2 ms·
This is undercut by the implicit acceptance that there is still an objective "guilty" which can somehow be determined in advance of the trial, and thus we can j
by jerf 16y ago
This is undercut by the implicit acceptance that there is still an objective "guilty" which can somehow be determined in advance of the trial, and thus we can judge whether the criminal defender is defending a "guilty" person or not. But if we had that, we wouldn't need trials at all. The very point of a defender is that we don't know that. How many people have confessed to crimes they didn't even commit? How much more sure can you be that they are guilty? Yet they aren't, necessarily.
That's what the defender is for, to ensure that we consider the best argument for innocence, and then, if we screw up and convict an innocent person, at least the system as a whole has the defense that it tried its best to not convict the person. After all, mistakes regrettably happen and we certainly can't just give up on justice as a result. Just as we don't give up because of the other imperfections in the system, which certainly exist.
The defender of the most (objectively) guilty person in the world is still obligated to bring their best defense, and they are doing their job and serving as a credit to their civilization when they do so. Anything less means the conviction is tainted, regardless of the guilt status of the defendant. The defender's obligation is to help the system render untainted verdicts.
(Just because I'm expressing the theory does not mean I naively believe it precisely corresponds to reality. It is, nevertheless, important to understand the reasons behind what we do even if they are only imperfectly implemented.)