7 ms·
What nobody talks about is the link between this rubber pollution and safety. Modern cars have huge oversized tires with massive friction potentials. In norma
by sandworm101 6y ago
What nobody talks about is the link between this rubber pollution and safety. Modern cars have huge oversized tires with massive friction potentials. In normal driving we never get anywhere near those friction limits. It all sits in reserve for that time we need to stop now. Our cars can stop on a dime in an emergency, far far shorter than current regulations mandate. Compare any new car today to a classic car from the 60s or 70s (on the old rubber). Our stopping distances today are half or even a third of previously accepted norms. The price for that ability: rubber on the road. It is a choice we have actively made, one i doubt many would reconsider. Who here would buy a non-polluting tire if it meant your car stopped even 25% slower?
- permo-w 6y agoI think you’re massively underestimating the impact of automatic braking
- permo-w 6y agoTo be clear, the commenter I’m replying to edited his comment, making mine look odd. Previously it commented on braking distances falling 40-50% between the 70s and now, and didn’t seem to be taking ABS into account
- dawnerd 6y ago> Who here would buy a non-polluting tire if it meant your car stopped even 25% slower? I wouldn’t. The regulations are outdated and for heavier cars like Evs you need all the stopping power you can get.
- spaceisballer 6y agoI always thought BEVs would be way heavier and I remember looking my model 3 up before I bought it and was surprised. Did a quick look again and here are the curb weights I found. Tesla Model 3: 3,686lbs Audi A4 2020: 3417-3627 2020 BMW 3-Series: 3582
- sandworm101 6y agoYa, they are all similar performance/luxury sedans. Compart the Honda Civic, a pretty standard car, with a curb weight of 2770lbs. A thousand pounds less.
- dawnerd 6y agoThe Model S is nearly 5,000 as well. Newer 3s are more like 4,000
- dkdk8283 6y agoI wouldn’t even consider it. I intentionally run tires larger larger than OEM for safety. If everyone I love is in my car and there is anything I can to help protect them I will. This is one area where I’ll proudly admit I come before mother nature. As George Carlin famously said the planet will be here long after I’m gone.
- ericd 6y agoPollution is also a trade against future humans, though, including your descendants. We should really rebrand “Save the Earth” as “Save Humanity”. It’s pretty clear the Earth will survive us, as it survived the cataclysms that killed the dinosaurs.
- dkdk8283 6y agoThe survival of my family now is implicitly required for survival of my lineage. There’s nothing you can say to change my mind based on environmental rhetoric.
- stefan_ 6y agoJudging by the absence of regular safety inspections in vast parts of the US... mostly no one cares? Talk about an active choice there. The stopping distance fetish is weird in any case, whatever benefit you got from stopping faster is obviated by the outsized inflation in vehicle weights.
- bigbubba 6y agoStopping distance won't seem like a ''fetish'' to some kid who cases his ball onto a busy street and doesn't get his brains splattered because cars do stop faster than they once did.
- scrose 6y agoIt seems like the obvious solution is lower speed limits and less deadly cars. Not more pollution in case the person texting on their phone at 30+mph looks up from their phone a split second before they notice a kid playing in or crossing the street.
- dredmorbius 6y agoChildren aren't the only suddenly-appearing risks, even in otherwise blue-sky, fair-weather, controlled-access conditions.
- bigbubba 6y agoThat's a fine snarky retort if you only consider idealised abstract scenarios. In the real world, streets are lined with all manner of visual obstructions that children, deer, etc may be hidden by. Bushes, cars, buildings or garden walls; any speed above parking lot speeds has the potential to kill somebody or something in real world scenarios. Shit happens.
- scrose 6y agoI wasn’t being snarky, and I’m well aware of real world scenarios. I’ve biked in NYC for over a decade, I’ve worked in transportation and volunteer my time for building safer streets. The majority of drivers I see on the street at looking at phones on their laps, or dashboards where their phone is hanging. The obstacles you named(visual obstructions) are all also things that should not exist as much as they do in their current forms. Daylighting intersections to improve sight lines, smaller cars to prevent crushing kids and also improve sight lines, narrower streets to reduce speeds are not idealized abstract scenarios. Plenty of countries outside of the USA have this as a reality and a few have achieved 0 traffic deaths, and that is owed almost entirely to street design, not bigger car tires. ‘Shit Happens’, yes. But there are significantly better ways to make ‘shit happen’ less, and make it less deadly for the people outside of a car.
- bayindirh 6y agoI've experienced enough events that having all the grip saved my life so, I wouldn't even consider it. Traffic is a place where everyone is going with ~1 ton boxes and nobody (incl. me) is not knowing what they're doing so, every mm of safety is preferable.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoConsidering how long wearing economy tires fly off the shelves compared to "nice" tires that easily have 10-20% more traction I think that society has made its preferences quite clear. What I want to know is how many of the people in these comments talking about unconscionable even an extra millimeter of stopping distance is are actually putting their money where their mouth is and buying season specific tires.
- giantg2 6y agoI agree that the overall trend has been towards higher treadwear tires. One thing to note is that the treadwear of these modern tires is higher while still providing better stopping distance when compared to the old '50-'60s tires mentioned. Of course there are other factors such as anti-lock brakes, tread design, and other vehicle traits that can decrease the distance. Still, the material component does provide longer life and better performance than in the past. Also, I have owned high performance 200 treadwear tires. The millimeters you are talking about can be meters at highway speeds. You are looking at a return in safety that increases substantially with speed. Roughly, your stopping distance quadruples when you double speed. So 30 feet at 30 mph turns into 120 feet at 60 mph (depending on a ton of factors, including tires). So some people who drive at highway speeds such as 80 mph may prefer the extra safety of performance tires which could shorten their stopping distances by 20 feet.
- dugditches 6y agoI mean, rubber is certainly important when compared modern compounds to stuff from the 60's & 70's. But the advent of ABS and Disc Brakes is also a big factor in stopping power & distance.