4 ms·
> ... an “all star” culture, with mostly young white and Asian men. Up until yesterday I was very confused at how a tech company could be accused of racism whi
by roenxi 6y ago
> ... an “all star” culture, with mostly young white and Asian men.
Up until yesterday I was very confused at how a tech company could be accused of racism while simultaneously having a (presumably) vast over-representation of Asians who - to the surprise of some - are a minority.
I have since learned [0] that there are literally a large group of people who have redefined "racism" to "unequal distribution of privileges between white people and people of color".
I think it would be necessary for the NYT to be using that definition here to distinguish this from an ordinary labour dispute. I've seen non-black teams where half or more the people quit.
[0] https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/white-fragility-definition https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/white-fragility-de...
- mattmanser 6y agoYou can be accepting of one race and still be racist against another. Racism means discrimination against a particular group or groups. It's not mutually exclusive, you don't get a free pass for thinking Asians are great while still persecuting Black people. So you're the one redefining the meaning of the word.
- SamReidHughes 6y agoNo, he's defining the meaning as you put it, or compatibly with it. And taking the claims in the article at face value -- not people's feelings, but the specific facts asserted -- it's clear Coinbase hasn't been persecuting black people.
- mattmanser 6y agoNo, this is exactly what he said, laid out in argument form: Premise 1: Tech companies are often accused of racism (any, not coinbase, neither of us mentioned coinbase) Premise 2: Tech companies often contain a much larger % of Asians, a minority Premise 3: (implied) having a disproportionate % of any one minority makes you non-racist Conclusion: Therefore Tech companies are not racist The conclusion does not follow because premise 3 is wrong. You can be racist about other minorities even while enthusiastically supporting one minority group.
- SamReidHughes 6y agoPremise 3 was not implied.
- mattmanser 6y agoThen why is he "very confused at how a tech company could be accused of racism"?
- roenxi 6y agoMy definition of racism (which I did not share, despite it being the source of much debate) is discrimination against a particular group or groups on the basis of their heritage (ie, stuff outside their control). So I was confused, because companies (like Coinbase) are being asked to discriminate by raising black employees to an especially high-status position vs, eg, Asians, then getting called racist when they do not. But if the definition of racism was redefined to "unequal distribution of privileges between white people and people of color" then the accusations make sense.
- tyrust 6y agoYou're right, it wasn't implied: it was explicitly stated.
- SamReidHughes 6y agoIt wasn't explicitly stated, either.
- tyrust 6y agoI think mattmanser has argued the point well. The first paragraph is the OP saying that the company cannot [0] be racist since they (might) have a disproportionate number of one minority under their employment. [0] - "cannot without causing the OP confusion", at least
- 6y ago
- ramraj07 6y agoAsian who spent a decade in Texas - numerous occassions where blatantly racist people would consider me as "one of the good ones" and ask questions like "why are Indians so smart?"; There are the good races and then there are the bad ones you see! In fact the racist ones were especially nice to Asians to try to emphasize they're not blindly racist, just against the criminals and illegals!