghz as well. Beyond that there's basically no major difference that really matters, and no "inherent" power efficiencies or advantages of any kind, either. If AMD or Intel manage to make an 8-wide x86 CPU core, then you'll see that power efficiency advantage of the M1 vanish overnight. Similarly, Apple is currently the only one making ARM CPU cores that are wider than the typical x86 core is, which is why nobody else has impressive ARM CPUs. ARM has some advantages in that it just doesn't have the history & legacy that x86 does, but then that's also a disadvantage because legacy software also is very much a thing. What the future holds nobody really knows. At the end of the day what matter is how a CPU performs, not what instruction set it runs.
- zamadatix 6y agoI think the options on this are either a lot of hand waving that basically says "it's been done better this time because they didn't need to do it the old way" with more fancy sounding words or you could have some expert conversation that goes deep into the reasoning but doesn't really translate usefully for a layman. A bit like looking to understand an upper level math theory by looking for a video breaking down what the symbols are named - sure you know more about it now but you're not really any closer to understanding the theory than before. For the "what the symbols are named" level explanation https://www.anandtech.com/show/16226/apple-silicon-m1-a14-deep-dive https://www.anandtech.com/show/16226/apple-silicon-m1-a14-de... talks about the functional units and what's changed though.