7 ms·
> ... apple tried to ditch all GPL software so that they wouldn't have to upstream anything if they don't want to. A side point: it was the patent clause of th
by gumby 6y ago
> ... apple tried to ditch all GPL software so that they wouldn't have to upstream anything if they don't want to.
A side point: it was the patent clause of the GPL v3 that frightened them off. The GPL doesn’t require “upstreaming” of anything — you merely have to release the source code you used; any use of that code by another person is that person’s responsibility.
More generally on Apple: they just treat open / proprietary as another tactical tool. When they were on the ropes (e.g. late 90s) they happily embraced open standards like mp3 and jpeg, yet also happily purchased a license to .rtf. They quickly realized the ipod needed Windows support. Then as (and where) they became stronger they stoped caring.
- xenadu02 6y agoI seem to recall a wide variety of people objected to the patent clause during discussions on the GPLv3. Quite a few companies won't touch GPLv3 software which is unfortunate because it was gaining a lot of momentum at the time.
- krrrh 6y agoMP3 wasn’t an open standard. They paid licensing fees to the Fraunhofer institute like every other commercial vendor.