7 ms·
New variety of apple discovered by Wiltshire runner
- nixy 6y agoThe capital "A" in the submission headline confused me, but it is a variety of the fruit, not the company, that has been discovered :)
- tlb 6y agoI changed the capitalization, thanks.
- jhoechtl 6y agoMakes me no wonder given the nature of the rosacea the apple belongs to and their easy willingness to cross-pollinate, for appomixis and self-fertility. Btw. only from appearance it looks like at cross between an apple and a quince (cydonia) ?
- dehrmann 6y agoStone fruit, also in the Rosaceae family, also hybridize pretty easily, and a lot of hybrids like apriums are sold commercially.
- als0 6y agoWhy is apple capitalised?
- szatkus 6y agoAutocorrect? It's HN, so OP probably write about the company more frequently than about the fruit. Or deliberately clickbaity title :)
- ndz215 6y agoLooks like a typical Russian apple Antonovka, first presented at Nizhniy Novgorod exibition in 1896.
- Etheryte 6y agoHaving Antonovka grow in my childhood garden, I can't help but very strongly disagree. Antonovka is considerably smaller, smoother, and nowhere near as yellow. In fact, I struggle to see any similarities, outside the fact that both are apples.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y agoFor the malus-curious https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antonovka https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antonovka. So how's it taste?
- mnw21cam 6y agoNew varieties of apple are two a penny. Every single seed you plant from an apple will come up as a different variety. Most of them will be completely impractical as an eating/cooking apple, and most of the trees will grow huge. The rarity is getting an apple variety that tastes good and grows well. Then you have the added complexity of having to graft it onto a useful root stock to get a reasonable-sized productive tree.
- kranner 6y agoMichael Pollan's book The Botany of Desire has this and a lot more on apples for anyone interested.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Every single seed you plant from an apple will come up as a different variety. What's the meaning of the word 'variety' then? What is its use if 'different variety' is just the same as 'different individual plant' if every seed produces a different variety. Surely 'variety' must have more meaning than that?
- gilrain 6y agoIt's a different individual plant which gained popularity by tasting good or otherwise being useful.
- phito 6y agoI would say that a variety is one individual that has been selected and cloned for some of its traits.
- PeterisP 6y agoIn general, a variety would be something that's stable and reproducible with the same properties and sufficiently distinct from others. In sexual reproduction you'd expect the variety to be stable if and only if you breed it within itself, and any cross-breeding to result in something that's new. Apple trees are generally pollinated by a large number of other apple seedlings, so it may make sense to consider every individual plant grown from seed as a potential separate variety, so we generally don't do that as the vast majority of these random cross-breeds are bad. Only experimental breeders would even consider apples from individual grown-from-seed plants, everyone else uses genetically identical clones grafted onto rootstock that's (AFAIK) also cloned.
- Angostura 6y agoWiltshire runner would be a rather good name for the new variety.
- prox 6y agoI was just about to comment this.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- asadkn 6y agoAren't there already more than 7k varieties of apples? And There are so many regional variants, it's hard to have any consistency. For instance, one specific type of red apples with a local name in my country have no equivalent in all the countries I have traveled. P.S. It's amusing to me that it's on front-page. Apple really works at HN ;)
- ogre_codes 6y agoPerhaps 7k named/ commonly cloned varieties. Every seed grown apple is unique so there are likely hundreds of millions of Apple varieties.
- koeng 6y agoPosted elsewhere, but https://applesearch.org/ https://applesearch.org/ is a super cool site of a mans journey to discover lost apple varieties.