6 ms·
> Xcode runs FAST on the M1. Compiling the PSPDFKit PDF SDK (debug, arm64) can almost compete with the fastest Intel-based MacBook Pro Apple offers to date, wit
by izacus 6y ago
> Xcode runs FAST on the M1. Compiling the PSPDFKit PDF SDK (debug, arm64) can almost compete with the fastest Intel-based MacBook Pro Apple offers to date, with 8:49 min vs 7:31 min. For comparison, my Hackintosh builds the same in less than 5 minutes.
This is telling just about how unrealistic Geekbench benchmarks, used by most reviewers, really are - they were all forecasting M1 completely humiliating everything from Intel and yet in practice it's not quite right. It's a dang impressive chip still though.
- dschu 6y agoYeah, but the MBA is doing all that with just 10W (15W burst), while your hackintosh most likely consumes 400W. Not really comparable though.
- ianhowson 6y agoI'm happy to pay for the electricity if I get faster builds. My daily driver is a Hackintosh and with the CPUs pegged pulls about 70W from the wall. The two displays add another 90W. M1 is impressively efficient but there's still a gap for fast, no-compromise workstations.
- kevindong 6y agoOn a desktop, power consumption doesn't really matter. But on a laptop, it matters a ton. Personally I prefer doing work from my couch rather than my desk; ergonomics and external monitors be damned.
- threeseed 6y ago> M1 is impressively efficient but there's still a gap for fast, no-compromise workstations. Apple has already said that they are releasing a workstation-class M1X/M2 next year. The point is that the M1 is already comparable to many workstations.
- izacus 6y agoAnd yet everyone keeps comparing those and claiming how much faster Air is supposed to be based on a very funny benchmark. Not sure how power use actually matters when I'm sitting and waiting for things to compile several times a day.
- postalrat 6y agoMaybe 400W burst with a fast graphics card. Do we have actual measurements from the MBA yet?
- sudosysgen 6y agoSure, but his Hackintosh isn't running a laptop chip. 15W X86 CPUs would probably compile that faster than the M1 if the difference from Intel is that small.
- macintux 6y agoIt would be interesting, though, to see what those numbers would look like with a fan. Anything that runs that long on an Air is going to start throttling.
- Aperocky 6y agoYou can't compare M1 to a 95W TDP chip, that's not really fair.
- selsta 6y agoSingle core vs multi core. The top Intel MacBook has 8 cores and only beats the M1 (4 performance cores) by 1 minute. The desktop Hackintosh most likely has way more cores, expecting the low power M1 to beat it is unrealistic.
- ianhowson 6y agoI hate the "M1 vs Intel MacBook" comparison. Every Intel MacBook back to 2016 has broken thermals. They're all running at maybe half their rated clock speed. 13" MBP is a 4GHz part running at 1.4GHz. 16" MBP is a 4.8GHz part throttled to 2.3GHz. You're comparing M1 vs. a broken design which Apple broke. Don't congratulate Apple for failing to ship trash. There's an argument for efficiency on a laptop, no doubt, but that's not what the parent commenter is talking about. M1 is the highest perf-per-watt CPU today, no question. Ignoring efficiency, there are plenty of faster CPUs both for single-core and multi-core tasks. That's what "my Hackintosh did the build in 5 minutes" is showing.
- read_if_gay_ 6y ago> very Intel MacBook back to 2016 has broken thermals. They're all running at maybe half their rated clock speed. Are you saying it's an unfair comparison? The Intel Macs are operating in the same environment as the M1 Macs. It doesn't matter if the Intel parts could be faster in theory, because you're still dealing with battery and size constraints. If you want unthrottled Intel CPU in a laptop, your only options are 6 pound, 2 inch thick gaming laptops with 30 minutes of battery life. Now comparing that (or worse, a desktop) to M1 is unfair.
- mbell 6y ago> 13" MBP is a 4GHz part running at 1.4GHz. 16" MBP is a 4.8GHz part throttled to 2.3GHz. Apple's thermal solutions could be better, but they are designed within Intel's power envelope specs. e.g. The i9-9880H in the current 16" MBP is only rated for 2.3Ghz with all cores active at its 45W TDP. The i9-9880H is a 2.3Ghz @ 45W part that can burst up to 4.8Ghz for short periods, not the other way around.
- trynewideas 6y ago
- adamnemecek 6y agoThey were comparing m1 vs the intels that are in MacBook Pros, not any intel.
- mcintyre1994 6y agoFWIW I’ve seen iOS developers compare the M1 laptops favourably to $5000+ iMac Pro’s as well.
- izacus 6y agoWhich is why it's such a horribly meaningless comparison - the marketing (and reviewers assisting it) blasted out comparisons with Intels obsolete technology, hamstrung by awful thermals. And then proclaimed it generally faster.
- czzr 6y agoWhich laptop should it be compared to?
- djrogers 6y agoThis is one data point among many. Tons of devs have been tweeting their compile times, and in many/most cases the M1 spanks the best Intel Mac out there. If anything, then numbers in TFA are an outlier rather than a contradiction.