7 ms·
A few ways to make money in FOSS
- verdverm 6y agoDiscovered this via a tweet: https://twitter.com/asynchio/status/1332399494634225664 https://twitter.com/asynchio/status/1332399494634225664 I've been personally thinking about such things recently and found Drew's article reassuring that not needing to think like a unicorn is OK. Having taken a step back from raising funding has been freeing. Witnessing what it can do to companies, I worried what it would do to my OSS ethos. Still, to make something people love takes effort and money can help a lot. Projects I work on for the interested: - https://github.com/cuelang/cue https://github.com/cuelang/cue - https://github.com/hofstadter-io https://github.com/hofstadter-io
- koeng 6y agoYour github link for cuelang gives a 404. I've been interested in cuelang for a while but just haven't found a real use case for it. For validating incoming data, JSON Schemas tend to do the trick and are widely distributed, and for things like Kubernetes YAMLs I usually just edit the YAML itself. Keeps it simple. Any cool use cases I should check out?
- verdverm 6y agoThanks, fixed the link. Cool use cases: I'm personally using Cue for representing DSLs for code generation. Cue can be used to reduce the configuration size and boilerplate. You can 'cue import' your JSONSchema and remove repeat sections. Because Cue is assoc. / comm., the order you merge in does not matter. 'cue get go' enables you to import Go types into configuration automatically. There work towards making Cue an language of translation for configuration / types. Something where you can get others from any of the supported (json, yaml, jsonschema, openapi, protobuf, golang) The scripting layer just got an upgrade, to support "flow" based programming. Haven't looked at it myself yet, hoping to soon. There are several projects in the DevOps world. A docker alum is up to something. Another group has Cue-ified CloudFormation: https://github.com/TangoGroup/cfn-cue https://github.com/TangoGroup/cfn-cue I can see helm being replaced with a pure-Cue solution.
- koeng 6y agoI didn't know the 'cue get go', that could be very useful for a Go project I'm working on. Thanks!
- bjelkeman-again 6y agoI, sort of, turned it around. We found something that needed doing, got financing for it and then decided to release it open source. It is not a big thing in the open source community, but it has helped a lot of people who don’t even use software. Among other things we have helped communities, NGOs and governments map rural water supply where this isn’t a sure thing to exist or be safe to drink, for more than 100 million people. Then this data is used to support investments at country or regional level to improve the situation.
- pickledcods 6y agoHow about a new type of licence. If you contribute to FOSS its copyleft, otherwise if you want to use it closed source its a copyright 10% revenue based commercial licence.
- cercatrova 6y agoThat's not really FOSS, if I get it from someone else who did contribute to the project, which they can share with me under their FOSS license, then I just bypassed your commercial license legally.
- pickledcods 6y agoYou can catch that with a pass-on clause. The idea behind this is to stop commercially exploitation of your contribution to FOSS with intention to keep everything for themselves and keeping the FOSS philosophy for those who do care.
- cercatrova 6y agoThe problem with all of these kinds of FOSS-but-not-really is that, well, they're not really FOSS, only ostensibly so. Companies would have every right to use FOSS themselves, so it's not really the FOSS philosophy, it's something else. In that case, just make it source available or even proprietary, just don't call it open source.
- ThrowawayR2 6y agoThat's just a proprietary license with source code available, the same kind of thing that companies get mocked for "expecting free labor to help them make money" on HN.
- fhrhsfwdrj 6y agoIsn't it the dual-license that for e.g QT does ? (LGPL for open source projects, Commercial licence for closed source projects)
- 6y ago
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago3) try a pay tunnel approach, in which pre-built binaries of your GPL'ed source code are available for a name-your-price amount. Source code remains freely available at no cost at all times. (thanks to Radiohead's In Rainbows release for the inspiration) 4) try a modestly priced subscription approach. Try to be 100% clear that this is not a licensing system, but rather enables you (and others) to keep developing the software. [ EDIT: essentially, Patreon but hopefully without another 3rd party middleman. ] Works for us at ardour.org (on the order of $200k this year, through a combination of donations, 3 and 4 above).
- blackrock 6y agoCongrats! It’s quite the achievement to sell $200,000 worth of software. But this is only enough to sustain 1 Software Engineer. Are you able to raise this up to $1 million? Or $10 million? Or is your niche software forever relegated to $200,000?
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThose of us involved are not interested in such goals. Also, we've received much more income than that. Ardour is more than 20 years old at this point, and generating revenue for more than 12 years. Also, your estimation of how much a software engineer earns would be fairly humorous anywhere except a few major tech centers in a few western nations.
- boogies 6y ago> Patreon but hopefully without another 3rd party middleman https://liberapay.com/ https://liberapay.com/ is a great 3rd party middleman / alternative to Patreon that doesn’t take a cut of payments (so arguably the best of all worlds).
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThey state that they use Stripe and PayPal as payment processors. Not clear to me why someone would want to use an additional layer, although it is nice that they take an additional cut of payments on top of the processor.
- fhrhsfwdrj 6y ago> you’re unlikely to make a living from donations Blender gets 135.000$/month through donations & sponsors Godot hires 4 full time employees through donations Krita got 4.200$ donation for this month (not sure about the other months) Ardour seems to have 11.500$/month etc. I agree it is hard to reach a stable income through donations & sponsors but some open source project managed to do so, and I hope other will in the future. There still room for many "Blender of XXX" (in the sense of a flagship FLOSS that is competitive with proprietary solutions). I'd say Godot is well on the path of being the "Blender of Game Engines". But there is still room for the Blender of Photo editing (Gimp is far behind Photoshop), the Blender of Vector/UX (inkscape is not on part with Figma/Illustrator), the Blender of Music (Ardour is nice but UX wise not as "modern" as Ableton or Bitwig), etc. For someone who has some time + a strong commitment to pretty UX & clean architecture, I think there might be still my opportunities for donations & sponsors driven projects
- hajimemash 6y agoDonations is like.. create $1m of value, get $100 in donations
- thayne 6y agoThe way I wish software development worked was that the norm was paying for the development itself, rather than for the resulting software. Meaning instead of paying for a license you either pay for the development of bug fixes and features you want, or bid towards a pool for them. I know bounty programs exist, but from what I understand they have not been terribly successful.
- generalizations 6y agoWhat I've run into as well is free software, where the source is available but the process of building it into something usable would take "months" of work, and the internal toolchain (old software versions, patched packages, etc) is only vaguely documented. Effectively, it's a 'moat' around the business, and allows the business to get the best of both worlds: association with the open source community, and effectively proprietary software. The actual business plan can then treat the software as an exclusive asset (not in a technical, legal, sense, but de facto for sure). I'm not saying it's a bad model; it's probably one of the few that can provide a reliable income, and it gives outside developers a 'fighting chance' at accessing the value of the software.