3 ms·
RISC-V is just a specification, you could quite happily sneak stuff into the RTL if you beat the right hands with a pipe.
by mhh__ 6y ago
RISC-V is just a specification, you could quite happily sneak stuff into the RTL if you beat the right hands with a pipe.
- fsflover 6y agoPrecursor’s mainboard was designed for easy inspection as well, and even its LCD and keyboard were chosen specifically because they facilitate verification of proper construction with minimal equipment
- mhh__ 6y agoYou still have to trust both the verification procedure and the specification i.e. Given how a modern CPU has to have features to manage itself, it's relatively trivial to design a system to do what VW did and recognize when the device is under test. For example, if you've seen Christopher Domas's talk/s on finding undocumented features of CPUs, any backdoors in a modern CPU will be buried deep in the vendor-specific features or require an extremely esoteric combination of register values and the like.
- bobthebuilders 6y agoThe CPU architecture is open source for one, and the boards are designed in such a way as to make outside verification easier. Excited to get my hands on one!
- mhh__ 6y agoThe architecture isn't the chip itself.
- tsimionescu 6y agoSo is a lot of malware, that doesn't mean the specification matches the final build. And even if you can verify the board, you can't verify the chip itself or any other IC.
- fsflover 6y ago> You still have to trust both Yes, you can never 100% get rid of some trust, but it does not mean that you should give up and verify nothing. The more you (are able to) verify, the more secure you are.