7 ms·
There aren't really that many ways to do notifications. If you want something that pops up on a large screen but isn't overly intrustive, a rectangle with text
by crazygringo 6y ago
There aren't really that many ways to do notifications.
If you want something that pops up on a large screen but isn't overly intrustive, a rectangle with text in it in the corner next to a menu icon to control them is what you're going to come up with.
And if you're Apple it'll be a rounded rectangle.
And Apple absolutely did not rip off Growl "pixel for pixel", the visual styles are totally different. I don't know where you even got that from?
- thewebcount 6y agoNot only that, but Apple already had a similar feature in MacOS 8 and 9 that Growl was reproducing in OS X. It seems like Apple just hadn't gotten around to putting it in OS X yet because other things were more important. Then eventually they had time and added it.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoWait wat? I’m not disputing this but I came up on MacOS (it wasn’t even named that at the time, I believe I got started on System 6) and I never saw notifications like that.
- webwielder2 6y agoAround Mac OS 9, they changed some types of errors from modal dialogs to floating palettes in the corner of the screen.
- ChrisGrowl 6y agoI’ve never seen these before. Sounds interesting but not the inspiration for Growl by any means. :)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kps 6y agoNot very similar. If you wanted a message, the OS put up a modal dialogue blocking everything else. The whole point of Growl was that it didn't interrupt you, and you could have its messages go away on their own.
- kergonath 6y agoThere were these yellow messages that popped up in the upper right-hand corner in MacOS 9. Those were just non-blocking notifications.
- thewebcount 6y agoExactly. They look a lot like Growl and the macOS X notifications and were not modal.
- ChrisGrowl 6y agoI never used macOS until OS X and most definitely did not copy it. Nothing about Growl was a copy of that. Growl was inspired from being project manager on Adium and worked with the people making colloquy. The devs on colloquy were working on notifications and so we’re we and I thought it was smarter to make it a separate tool.
- SwimSwimHungry 6y agoHey Chris, for what it's worth, your software was quite a lifesaver for me in my earlier OS X days back in college. Your software had great impact on my workflow and I'll never forget it. :)
- ChrisGrowl 6y agoHappy to hear it. We’re totally didn’t know what we were doing really, just making something we wanted.
- kergonath 6y agoIt just illustrates how natural the concept is. I don’t mean that in a bad way; it’s such an elegant solution and I would not be surprised to see other implementations before MacOS 9. Anyway, Growl did much more than that, and I don’t think there is any doubt Apple’s current implementation owes a lot to your design.
- ChrisGrowl 6y agoYea I just wanted to clear up the inspiration bit. I’m sure if we hadn’t done it someone else would have.
- thewebcount 6y agoFair enough. Thanks for the clarification.
- armadsen 6y agoAll great design innovations seem dead obvious in hindsight. But they're not.
- crazygringo 6y agoHuh? Notifications that pop up in the corner aren't a "great design innovation". They are an obvious one. Just because there are some non-obvious great design innovations out there, doesn't mean every little interface component is one. Some things are just the logical solution to a problem.
- ChrisGrowl 6y agoGrowl did more than pop into a corner. :)
- crazygringo 6y agoOh absolutely. :) But I assumed the accusation that Apple copied Growl was mainly that. Growl had so much configurability, so many options, it's not like Apple implemented really any of that!
- wpietri 6y agoOh? In your estimation, how many years passed between Growl being technically possible and it actually existing? I was using NeXT OS, which is what later became OS X, circa 1990. Growl apparently launched in 2003. So that's a minimum of 13 years that something "obvious" was missed. And it's probably more fair to count from the mid-1980s, when GUIs first started becoming popular. That doesn't sound obvious to me. Most things are obvious in retrospect. But it's a mistake to confuse your after-the-fact perspective for what was going on at the time. (For those who are interested, Dekker's "Field Guide to Understanding 'Human Error'" is a great look at how subtle and dangerous that confusion can be.)
- Someone 6y agoI don’t think it’s that easy. Timing is a factor, too. For such a thing to be successful, you also need a OS/hardware combo that can draw the notification without slowing down using the main window (rules out early Mac OS) and users who think the added distraction of notifications is worth it. I would that added distraction goes down with screen size. I doubt it would have been a success on 640×480 displays, for example. Also, Apple had something similar in 1997 or 1999, with Mac OS 8 or 9.