29 ms·
> The problematic part of a fiat system is not that is fiat, but that is in the hands of the government who knows not how to exercise constraint and inflates it
by arcticbull 6y ago
> The problematic part of a fiat system is not that is fiat, but that is in the hands of the government who knows not how to exercise constraint and inflates it at will to "pay" for things, more realistically, to promise to pay for things that if it had to actually pay for it will never be able to afford.
If economic growth outpaces debt growth then it does not ever have to be paid back.
> ...what do you think money is?
Money is an intentionally lossy temporary store or value and a medium of exchange. Interact, yes. Store long term, no.
If you have problems with monetary policy vote in a new government, just taking your ball to the BVI isn’t a solution.
> ...you don’t understand what Bitcoin is.
I understand full well, and I believe those are bad things. Deflation is bad, for the reason I stated, and an inability to print means an inability to respond to geopolitical shocks (like COVID, for instance Canada has been paying everyone $2000/month this whole time). Not to mention an inability to grow supply with the entry of new market participants.
Bitcoin cannot and will not change the wealth gap when it’s overwhelmingly spoken for already. The best you can do is sentence your children to fight for scraps while the new moneyed class of criminals and lowlifes continues to grow in relative wealth as a fraction of economic activity by doing literally nothing with their money - backed on an inflation schedule created and managed not by economists or experts but a narcotics smuggler and a bunch of random GitHub contributors.
If you really want to change society for the better, run for office, don’t shill magic beans.
- georgesC 6y agoThe fact that so many people don't know that cash/fiat is losing value over time makes it somewhat of a problem. Furthermore the creation of cash/fiat creates high benefits to those that benefits from the newly created money first, before the money spreads and devalues its value due to inflation over time. Inflation vs deflation debate is a complicated one, I don't know which is best in terms of enabling technical progress. One is more short termist, another is more long termist. But fiat/inflated currencies won't go away. It's just that those kinds of currencies just tends to blow up at some point because of inflation and human nature. It's more than nice to have other options, especially digital. The idea to have some kind of worldwide standard that is open and won't change is also nice.
- arcticbull 6y agoNot changing is nice conceptually but very bad in practice because the real world changes. It doesn’t map. It’s one of those software engineering tendencies to rewrite instead of understand and improve. One side note though. Consider that inflation doesn’t affect the poor as the poor live paycheck to paycheck and wages in the US have kept pace with inflation. The wealthy don’t hold cash, they invest. Even cash tends to be held in a savings account with at least partially offsets inflationary pressure. Has it impacted anyone materially? I’d love to see some quantification.
- georgesC 6y agoIn practice, I'd say "selected" lower level standards aren't changed but built upon. Standard tools also tends to not change much. web protocols, C, C++, php, those are not getting away despite many attempts to reinvent the wheel. Maybe someone will make a better wheel one day, or maybe not, but for me it's nice to have a starting point in the domain of p2p "exchange" that may or may not be adopted as a standard. As for inflation, it makes it harder for the poor workers to become wealthier, but the issue is more when it stops being sustainable. Inflationary fiat has proven that it could fail. I personally don't trust those persons handling it and I feel that such sentiment is growing among people. There's reasons behind that. That is terrible for a currency. Governments may or may not start having a better monetary policy. We don't have guarantees and much control over it, that's the issue for me. I'd rather avoid an economical disaster and keep a business running than having to deal with the failure of others.
- arcticbull 6y agoEach of the languages you called out have changed dramatically to respond to the needs of users, which Bitcoin cannot, has not and will not do. You’re basically advocating for K&R C forever. Re inflation again, has no impact on poor workers. The amount of value transferred to them in exchange for work is purely social policy and fiscal policy not monetary policy. You can improve workers mobility by supporting unions and minimum wage, not by changing the inflation characteristics of their medium of exchange they don’t get to hold on to anyways. None of your criticisms matter if you’ve invested your fiat.
- anythingdude321 6y agoRun for office? I prefer the trim tab approach: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trim_tab#Trim_tab_as_a_metaphor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trim_tab#Trim_tab_as_a_metapho... If Bitcoiners are right, Satoshi has been the trim tab of the century thus far. Time will tell :)
- arcticbull 6y agoSatoshi is likely Paul Le Roux. Let’s hope not. He’s managed to waste more of our time, money and brainpower than anyone in recent memory. Either way my point remains that Bitcoin solves nothing other than making criminals wealthy. Time will tell.
- seibelj 6y agoYou have been grinding this axe so hard it's almost gone at this point. When BTC is 30k, 50k, 100k you will still be tilting at windmills, and no one will care. You are so wrong and incorrect on nearly everything you type, you must be an absolutely insufferable person to deal with.
- arcticbull 6y agoI could not care less what price Bitcoin ends up at, it will not change the garbage fundamentals, or my opinion of it, nor should it change yours. There's tons of different ways to make money investing, and I stick to traditional markets. Tesla has seen a 15X increase in value over the last year, Square 20X since 2016. I suspect I may be insufferable when I see something that's just a giant waste of time, power, energy, effort and brain power, and I'm not mad about that. I do wish you the best of luck making money, however you choose to do so!
- cloudinshape 6y ago> If economic growth outpaces debt growth then it does not ever have to be paid back. Bernie Maddoff said the same thing. He also tried to create a perpetual motion machine. > Canada has been paying everyone $2000/month this whole time) Canada has been lending everyone $2000/month this whole time. > Bitcoin cannot and will not change the wealth gap when it’s overwhelmingly spoken for already. Again, you don't understand what bitcoin is, nor money apparently. People don't stash money away, not all of it anyways, and specially not when its inflation rate is limited (as in there is not a lot of excess to stash like right now), they use it to buy stuff, to pay for stuff, to invest in stuff, they enjoy it, that is why you want money in the first place! Money is, was and always will be exchanged, which means it changes hands. Odd concept, I know. > backed on an inflation schedule created and managed not by economists or experts but a narcotics smuggler and a bunch of random GitHub contributors. Yes, the "experts" managing the "economy" right now are doing such a great job. > just taking your ball to the BVI isn’t a solution. At some point, sooner rather than later by the looks of it, it will be the only solution. > If you really want to change society for the better, run for office, don’t shill magic beans. Weird advice from someone convinced we'll never have to pay back our debts.
- arcticbull 6y ago> Bernie Maddoff said the same thing. He also tried to create a perpetual motion machine. Bernie Madoff doesn't get to print his own currency, you see why that's different right? You know who does though? Tether. > Canada has been lending everyone $2000/month this whole time. Paying. Lending implies that it has to be returned, it does not. > Again, you don't understand what bitcoin is, nor money apparently. Incorrect, I know what money is for and how it works. I don't disagree with anything you said about money. What I disagree with is that inflation matters in that context. It does not. I also see Bitcoin as having been spoken for already, and it has. with a worse wealth distribution than a banana republic, which it has. > Yes, the "experts" managing the "economy" right now are doing such a great job. Inflation has been in a tightly controlled 1-2% range in the US since the 1970s. They are. So forgive me for not giving a bunch of un-elected, un-accountable randos with commit privileges and a narcotics trafficker the steering wheel lol. > At some point, sooner rather than later by the looks of it, it will be the only solution. Agree to disagree. > Weird advice from someone convinced we'll never have to pay back our debts. Who is "our" and why does one have anything to do with the other?