3 ms·
PGP lacks a good library implementation. The remedy for that is not creating a new protocol with radically different properties, one that's difficult to analyse
by lmm 6y ago
PGP lacks a good library implementation. The remedy for that is not creating a new protocol with radically different properties, one that's difficult to analyse and gives up important properties. The remedy is writing a good library implementation.
- tptacek 6y agoThat's not true. PGP's problems with message verification are endemic to the protocol; see, for instance, the MDC. This isn't just a known problem with PGP, it's probably the single most notorious design problem in the protocol, so it's surprising to see this response.
- lmm 6y agoFeigned surprise is a cheap rhetorical trick; pretending that your faction has the expert consensus doesn't make it so. And pretending that you were talking about the protocol rather than the libraries a minute ago won't fool anyone when your post saying "APIs" is right there. There is a specific imperfection in the protocol around verification; there is a mitigation in place, and a good library implementation (that didn't simply 1:1 replicate the protocol) would include that. The consensus is largely that the mitigation is adequate, but again, if you disagree with that then the remedy would be a protocol update that addresses that specific issue, not a radically different protocol with very different properties that's missing key protections.
- tptacek 6y agoMy faction has the expert consensus. Feel free to cite the countervailing expert opinion. I think at this point any reputable cryptography engineer would do!