4 ms·
I think about this article a lot. I think this perhaps discounts the usefulness of GPG in specific professional applications. He's judging it on mass adoption
by sneak 6y ago
I think about this article a lot.
I think this perhaps discounts the usefulness of GPG in specific professional applications.
He's judging it on mass adoption; that's fine but it's not the kind of tool that will ever be adopted by most people. It serves a specific purpose (and shoehorning it into email isn't that) and for that purpose I (and other competent professionals) still use and trust it for that purpose.
I am also excited about new tools (like age, which will also never have hundreds of millions of users) along these lines.
I think some similar criticisms could be levied against, say, Adobe Premiere, even though it has an order of magnitude or two more users than PGP (although perhaps not when you consider every apt user in Debian and Debianlikes such as Ubuntu). Industrial software for trained professionals has a lot of sharp corners and footguns. Not all software is (or should be) Instagram.
He's 100% right that GPG email sucks, though. Don't use GPG for email except when attaching secrets.
- garmaine 6y ago> Don't use GPG for email except when attaching secrets. Don’t even do that. Find a different way to send those secrets.
- corty 6y agoNever say something like that without offering a proper replacement that is proveably more secure.
- garmaine 6y agoThe thing is it is less secure in many ways because you are giving up on reputability and using long-lives keys stored on untrusted devices.
- corty 6y agoLess secure than what? Unencrypted attachments?
- garmaine 6y agoThe guy who wrote the OP is the guy behind Signal. That's the most obvious alternative. But there's not a go-to answer because the lesson learned from PGP is that there can't be a single crypto Swiss army knife of a protocol. There are conflicting tradeoffs that necessitate the use of different protocols for different use cases. The best replacement for PGP is probably a basket of different protocols. See for example: https://blog.gtank.cc/modern-alternatives-to-pgp/ https://blog.gtank.cc/modern-alternatives-to-pgp/
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- blitblitblit 6y agoSomeone did make an alternative to GnuPG called OpMSG, but I'm not certain that it is reliably more secure, other than not depending on an online Web of Trust / key server. https://github.com/stealth/opmsg https://github.com/stealth/opmsg
- sneak 6y agoEmail is the only widely used decentralized communication system that most people have access to that doesn't require showing ID. Everyone this applies to already has GPG installed. It's fine. If you have some specific argument against it, speak up.
- garmaine 6y agoYou give up reputability by using PGP/GPG, which is a pretty big deal when transmitting secrets, and in the default configuration that everyone has GPG involves using long-lived secret keys on untrusted devices. The first is a problem that is often not thought about in the moment. You know you need to transmit a secret, but it is rare that people think about under what future circumstances they will want to deny having sent it. The second is a practical defeat of the assumed security model. The GPG secret is a high-value target that is relatively easy to snag from unencrypted memory on untrustworthy devices.
- sneak 6y ago> You give up reputability by using PGP/GPG Signing is optional.