5 ms·
American society is more unequal than those in most other OECD countries
- fleitz 16y agoIt looks like the efforts to promote entrepreneurship have been successful. In a truly egalitarian society wealth would be distributed by contribution to society. And one should expect unequal distribution of wealth according to the unequal contributions to that society. These studies presuppose that income should be divided equally, it shouldn't, it should be divided fairly and that's something that's very difficult to measure. There's nothing egalitarian about taking money from people who've earned it and giving it to those who haven't. We could equalize income tomorrow by gov't decree but the real question is whether that makes for a better society.
- wladimir 16y agoDon't try to turn this into a strawman communism versus capitalism discussion. I think most would agree that some inequality is good. After all, people are not equal. However, a too high degree of inequality will fuel social unrest. It leads to a society in which the rich have to build higher and higher walls to keep out the poor. Not my idea of a fun place to live.
- abbasmehdi 16y agoI agree, it must be a mix, where you have the opportunity for growth at the same time you don't get a free ride. However there is always and always will be a bottom 20 percent that needs to be taken care of.
- palish 16y agoEr. Why should the bottom 20% of society be "taken care of"? Is it because we're afraid they'll turn into criminals if we don't? Because that would be equivalent to paying off the mob. Honest question.
- sliverstorm 16y ago"Since they can't or won't do it for themselves, it's our duty" is how the argument usually goes. I've always chaffed with that sentiment a bit. "Can't"- ok. "Won't"? That's a choice.
- palish 16y agoBut... It's not our duty. Why should it be?
- sliverstorm 16y agoI never said it was our duty. Hell, I even said I didn't like it. It's a moral judgement many folks make, is all.
- corin_ 16y agoMy brain's not yet running this morning and I can't think of the term for this point, but as it's now in my brain I'll come back and link to more details as soon as I think of it. The rough concept is that, when it comes to society/politics/law, you should think as if you are yet to be born and don't know where in society you will end up. So, you might become the richest man in the world, or you might live a life in poverty and unemployment. As to why it matters, should people dying of hunger in the third world be ignored? Should we not care about homeless people who are sleeping in the cold and wet and will have crazily low life expectancy and a terrible standard of living? I'm not sure where the 20% comes from or how accurate an estimate that is, but the more fortunate should always do their part, whether through legislation (such as taxation) or charity, to help the less fortunate. While different people will have different views on many areas of this, such as to what extent they should be helped, how badly off you have to be to deserve it, and so on and so on, I think very few would say that the bottom end of society deserves no help at all.
- palish 16y agoWhat I'm saying is, if people decide to donate their own money to charity, then that's fine. But I don't understand the attitude of "It's noble to steal money from some, and redistribute it to others". It seems immoral.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- tomjen3 16y agoThey are being taken care of. Look at how much money we pay for food stamps, unemployment benefits, section 8 housing, etc.
- fleitz 16y agoTo me it's about egalitarian distribution of wealth, there are many ways to distribute it, perhaps there are systems that distribute wealth in a more egalitarian manner than capitalism and it would be great to hear some of those ideas. It's well known to most economists that there are definite cases where the free market system does not work well. I didn't even mention free market / communism, let alone construct a straw man. If you think I have please point it out and add to the conversation. If you don't agree with the idea that wealth should be distributed according to contribution then please let us know why. (Seriously, the idea is 300 years old, surely in that time we've found something better) I agree with most people that those unfortunate enough to not be able to provide for themselves due to sickness or disability should be taken care of but I think that's a relatively small amount of money and everyone would agree that that sort of thing should be done.
- wladimir 16y agoIf you don't agree with the idea that wealth should be distributed according to contribution -- I never said that. Wealth should indeed be distributed according to contribution, but contribution is not that easily measurable. There are a lot of things that affect your contribution to society that are not measured by how much money you can take from others. I just don't agree that some people contribute more than 1000 times as much as others. Everyone is human. We all simply play our part. So in my eyes, distributing according to contribution will not result in a that large inequality.
- exit 16y ago> If you don't agree with the idea that wealth should be distributed according to contribution then please let us know why. an individuals contribution is largely a matter of their innate dispositions coinciding with their innate aptitudes coinciding with the particular labor demands at the time in which one is alive. society perpetuates bring people into this world without any guarantee that they will be able to contribute at a certain level. yet you expect that only the individual should carry the burden of that throw of the dice? i put A LOT of effort into training myself as a software developer and now make a reasonable living from that, but i also simply found myself at a young age with a passion for understanding computers and a reasonable aptitude for the kind of thinking involved. other kids found themselves with a disposition for sports, or painting, or french literature, etc., but maybe their aptitude doesn't make the cut in those winner-take-all fields. tragically, other kids simply never find any disposition or aptitude. they don't deserve to be in that position any more than i deserve to be in mine. so yes, there ought to be systems for redistributing wealth from those who are lucky enough to find themselves with financially remunerable dispositions and aptitudes. there ought to be guarantees for certain standards of living, and those standards ought to be damn high given that no one asks to be born, no one asks to be afflicted with attachment to being alive.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- mseebach 16y agoAre there any examples of inequality fueling social unrest in otherwise free countries? The US is frequenty touted as the least equal free country, but social unrest is pretty absent. The unrest there has been (the LA riots and the fight for civil rights) was fueled by pretty blatant cases of non-financial inequality. And are walls to keep out the "poor" really a consequence of inequality?
- onan_barbarian 16y agoI saw this article and thought, I bet it won't be long before someone gets on and says something utterly specious about how this is all entirely to do with entrepreneurship. And behold! This is the standard boneheaded 'I'm on Hacker News and banging on about entrepreneurship and how we're all headed to a beautiful meritocracy, so I will interpret everything that occurs through this lens'. US manufacturing collapses? Entrepreneurship. Estate tax weakened? Entrepreneurship. Growth of low-end service jobs? Entrepreneurship. Entrepreneurship. Entrepreneurship. Entrepreneurship.
- palish 16y agoWould you say all that to his face? Chill out. There's no reason to be nasty.
- onan_barbarian 16y agoYes, I would. I'm happy to use fairly mild words like 'specious' or 'bonehead' to describe a person who has decided to _celebrate_ the rise of income inequality by reinterpreting several decades of complex social and economic changes as having to do with 'entrepreneurship'. It's hard to tell whether the guy is being actively intellectually dishonest (ie. is aware of what the major factors are in increasing inequality but is choosing to ignore them) or simply naive to the point of dimness. Even TFA - an extremely brief treatment of inequality without a definitive focus on the US - offers enough illumination to make it obvious that simply chanting 'yay, this must mean entrepreneurship' in response to this isn't so smart.
- palish 16y agoOccam's razor. You are likely more educated than he is. But why be a douchebag about it? If your goal is to convince people of your point of view, then pissing them off is directly contrary to that. On the other hand, if your goal is to make fun of the dimwits that surround you... It's a fact that the world consists mostly of dimwits. I'm a dimwit about virtually everything, except programming. But it would be much more satisfying for me to teach you something programming-related, rather than to point out how stupid you are for [X programming mistake due to lack of knowledge], don't you think?
- ugh 16y agoThis argument cuts both ways. All OECD countries have some degree of inequality and, as you said, we don't really know what the right amount of inequality is. On the basis of inequality numbers alone, it is not possible to say whether they are good or bad. Where, by the way, do 'these studies' assume that income should be divided equally? That seems like an odd position and I honestly haven't heard very many people except for extremists express it. I think a solid majority accepts (some degree of) income inequality.
- jbri 16y agoWhat about taking money from those who haven't earned it and giving it to those who need it?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- tomjen3 16y agoHe is right, stop d stop downvoting just because you don't agree with him, Instead show why he is wrong or admid he is right.
- crocowhile 16y agoThe countries with highest gini coefficient are USA, Mexico, Brazil, China. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gini_coefficient#Gini_coefficient_of_income_distributions http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gini_coefficient#Gini_coefficie... Does it look to you like there is any correlation in how they all succeed t promote entrepreneurship?
- redthrowaway 16y agoJumping on the socialism badwagon in response to concerns over income inequality is not a well-considered view. The American economy is predicated upon consumerism, which requires a strong middle class. Nobody is saying we should take from the rich and give to the poor, rather we are saying that those [productive] members of society who find themselves marginalized by the increasing polarity of capital are the primary drivers of the economy that produces that capital in the first place. It's not about taxing the rich and giving to the poor, it's about ensuring that the burden if taxation is shared equally and that the benefits thereof are invested in education and other programs that ensure continued competitiveness.
- corin_ 16y agoHave to say that, as soon as I read just the title, my initial reaction was "no shit". I mean, I love America, there's no country of the many I've spent time in that I enjoy being in more, but social equality certainly isn't on the list of reasons I love it. Does anyone have any insight as to why Mexico was at the top of the list of countries with growing inequality?
- palish 16y agoIf I had to guess randomly, I'd say it's because of the drug cartels.
- andrewcooke 16y agoAnd the drug consumers elsewhere, maybe?
- fleitz 16y agoMexico has huge corruption problems, they also have a lot of monopolies and state intervention into commerce. Generally, Mexican citizens have a very low level of economic freedom. Those in Mexico that can easily cross the border often come into America not to seek work but to buy their groceries and other items at a much cheaper price. Yes medication is a lot cheaper in Mexico, but most things are not when you look at comparable quality. http://www.heritage.org/index/country/mexico http://www.heritage.org/index/country/mexico http://www.heritage.org/index/country/unitedstates http://www.heritage.org/index/country/unitedstates http://www.heritage.org/index/country/canada http://www.heritage.org/index/country/canada
- JesseAldridge 16y agoYou really gotta wonder how this is gonna turn out. How are dumb people supposed to earn a living when technology makes all the jobs for dumb people obsolete? I guess we'll have a huge class of people that will basically get free money through the state. But maybe that won't be so bad since wealth will be so abundant?
- photophotoplasm 16y ago> How are dumb people supposed to earn a living when technology makes all the jobs for dumb people obsolete? So we're just assuming it will?
- lionhearted 16y ago> You really gotta wonder how this is gonna turn out. How are dumb people supposed to earn a living when technology makes all the jobs for dumb people obsolete? Every time new automation is invented, people think is going to happen. Seriously, this goes back to pre-Industrial Revolution times. Any time part of the labor process is automated away, people think that there's going to be permanent economic damage, and they're consistently wrong. We'll adapt. There's always new things to be done. Personally, I'm betting on a greater diversity of creative and artistic work happening - people in core industries that are going to remain and grow in profitability (technology, raw materials, energy, consumer goods, construction, etc) will have more surplus income to spend on personalization, customization, different and more unique kinds of entertainment, etc. We're going to seem a massive boom in people able to make a basic living from pure creative professions enabled. There'll also be more personal services offered. Ideally a lot of ineffective governmental costs can be optimized down, and more of government spending can go to refining and cleaning up the environment too, planting more trees and flora and fauna, things like that. I think a lot of excellent jobs that don't exist today are going to be created. I also think many more people will learn basic technology skills than perhaps is commonly thought. A few hundred years ago, no one - and I mean no one - would have believed you if you told them what literacy rates would be in developed countries. They just wouldn't think it possible. So, more people will get on the tech bandwagon as time passes and kids grow up with it. Computer literacy will become like language literacy. Good things are happening man, we're living in the greatest era ever. God damn I'm so optimistic and grateful to be alive right now.
- pelle 16y agoMy main response is So? Really it is well understood that the main reason for high unequality in the US is relatively high numbers of poort immigrants. I'd say that is a good thing, not a bad thing.
- andrewcooke 16y agois that true? i don't have any data, but i don't think it is. my understanding is that immigrants in the usa typically move quite quickly up the social scale. your problem is that you have a large class of americans who have somehow got locked out of any progress.
- jasonkester 16y agoSo, among this list of "societies with hardly any inequality", America is at the top. Not really a surprise. They sort of tip their hand by including Mexico, which should probably be on the "societies with a bit more inequality than the West" list instead. If you included every nation in the world, I wouldn't be surprised to see the USA still sitting sixteen places from the right.
- redthrowaway 16y agoAmongst first-world, developed nations, the us has the highest inequality. Developing nations, with a rich established elite, little to no middle class, and a massive lower class will obviously score worse than the us. They are not, however, the countries by which we should judge ourselves. Look to the productive nations of the world for an apt comparison, and you will see that the us is an outlier with an ever-richer upper class and a shrinking middle class. This brings the us in line with developing countries, which is hardly where it should aim to be if the goal is long-term sustainable growth, the benefits of which are not limited to a select few.
- jasonkester 16y agoExactly my point. Among nations with hardly any inequality, America may not compare so great, but it's still a nation with hardly any inequality. Go to downtown Portland today and you'll find young people from middle class families living on the streets by choice. That's how good our safety net is. You really can't get yourself into the same sort of poverty that you see in most of the world here. In most places, being poor means you're likely to die of starvation in the near future. In the US (and other countries on that chart), it means you can't afford a new television this year. So sure, there's always room for improvement. But it's a bit silly to compare the USA to places that actually have a big divide between rich and poor.
- thirdusername 16y agoSingapore beats America as the highest income inequal first-world developed country by a small margin. It's got a ginni coffecient of 47.8 vs Americas 45. https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/fields/2172.html https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/...
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- arethuza 16y agoI suspect that if you took the EU as a whole it probably have a much higher amount of inequality than any one of its constituent states as the differences between these states are currently ignored (and they are pretty big - compare the GDP per capita of Luxembourg ($81,800) and Bulgaria ($12,800)).
- corin_ 16y agoBut within the EU they aren't "states" they are "countries". It would be just as logical to take the Americas together and see how inequality looks when you're spanning from the top end of USA to the bottom end of Columbia.
- arethuza 16y agoStricly speaking that is true - but there is free movement within the EU - someone from one EU member state can live and work in any other member state (with some temporary restrictions for states that have just joined) - so they aren't like other countries. Also member states have already given up a lot of their sovereignty to the EU. We are continually told that the US is a terribly unequal society - I'm just curious how things would work out if you took something like the EU (higher GDP, much higher population) and compared it to the US. Note that I am a European, I'm generally pro-EU but I think Europeans generally unfairly criticize the US in this area when we actually live in an increasingly shared society that clearly has its own issues with inequality.
- orijing 16y agoGood point. It may seem intuitively true given that the constituent states in the EU are probably as diverse as those in the US. However, the US had a Gini of 45 [1] while the EU had a Gini of 30 [2], suggesting that despite the vast differences among the European states, overall they are more equal. The reason is that countries like Luxembourg are very small (in population), and Europe as a while is dominated primarily by countries like France, Germany and England where individually income distributions are vastly more equal than in the US. [1] https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/us.html https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/... [2] https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/ee.html https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/...
- olalonde 16y agoInequality of outcome is a small price to pay for liberty. Milton Friedman has some interesting thoughts on the subject: Friedman and Sowell on Equality http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WJBeuR0xEP8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WJBeuR0xEP8 Milton Friedman - Redistribution of Wealth http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MRpEV2tmYz4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MRpEV2tmYz4
- spicycat 16y agoIf you're rich and not happy, inequality probably is a large part of why. The richer you get, the smaller the group of people exists that shares your problems... and the smaller your pool of potential friends becomes.
- hootmon 16y agoAll the snobby effete commenters who write off this trend, just wait until enough people are marginalized and they decide to do something about it.
- olalonde 16y agoLast time I checked libertarianism and free market capitalism is what's growing in popularity, not socialism. http://www.theatlanticwire.com/global/2010/09/cuba-lays-off-500-000-major-shift-to-a-free-market/23054/ http://www.theatlanticwire.com/global/2010/09/cuba-lays-off-... http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,2043235,00.html http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,2043235,00.htm... http://www.nolanchart.com/article8623_If_You_Pit_Ron_Paul_Against_Obama_They_Are_Virtually_Dead_Even.html http://www.nolanchart.com/article8623_If_You_Pit_Ron_Paul_Ag...
- olalonde 16y agoRemind HN: Down voting isn't meant to express disagreement.
- corin_ 16y agoThat pretty much went out the window quite a while ago, I'd estimate that nearly all down votes on HN are used for that purpose. It's just more visible when on a political topic than a tech topic.
- decadentcactus 16y agoThere was an episode of QI where this was mentioned (can't find the video now). It basically said the "happiest" countries (as best you can measure it) were the ones with the lowest income inequalities (like Nordic countries).
- olalonde 16y agoMight not be a causality relationship though.
- mseebach 16y agoAnd then there's the strongly subjective nature of happiness. Can you really compare the happiness of a Norwegian and a Texan in any meaningful way?
- pasbesoin 16y agoI don't have studies at hand to cite, but there seem to be a growing number of them indicating or demonstrating that a significant portion of humans' cognitive ability goes into making (instantaneous, sub-conscious) comparisons. Contentment seems to be more a matter of "keeping up" and "as good as" than some sort of absolute measure. From an evolutionary perspective, this might -- speculation -- involve the individual ensuring they are still valued by and a member of community. If you aren't doing well within the community, you are at risk.
- pitdesi 16y agohttp://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/01/31/the-haves-and-the-have-nots/ http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/01/31/the-haves-and-t... This chart puts inequality in some perspective for me... The poorest Americans are still in the 68th percentile for world-wide inequality. I suspect that if you charted European countries on this map, the line would start higher and end lower than the US, hence their lower Gini.
- yason 16y agoWhen talking about this kind of inequality we usually mean financial inequality. Given a society where everyone at least has the possibility to have a home, have food, and live a decent life (i.e. not do 16 hours of work per day or be applied a different legislation for different people), I don't care how inequal we are or how many hundred or thousand times more an executive makes than the employee with the lowest salary. "Fixing" a society by making it more "equal", mainly to shrink the income distribution, doesn't magically help the poormost. Any "fixes" to the wealth distribution are likely to sift down only to the nearest classes in the continuum: the acquisition of any wealth extracted from rich would be a task easiest for upper middle class. Humans are likely to always form into a number of "lower" and "upper" groups: if we can't do it with money, we do it by some intangible property such as ancestry or nobility. Compared to those, I much prefer money. Conversely, a person doesn't need much: we only need to guarantee some minimal standard of living, should a citizen wish to receive it, and we can afford that if we wanted. There's no reason to try and take on the impossible task of "fixing" inequality: unless we gave an equal salary to everyone we would still have some people who form the poormost group. The only thing that does matter is how well the poormost are doing. We can fix that if we want. Compared to them everyone else is doing just fine, equality or inequality, more Porsches or less Porsches.
- quadhome 16y agoBut where can I find numbers on income mobility?
- SteveJS 16y agoThe paper this points to is the "OECD FORUM ON TACKLING INEQUALITY". (capitalization in the paper) Post-colonic: "What drives it and how can policy tackle it?" (I had to decapitalize.) The paper explores a large number of factors, but it is diffult to see how the base premise is anything other than Inequality needs to be 'tackled'. Where destruction of the middle class is happening, that needs to be tackled. Extreme poverty needs to be tackled. Creation of a middle class in countries that lack it needs to be tackled. Inequality, however, is a metric, and one that is oblivious to whether things are getting better or worse. Successfully tackling inequality says nothing about whether the lives of people have gotten better or worse, it merely tracks uniformity of outcome. I'm very supportive of policies that prevent social instablity, and poor outcomes. My libertarian streak is weak at best, and centered around a distaste for government interfering in social policy. I'm unhappy with framing this metric as problem, because it easily falls into the trap of helping make people unhappy with otherwise good outcomes. The metric used is inherently oblivous to outcomes that I think matter. Churchill's "The inherent vice of capitalism is the unequal sharing of blessings; the inherent virtue of socialism is the equal sharing of miseries." applies here. I can agree we should have distributive tax policies due to falling real wages at the bottom, yet that point is obliterated by starting the debate with a relative metric that I do not agree should drive the policy.