26 ms·
> I can't really think why anyone would think Apple would lock down macOS. Because they keep introducing new security features that get progressively more anno
by saagarjha 6y ago
> I can't really think why anyone would think Apple would lock down macOS.
Because they keep introducing new security features that get progressively more annoying to disable. Have you looked at how difficult it is to modify system files these days?
- rbrtl 6y agoSecurity is the antithesis of convenience. Would you rather they send every unit out with Frontier Law levels of user protections? Every graphics artist, musician, businessperson, student, and Joe Bloggs who buys a Mac needs to study the implications of owning a computer for themselves and mitigate all the threats on their own. Suddenly Apple computers are infected with malware like Windows was in the 2000s and we just burn all the research Apple did on the right compromise for their entire user base because a few power users want to turn on a machine and debug system processes before they even log in. I perceive a level of anti-Apple bias in HN threads, I don't think it's imagined, but more prevalent is the power user bias of people who have advanced knowledge of computer systems and want a superuser machine off the shelf. To me, the fact that you call them "security features" and not some pejorative euphemism is a bit of a capitulation.
- saagarjha 6y agoSome of the things Apple makes are certainly "security features" and not security features, but to your main point: Apple designed their security model to be "trust us or trust nobody" and the security model most users want is "I trust me". It is eminently possible to do that without going back to the wild west of not having any security, actually, the issue is that Apple forces you to go there if you aren't happy with anything they add on macOS.
- rbrtl 6y agoMost power users maybe. Most consumer users don’t think about the fact they have to trust at all. And you can’t say you don’t want the security features and then say that it’s bad you have to turn them off if you don’t want them. The goalposts are Apple’s customers, my guesstimate is that 80% of those paying customers would rather be secured by the vendor they already trusted to produce the hardware, firmware, software, and infrastructure they use on a daily basis. Do you know of any market research about the level of security most users want?
- chongli 6y agoNo, most users would rather trust Apple. These are the people who drop their computer off at the Genius Bar for software problems. They never even think about rolling up their sleeves to fix a problem, never mind firing up the terminal.
- kergonath 6y agoYou have to be realistic: you already trust them if you buy their hardware.
- ehutch79 6y agoWhy specifically, are you trying to modify system files?
- saagarjha 6y agoI run beta software on my devices. Apple, in its infinite wisdom, believes that programs compiled on beta operating systems do not belong on the App Store. Thus, I modify SystemVersion.plist so Xcode will think it's running the latest release version rather than the beta. This is just one of the things that you can do; I've occasionally patched system libraries, replaced resources, and so on depending on what I've wanted to do.
- ehutch79 6y agoDo you think it's really that odd that they wouldn't want someone publishing releases from beta OS/Libraries? Given how everything else you talked about could be turned off. Do you think that would be a better default? to allow system libraries and such to be altered? and that the protection would need to be explicitly turned on instead?
- saagarjha 6y ago> Do you think it's really that odd that they wouldn't want someone publishing releases from beta OS/Libraries? Yes, very. It's not like the toolchain really cares which version of XNU it's running on. > Given how everything else you talked about could be turned off. Do you think that would be a better default? to allow system libraries and such to be altered? and that the protection would need to be explicitly turned on instead? I liked what they did in Catalina, where you could remount the rootfs as writable. What they have in Big Sur is too much; you have to restart every time you want to modify anything and it is not possible to change anything after booting.
- gjsman-1000 6y ago`sudo spctl --master-disable` to disable Gatekeeper, and `csrutil disable` in Recovery Mode to disable rootless/System Integrity Protection. Just like that, it's a Mac from a decade ago in openness.
- saagarjha 6y agoNeither of those help with the thing I mentioned.
- jsz0 6y agoAlmost all the security features are getting progressively less sensible to disable though. You gotta be for real Jedi to be using a computer with easily modifiable system files these days.