5 ms·
Cheating in chess typically means using engine. There is big enough difference in how engine plays and how human plays for it to make game less fun. Pls, it is
by watwut 6y ago
Cheating in chess typically means using engine. There is big enough difference in how engine plays and how human plays for it to make game less fun.
Pls, it is quite natural for humans to care about notion of fairness. How and why we loose matters.
- 46756e 6y agoYeah, although this is speculation, I imagine its less of an issue because cheaters would get board somewhat easily. I mean whats the fun in copying what a machine says to win chess games against strangers? Its not like its people they know who might be impressed and if they cheat then their ranking will rise far above their skill, so if they wanted to play a real game, they would then be crushed.
- dragontamer 6y ago> I mean whats the fun in copying what a machine says to win chess games against strangers? I mean, what's the fun in beating everyone in Overwatch / PUBG / Fortnite / Quake / Doom / etc. etc. with an aimbot? To win. Because cheaters find winning fun, even if they're not doing it on their own skill. I obviously disagree with the mindset, but cheaters disagree with me (and clearly continue to use aimbots / chessbots / whatever to rack up "their wins"). Generally speaking, their excuses are along the lines of "I don't have the reaction speed of others", or "I don't find games of reaction fun" (etc. etc.). Similarly, a chessbot user would almost certainly say "I don't like having obvious blunders in my games, and a chessbot prevents me from missing obvious blunders". --------- I mean, Centaur Chess is a thing. Human + Computer, if you really wanted to fight fair. But these cheaters don't go towards Centaur Chess servers, they stay on human-only servers and just wanna have an advantage on the opponent. Soooooo... yeah. That's their decision. There's chess tournaments of 24-hours a move, no holds barred. (IE: Chess AIs are allowed to assist you). If you really wanted "blunder free chess", people can play in those communities. Those who continue to use computer-assistance on human-only servers are simply cheaters in my book.
- 1996 6y ago> Cheating in chess typically means using engine. There is big enough difference in how engine plays and how human plays for it to make game less fun. I've pondered moving to something different-but-close to get again the beginner fun, like shogi. Also, there's more variety of movement with the lances: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shogi#Movement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shogi#Movement
- cjohnson318 6y agoI had a Romanian stats teacher that sneered at Americans' preoccupation with fairness. She would say, "Why do you use this word fair? Life is not fair. It is a useless idea."
- lisper 6y agoIt is not a useless idea. Fairness is something one can choose to strive for, notwithstanding that one will inevitably fall short of perfection. Much like proficiency in chess.
- SamBam 6y agoThat seems merely like a way of perpetuating unfairness. I don't know the story, but it sounds like the teacher was in a position of power and someone said she was being unfair. Retorting "life is unfair" when you, yourself, are the agent causing unfairness simply inflicts needless pain. For what -- to teach the lesson that life is unfair? As a parent, I try to parent my kids fairly. I try not to show favoritism. I try to recall which kid had the last cookie most recently. Obviously the kids sometimes don't agree with me and claim I am being unfair, but by valuing fairness at the very least I am trying, and modeling for them a world where they value fairness in turn. (Of course, note, people may value different things. Fairness is its own category in the moral foundations theory[1], and some people rank it as less important than, say, authority or purity.) 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_foundations_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_foundations_theory
- cjohnson318 6y agoThis was a graduate level class and the teacher did not believe in partial credit. Someone had missed a sign and thought their B was unfair. I agree, kids should be treated fairly and taught to treat others fairly. However, I think it is just as important to teach children resilience in the face of unavoidable adversity. It’s important to feel feelings, but to not let them poison you. Learning to get over a breakup, or an injury come to mind. I’d like to stress unavoidable adversity, in contrast to crimes like discrimination, battery, fraud, etc. So, my harping on “life isn’t fair” is an indirect and misleading way of saying, “it’s important to be resilient”. I apologize for posting my comment without more context.
- Buttons840 6y ago> Pls, it is quite natural for humans to care about notion of fairness. Yes, but should we give up things we enjoy because the possibility for unfairness in that thing exists? We may never know whether someone is using a chess engine assistant, but by observing what we can, their moves and game records, we can objectively argue that the match is fair. Statistically speaking, you have about a 50% chance to win. Is that unfair?