6 ms·
A New Theory of Western Civilization
- vixen99 6y agoLarry Siedentop's 'Inventing the Individual: The Origins of Western Liberalism' takes a different slant on this topic. To quote from a review: he argues that 'liberal thought is the offspring of Christianity and that it is Christian moral beliefs that are the ultimate source of the social revolution that has made the West what it is.'.
- throw0101a 6y agoThis is basically what the book discussed in the article also argues: specifically the (Catholic) Church's “Marriage and Family Program” (MFP) forced a move away from tribal/clan thinking that most human societies start with and continue with. It's why there are very few "honour killings" in more Westernized societies: non-WEIRD cultures need to restore the family's reputation from the actions of an individual. While in WEIRD cultures it is only the individual's reputation that suffers, not the parents'/relatives'.
- zozbot234 6y agoI'm not sure what's supposed to be "new" about this theory. The idea that the ancient Church's prohibition on cousin marriage might have incented cooperation across clan lines is not novel in itself.
- bluetomcat 6y agoIt's a game-changing paradigm when you put it in perspective to most other contemporary non-Western societies where kinship, long-term friendships and intergenerational family obligations are forming the fabric of society. In the west, individuals are much more autonomous and that enables more effective social associations where people are gathering in groups based on their levels of competence, interests and views.
- zozbot234 6y agoOf course the idea has plenty of merit; I'm just saying that social scientists have been aware of it for a long time, and it's a bit strange to describe it as "new". See e.g. [0] which is cited in the wiki article on cousin marriage. [0] Woodley, Michael A.; Edward Bell (2013). "Consanguinity as a Major Predictor of Levels of Democracy: A Study of 70 Nations". Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology. 44 (2): 263–280. doi:10.1177/0022022112443855. S2CID 145714074.
- throw0101a 6y agoI think perhaps "new" to the mainstream specifically. While book is ~700 pages, about ~200 of that is end notes and the bibliography: the author [1] is simply collecting all the most recent findings in one place and putting forward a thesis to the public that seems to have a bit of a consensus in academia. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Henrich https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Henrich
- bserge 6y agoThat sounds nice and all, except "kinship, long-term friendships and intergenerational family obligations" is still forming the fabric of western societies and up to as late as the 1960's (and even later), most people were not freely able to "gather in groups based on their levels of competence, interests and views". Western liberalism and individual freedom is really a very recent development. Just 100 years ago, people were being forced to work on ships, in factories, on farms, in wars and 3-4 generations living in one home was normal. Just 60 years ago, many people were heavily discriminated against and had little freedom. Imo, these "more effective social associations" just lead to an increase in mental problems and perhaps ultimately, to the unraveling of such societies. Long term *ships are good, the focus on hyper efficiency just means more and more people are being left behind, and groups simply have no idea what other groups are thinking or how to work with them. See all the antimaskers, antivaxxers, authoritarian supporters. All dismissed as stupid/irrelevant and considered a minority by the other side. And vice versa. The reality is different, but there's such a disconnect that no one knows how to fix this.
- 6y ago
- rjsw 6y agoI wonder whether societally enforced monogamy might be important too in creating a WIERD culture.
- est31 6y agoI think so, yes. Polygamy creates structures where high status men have multiple wives, and low status men don't get any wives at all. Those low status men then get frustrated and destabilize societies by causing war etc. See: https://www.economist.com/the-economist-explains/2018/03/19/why-polygamy-breeds-civil-war https://www.economist.com/the-economist-explains/2018/03/19/...
- dragonelite 6y agoNothing more dangerous then males aged 16~30 in their physical prime sexually frustrated and access to weapons.
- theFco 6y agoI that includes a very narrow form of polygamy. In particular, that men are the only ones allowed to take multiple partners. In a form of polygamy where everyone gets to take multiple partners it is exactly the opposite. Everyone is always available to form bonds with whom they want. This notion of being "taken" in marriage is what breaks polygamy.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ta8645 6y agoThat ignores the reality of reproduction with a woman giving birth to a child of only one male. There is very little reason for one man to raise the child of another man in such a situation where multiple new partners are available without any obligations. The traditional form of polygamy comes from the natural forces of nature, not oppression.
- 6y ago
- F2hn 6y agoWe are heading to New era of communism. We are walking with masks on our face to believe, that these masonic one world order leaders gonna save us. Left or Right, it doesn't matter both playing same end game. As good obedient citizen we are, we judge people who dare to questioning the direction of our world. Believe in Google twitter and Facebook, they censoring opinions to protect you from anybody who is not aligned with the agenda. HN shadow ban again my account. So much of been innovative and open for ideas.
- LatteLazy 6y agoI'm not sure anyone every took this seriously. Here in Anglo-Saxon Essex, my uncle married his (1st) cousin in a Catholic ceremony some time around 1980...