4 ms·
This is hilarious :) I honestly thought it was a joke... but now I am uncertain.. he seems to genuinely think that Britain is like this :S The best bit is the
by ErrantX 15y ago
This is hilarious :) I honestly thought it was a joke... but now I am uncertain.. he seems to genuinely think that Britain is like this :S
The best bit is the wonderful caricature of Oxbridge interviews, as if the modern world is left behind once you step foot in those hallowed halls :D One guy at our school that went to Oxford worked like absolute hell to get his grades, pass his entrance exam and pass the exhausting round of interviews (2 days, testing all sorts of aptitidue).
Sure; the colleges have a tradition of "sprawling on sofa's" while enjoying a glass of the good stuff. But it is just tradition!
Aged 18, perhaps hungover, you read out your pitiful but elegant essay. The tutor points out gaps in your knowledge. For an hour, you talk your way around those gaps.
Hahahahahahahahaha. Ahem. All of the friends I have that went to a really top flight university (Oxford, Cambridge, Durham, etc) were basically working flat out for their exams from about January every year..
(I was the drunkard.. see "winging it" below)
Traditionally, elite Britons then leave education aged 21. Until recently they rarely bothered with graduate school.
Meh, classic nonsense confusion regarding the British and American educations systems.
Britain’s rulers still struggle to judge scientific arguments about nuclear energy or climate change
Very much struggling to see American, or indeed any other countries, "rulers" doing any better.
It was the urge to amuse that recently prompted Cameron to riff on an old TV ad and shout “Calm down, dear,” at a female Labour MP.
Failing to understand British humour, he only got it in the neck because at that level of politics you have to work with international norms.
Admittedly, ignorance sometimes saves Britain’s rulers from error.
And here we really get to the crux of it. We are not talking about "winging it", or an aptitude for rhetoric, but "ignorance". I'll be first to admit that the UK political elite are, to some extent, "clueless" on technical topics. But... how is that any different from any other politician in the world? Is that not why they have advisors? Hmmmm.
Nah, this is just some sneer-y anti-British hit piece. A caricature of the great and powerful of Britian as bumbling idiots who get by through a wing and a prayer.
But.
Winging it very much is a British tradition. One I have always been consistently proud of, because we tend to be fucking awesome at it. I winged it through school, university, life, career. And it works, brilliantly.
So, ba shucks ;)
I could go to America and make a casual, 2 second, assessment that the masses were pretty crass (seriously, the amount, scale and volume of advertising on your TV is terrible!), thick people and that the ruling elite were basically a bunch of manic argumentative idiots. Because they are the most vocal or visible types of people. I could go to France and make a similar assessment of the people there as rude and xenophobic. etc etc. But that would be a disgustingly shallow view. Quid Pro Quo. This is just thinly disguised xenophobia and the FT should be ashamed to print it.
- lclarkmichalek 15y agoAs someone who will be applying for Oxford this September, I wholeheartedly agree with you. Even just the work needed to get the grades is immense. This year the entrance requirements for Mathematics are A Astar Astar, Mathematics and Computer Science A A A and Computer Science A A Astar. There is no way I shall be winging it (for the first time in my life, I am seriously revising).
- jdminhbg 15y agoThe author, Simon Kuper, is British and studied at Oxford (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simon_Kuper http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simon_Kuper), so while he may be wrong, it's not because he's unfamiliar with the country or the eduction system.
- petesmithy 15y agoHe has a British passport. He was born in Uganda of South African parents, spent his childhood in the Netherlands, "also lived in Stanford, California, Berlin and London", and studied at Oxford and Harvard. He currently lives in France. He should stay there :)
- zwischenzug 15y agoThe article was 90% misleading bullshit. The three years I spent at Oxford studying History were invaluable from an educational perspective, equipping me with skills that allowed me to continue to develop further skills to succeed, and not just by talking well. The 10% is there and undeniable, though. To be a leader you have to have good rhetoric, and that's drilled into you from day one. But there's no denying that you also have to learn when you have to. There's not much mention of the lonely and stressful hours spent in libraries preparing for those tutorials where I had nowhere to hide and a lot of face to lose with a whithering glare from an academic that had better things to do than compensate for my youthful indolence. You don't get that from lectures.
- kikibobo69 15y agoI'm sure I will regret this, but: One guy at our school that went to Oxford -> One guy at our school WHO went to Oxford All of the friends I have that went -> All of the friends I have WHO went