4 ms·
Largely, successful people have little idea what they did to succeed at something. I observed this first in others and then in myself when trying to teach other
by trabant00 6y ago
Largely, successful people have little idea what they did to succeed at something. I observed this first in others and then in myself when trying to teach others.
One reason is - like PG says - the inclination for activities is more nature vs nurture than we like to think. We want the success to be caused by our choices and intelect. When it was largely chosen for us at birth.
Another aspect is post fact rationalization. Again like he says the unconscious mind decides first. Then the rational part tries to explain the choice but it often fails even to identify it, let alone pinpoint the reasons for it.
Third: teaching is mostly done through example and practicing toghether. Simple words are very ineffective at passing on experience.
And finally successful actions depend on context. For example what makes appropriate bussiness conduct varies from culture to culture, varies in time as the culture changes, is different even in the same culture depending on social class, etc. And these are just some points in the infinite variable group I called context.
All this makes such articles pretty much pointless as a recipe for success. But I'm not sure it is intended as that. There is value in the text, it's just not all true and all applicable to everybody. But then which text is?
- pdimitar 6y agoExtremely well-written comment! Enjoyed reading it. To answer your last question I'd say my takeaway is "apply critical thinking to everything, this article included". As you and others point out, PG suffers from survivorship bias and likes to post-hoc rationalize how genius he was. That definitely isn't something to learn from. One could analyze his career and maybe extract some valuable lessons from it. However I am not even sure PG is a good example at all; once some critical mass is accrued the rest of the success is pretty much inevitable. So maybe the conclusion is: strive to achieve that critical mass with all your might? Could be.
- astatine 6y ago> Largely, successful people have little idea what they did to succeed at something Well said. However, most don't seem to realize. There are people who are perfectly willing to pontificate using literally any situation and relating it to their success. Not sure, if it is them or the rest of the plebs who seek their views and put them on a pedestal.