3 ms·
It wasn’t “the administration.” The $1,200 stimulus is structured as a refundable tax credit. The CARES Act itself—which was enacted by a Democratic House and R
by rayiner 6y ago
It wasn’t “the administration.” The $1,200 stimulus is structured as a refundable tax credit. The CARES Act itself—which was enacted by a Democratic House and Republican Senate—clearly requires everyone filing a joint return to have a valid SSN. Section 2201(g) says:
> (g) IDENTIFICATION NUMBER REQUIREMENT.—
‘‘(1) IN GENERAL.—No credit shall be allowed under subsection (a) to an eligible individual who does not include on the return of tax for the taxable year—
‘‘(A) such individual’s valid identification number,
‘‘(B) in the case of a joint return, the valid identification number of such individual’s spouse, and
‘‘(C) in the case of any qualifying child taken into account under subsection (a)(2), the valid identification number of such qualifying child.
> ‘‘(2) VALID IDENTIFICATION NUMBER.—
‘‘(A) IN GENERAL.—For purposes of paragraph (1), the term ‘valid identification number’ means a social security number (as such term is defined in section 24(h)(7)).
- waheoo 6y agoBut.. but.. the narrative..
- jimz 6y agoAh yes, the clause that neatly manages to exclude tax payers who have ITNs that look and at filing time function just like an SSN but somehow are neatly trimmed out here, I wonder how that got in there...
- bigbubba 6y agoHow did it get there?
- rayiner 6y agoIt got there because Congress, not the administration, put it in there.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoIt'd be fair to say that vocal hostility toward immigration is more concentrated in one party - and that that party is spread across the WH and Congress. To be reasonable tho, effective hostility toward immigration is historically well represented in both parties (eg: immigration policies under the previous admin).
- rayiner 6y agoExcluding certain immigrants from taxpayer-funded public benefits isn't "hostility." Deciding to take care of citizens and permanent residents and not others, or denying government benefits to create disincentives for illegal immigration, is a legitimate exercise of a people's right to self-determination. This is not something limited to U.S. Republicans. Most EU countries exclude illegal immigrants from their universal healthcare systems, for example:https://rmx.news/article/article/germany-should-pay-illegal-migrants-1-500-in-coronavirus-aid-and-grant-them-amnesty-demands-leftist-party-mps https://rmx.news/article/article/germany-should-pay-illegal-... Giving government benefits to illegal immigrants is a tough issue. On one hand, its rightfully an unpopular policy and risks creating incentives to immigrate illegally. On the other hand, denying benefits risks creating a permanent underclass of people who are prevented from integrating. I tend to believe the best approach is to rigorously enforce immigration restrictions, while including those who the country isn't willing to exclude or deport within the welfare system. But these should be viewed as policy choices, not in terms of "hostility" or some such silliness.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Excluding certain immigrants from taxpayer-funded public benefits isn't "hostility." Maybe, but the vocal hostility toward immigrants in the Republican Party is, well, vocal hostility, and not limited to a policy preference for excluding certain immigrants from taxpayer-funded benefits.
- rayiner 6y agoThe "vocal hostility" (such as it is) rests on policy. The U.S. has twice as many illegal immigrants as "Europe" (EU-27+UK+EFTA), despite having a third less people overall. That is the result of policies--lax border enforcement, lack of enforcement of work eligibility requirements, etc. People get hostile when other people don't follow the rules and the government doesn't enforce the rules. (E.g. Wall Street after the 2009 recession.) But that's still a matter of policy.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y ago
- thedanbob 6y agoTo add to this, as I understand it if you have a SS card with the words “not valid for employment” then the IRS doesn’t consider it valid for the stimulus, even if you’ve been filing W2s for years. You have to apply for a new card so the SS database gets updated with the fact that you have a valid SSN. At least that’s what I’m hoping, so my wife and I can finally collect that $2400 on our next tax return.