26 ms·
To put it in context, this is a Canadian magazine, and here in Canada the housing market is just absolutely insanely irrational. There has been no downwards hou
by cmrdporcupine 6y ago
To put it in context, this is a Canadian magazine, and here in Canada the housing market is just absolutely insanely irrational. There has been no downwards housing price "correction" since the early 90s. The 2008 bubble-pop never happened here. Interest rates remain at record lows and the COVID-19 crisis seems to have led to massive _increase_ in housing prices rather than a decrease. It's a huge distorted market with real estate, construction, and renovations etc. being the largest part of our Ontario provincial economy with primary industry, etc. declining every year. It all feels just insane.
My little hobby farm has probably "doubled" in the 8.5 years I've owned it, but I don't feel great about it -- where will my kids live? Where will I retire to? When will this all blow up in our faces? My 70 year old father in law would love to retire, and sell his place and somehow reduce his costs and move closer to us... but my area has become completely unaffordable as Toronto money is suddenly blowing up the market out here with bidding wars and no-conditions offers and the like, stuff we never saw before.
So yeah in that context I can't even imagine being working class and trying to make a go of it. It was bad before, but it is only getting worse. Rents are absolutely mental even in outlying areas that should be cheap.
And most importantly given that these outlying areas around Toronto (Hamilton, Oshawa, London, Cambridge, Woodstock etc.) are often where the few remaining manufacturing sector jobs are, what happens to the manufacturing sector when their employees can no longer afford housing near the factory?
- refurb 6y agoThis is a problem that will solve itself. Sure, it will be a painful few decades, but we've already seen that shift. Toronto used to be the cluster of high prices homes, now it's spread all the way down to Hamilton. That process will continue - people will purchase homes in lower cost areas and businesses won't have much choice but to hire closer to those locations as well. That's of course ignoring the potential for some major housing correction in Canada which resets the clock somewhat. It's not like it hasn't before. I had family buy a home in a Toronto suburb in the 1980's. They sold at the peak in 1990 and the housing market crashed hard. Prices didn't recover until the mid-2000's.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoIt has spread far beyond Hamilton. You have to get as far as St Catharines/Niagara before prices start looking closer to affordable for middle class incomes. And forget about going north, my father in law is in Barrie, and fairly modest homes on his street are going well over $700k. That's almost as much as I paid for this 6 acre "estate" 8 years ago, and by my calculation with a 25 year amortization and with a very low interest rate and following the "housing not over 30% of pre-tax earnings" that works out to a required household income of $130k. That's not anywhere close to average household income in Canada, which is more like $90k, and there are certainly very few high paying jobs in Barrie itself and it is only marginally commutable to Toronto.
- holstvoogd 6y ago> The 2008 bubble-pop never happened here. I live in the Netherlands and that seems to be roughly what happened here too. ~~I mean, yes the prices have dropped a tiny bit around 2008, but in 2009 they were at an all time high again and have not come down.~~ EDIT: This was a lie, turns out they bottomed out around 2013 at ~25% below the 2008 peak. I live in a 'provincial' city, where prices are ~40-50% of what you might see in the big cities (i.e Amsterdam). With my income, which is well above median, only about 20-30% (2 to 3 % at median income according to the news iirc) of the homes that go on sale are within my mortgage limit. And to solve the on going housing shortages they are building a few new neighborhoods where, surprise, surprise, all houses start at 2 or 3 times that limit... I have read that one of the reasons this happens, is that _everyone_ expect the buyer is better of if prices are higher. Thus brokers, appraiser and sellers all keep driving up the prices. As long as there are more buyers than houses this will keep driving up prices. And the big building companies, that do entire neighborhoods, are quite happy to keep the market scarce.
- adflux 6y agoI also live in the Netherlands. I am starting to believe there is something a bit more nefarious at play here. Anyone who is in power owns a house. Anyone who owns a house profits from house prices increasing. Who benefits if house prices go down? A select few, who are currently unable to buy a house. There is little incentive to actually start building affordable housing. Actually, most people who already own house(s) are probably very happy with the way the market is currently working.
- bojan 6y agoAs a house owner in the NL, yes, it is comfortable to know that if I ever need to, I have room to increase my mortgage or sell my house at the considerable win. But then what? I still need to live somewhere, and the rest of the houses are also getting more expensive. And in any case, some of my taxes are based on the value of my house - meaning, they are increasing every year. The only people really benefiting from this are people owning multiple houses with the purpose of renting them.
- 6y ago
- dirtyid 6y agoHousing pressure in the few "tier1" Canadian cities like Toronto will only rise, especially with immigration and presumably inflation from covid debt. Simply too many transnational millionaires and too few cities in Canada with opportunities.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lanevorockz 6y agoSimple, more immigration means people need more homes. That's why the term house crisis doesn't make any sense. It's all artificial and made up by the government.
- bjarneh 6y agoThat sounds incredibly similar to all "large" cities in Norway.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoIn the United States, a common refrain is that the housing crisis is caused by a failure to build, in particular a failure to build up. That failure to build is usually blamed on regulation. That's a harder argument to make in Toronto. Toronto is a sea of construction cranes, almost all building apartment or condo towers, and it has been like this for at least a decade. Toronto has a third of all construction cranes in North America: https://www.blogto.com/real-estate-toronto/2020/10/toronto-construction-cranes-north-america/ https://www.blogto.com/real-estate-toronto/2020/10/toronto-c... And despite the narrative that people are moving away from downtown apartments during COVID, prices on downtown Toronto condos are still rising. Volume has dropped dramatically so I suppose it is possible that it will still crash, but I won't believe it until I see it.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoFailure to build is definitely not the issue, and that's why I posted here because people were talking about how this article was missing the mark, based on their Silicon Valley etc. experiences. The reality is that western countries are making on the whole fairly terrible macroeconomic decisions for the long run. They are putting primacy on real estate assets for the upper middle class, and undermining their own long run primary industry capacity by making housing for working class people unaffordable. It's all short term decision making made by a minority of moderately wealthy people whose own interests run contrary to the needs of the majority.
- dirtyid 6y ago>Toronto has a third of all construction cranes in North America Toronto can have all the cranes in the world and it won't really matter because construction industry cannot keep up. I think the city(not GTA) has grown 500k in the past 20 years (2.5M -> 3M), condo units only increased 200k (100k -> 300k), other new housing marginal. The fundamental problem isn't even that there's too much demand, but the west are incapable of building. If we're going to outsource manufacturing abroad, domestic agriculture to migrant farmers, might as well import some Chinese construction who can build a million unit ghost city in a few years. E: post too fast @dghlsakjg The only saving grace in Toronto condo construction is many of them maybe as shoddy as Chinese construction and hopefully will fall into disrepair and replaced before their life spans. >Chinese building practices assume a certain disposability That's Japanese residential construction. Chinese construction meme is lack of quality control which implies durability problems. But it's a meme, housing stock too new to really generalize on. My personal experience (worked adjacent industry in both markets) is some of the Toronto new constructs are experiencing much quality issues sooner than Chinese developments. Chinese build so much that they can build well if incentivized too. In terms of cheap, fast, good... Canadian developers simply don't have a fast mode... nor a cheap mode... and frequently not even good. China can at least get you fast & cheap or fast & good.
- smallnamespace 6y ago> where will my kids live In all likelihood, they will either need your help to buy a house, or be content with renting. If you think real estate prices have ballooned in Canada, wait until you see what rental appreciation was like in tier 1 cities in China — easily 10x - 20x price appreciation over a few decades. Price per square foot in Beijing is 'competitive' with world cities like Toronto, NYC, London, etc., but average wages in China are maybe ~1000-1500 USD per month equivalent. So yes, parents help their kids in China. If the government is unable to effective do wealth redistribution, then families have to do it.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoI have no problem helping my kids but the reality is even with my Googler income I will probably have to sell this place and move somewhere cheaper/remoter in order to have the retirement lifestyle I want. And if my kids are living with me, that will in all likelihood reduce their income potential. And if they're not living with me, I'll be having to fund them living in a more expensive area.
- dghlsakjg 6y agoAs a recent immigrant to Canada it sort of terrifies me how irrational the market is. That said, I'm buying a house. I moved from Seattle and it is utterly bizarre to me that housing in Vancouver is more expensive than Seattle, while also offering significantly lower pay. My hot take is that most of the rulemakers (politicians), are property owners, and are unwilling to take the drastic steps needed to put the brakes on. My solution is to take drastic steps to increase supply. The empty homes tax in Vancouver was a good step for rentals, but I think it should be punishingly high since I suspect that cheating is rampant. I also think that the permitting and building process should be inverted; any project that follows zoning rules should allowed by default, and it shouldn't take months or years to get permitting approved. If I'm allowed to go hog-wild I also think that anyone that supports historic 'character' neighborhoods should have to live the full historic lifestyle. If you fight density on 'historic' grounds you should also be forced to sell your price for the 'historic' price, use 'historic' appliances, and earn 'historic' pay.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoOn the supply front, both Toronto and Vancouver have densified _significantly_ over the last 10-20 years, with condo construction in Vancouver completely off the charts. It seems to have done little to alleviate issues. Immigration combined with net migration into the city is a big part of it, I guess. But I am not convinced this is entirely an issue of supply constraints, as high pricing is no longer confined to the largest metro zones.
- dghlsakjg 6y agoThere are a lot of issues, and densification is certainly happening in the downtown cores, but I don't believe it is enough to keep up with the demands put on it by population increases. More anecdata: I live walking distance to Downtown Vancouver, and within a block of 4 bus routes. There is an empty lot next to me that has been in the permitting process for more than two years for a lowrise mixed-use building. I wouldn't be surprised if the cost imposed by the permitting process is close to $1mm when you factor in interest, salaries to hire the people who know people at city hall, the cost of the actual permits, etc. Other things that factor heavily are cheap money (interest rates are lower than inflation on mortgages right now, around 1.7%), cultural normalization (buying a home for 10x your yearly income is considered normal), lack of opportunity outside of cities.