3 ms·
I am absolutely fine with origin naming legal defenses. You can’t sell something as though it was made somewhere when it wasn’t. That is an entirely different
by colechristensen 6y ago
I am absolutely fine with origin naming legal defenses. You can’t sell something as though it was made somewhere when it wasn’t.
That is an entirely different issue than using naming rights to prevent people from making a similar agricultural product somewhere else, or sharing information about it using the name.
The rights should extend to product labeling and thats it, and they do. This C&D to a youtuber is comical.
- olliej 6y agoWhy does origin naming only apply to "fancy" products from France and Italy - cheddar originates in England, but no one claims that cheese made exactly the same way elsewhere isn't cheddar.
- colechristensen 6y agoOrigin naming protections are all over the place. In fact “ West Country Farmhouse Cheddar” is a protected name. Another example is bourbon whiskey, it must be produced in the US out of 51% corn in a certain kind of barrel in order to carry the name.
- olliej 6y agoWhat makes “ West Country Farmhouse Cheddar” different from "West Country Farmhouse Grana Padano"? By the logic that leads to WCFC, Grana Padano shouldn't be protected. Only "Piacenza Grana Padano" should be. It is an identical situation: a method of making cheese, with an origin in a specific area. I can make cheese the same way, using the same ingredients for both cheeses, but one I can call cheddar, and the other I have to call "Not Grana Padano".