3 ms·
As a consultant with a reputation for actually getting real results and delighting my clients, firms like McKinsey whose reputation is built on fake hype make m
by rkagerer 6y ago
As a consultant with a reputation for actually getting real results and delighting my clients, firms like McKinsey whose reputation is built on fake hype make me sick.
Why would you hire a bunch of generalists who are probably less informed in your sector than your own staff and lack any track record of building great companies? What a waste! Go hire someone who's proven themselves instead. Maybe a champion from your competitor, a hero from the open source community, a promising young startup who's running circles around you.
Some quotes from the article:
- Despite its lack of corrections experience, McKinsey won the contract.
- As they formulated a reform plan, the consultants did not solicit the views of inmates, clinic staff or others with direct insights into drivers of violence.
- The city’s bill from McKinsey would include $5.5 million for data analytics... These tools, however, proved I'll-suited
- Officials discovered coding errors in spreadsheets used to collect violence data from Restart units. The flaws were significant.
If you're going to hire a big firm like this because you think they bring reputation and prestige, at least tie a portion of their remuneration to performance outcomes.
- bra-ket 6y agoWhat I keep hearing these firms are brought in for purely political reasons, when management wants something done but has to offload the responsibility to some external brand, so in case things go south they can shift the blame. Seems to work in this case.