5 ms·
Rule of thumb: Keep yourself as smart as possible but your items as dumb as possible.
by markus_zhang 6y ago
Rule of thumb: Keep yourself as smart as possible but your items as dumb as possible.
- userbinator 6y agoOn the other hand, it seems most companies want the exact opposite --- the more clueless lusers they can extract profits from, the better. A lot of people are still surprised when they hear that I work in the tech industry, but don't have - and recommend against - "smart"[1] devices in my house. The majority of my appliances are simple and robust without any computers or electronics, have lasted several decades, and will likely continue functioning for many more. [1] With the exception of a single smartphone which is rooted, not constantly within arms' reach, and kept off most of the time.
- catlifeonmars 6y agoWhat is the advantage of this strategy?
- FooHentai 6y agoThe strategy of locking consumers into a perpetual upgrade cycle? Profit and control. The strategy of purchasing long-lasting, simpler devices? Cost saving over the long term and independence.
- Nition 6y agoHonestly, despite the claims of IoT devices, usually time saving too. Time saved in setup, time saved in maintenance, sometimes even time saved just in general use.
- zakki 6y agoCreating cult.
- afrojack123 6y agoYour an idiot. The cult of idiocracy.
- Barrin92 6y agonot having to deal with distractions, malfunctioning devices, and over time saving quite a substantial amount of money I suppose. The purpose of technology is to enhance and improve human interaction. When technology is perfect it is invisible. These smart devices are in a sense anti-technology, they're gadgets that occupy people's time and attention and get in the way. The only product in the last decade that actually in my opinion is smart is the Kindle (or equivalent ereaders). It's like having a thousand books I can carry around with the weight of one, it lasts forever, I don't need a light to read, and otherwise I can forget that it is technology and actually just read books.
- Nition 6y agoKindle's 2007, it's in the same decade as modern smartphones. I'm struggling to think of any new tech product from this decade that's really improved general life. I'm not that cynical, there's gotta be something. Maybe modern dashcams?
- verisimilidude 6y agoIt's optimizing for a different type of convenience. If I get a smart toaster, such as the Revolution Cooking Smart Toaster, then I'll get a bunch of nifty features: touchscreen controls, notifications on my phone when the slice is toasted, etc. It'll be nice and a lot of fun for a while. Initial experience is great. A year passes. The touchscreen fades. The wi-fi chip doesn't work with my new router. The notifications app doesn't work with my phone's OS upgrades. I'm jealous of the cool new model at my friend's house. I'll be shopping again in the near future. Instead, I could get a complicated dumb toaster, such as the Panasonic FlashXpress. It's got a ton of buttons that all do different things. Every morning for the next three weeks is going to be an experiment; I'll need to learn the ins-and-outs. Eventually, I can play it like a musical instrument. From there, I'll be able to use it until it dies, probably ten-plus years. The toaster will not be something I think about, really, at all. It's just a tool that sits there and does the job well. So here's the question. Do you prefer the immediate conveniences of using the latest and greatest, next year be damned? Or do you prefer the long-term convenience of not ever having to think about it?
- chris_wot 6y agoI go the middle ground. I get a toaster that toasts with a dial that goes from 1 to 10, and set it to 4 for my toast. Result: toast goodness. I don't need a toaster like this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LRq_SAuQDec https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LRq_SAuQDec
- toomanybeersies 6y agoThe toaster I bought for $10 a couple of years back has 2 buttons (frozen and cancel) and a single dial. I've never felt the need for more than that, I don't even use the frozen button.
- catlifeonmars 6y agoThat makes sense to me. In software design terms, this is a generalization of the single responsibility principle. That being said, I there’s still plenty of room for smart appliances that are fault tolerant and degrade gracefully. I agree that most “smart” things on the market today fail to implement either of these features particularly well, but I see no fundamental reason why they couldn’t.
- rsync 6y ago"A lot of people are still surprised when they hear that I work in the tech industry, but don't have - and recommend against - "smart"[1] devices in my house. The majority of my appliances are simple and robust without any computers or electronics, have lasted several decades, and will likely continue functioning for many more." I have adopted the same strategy and have had very good luck with it. "TV" is an industrial/commercial display (NEC P461). Microwave is a commercial panasonic (NE-12523). Coffemaker is a Technivorm Moccamaster. In addition to being "dumb" these devices are very well built, are repairable, and last forever.
- judge2020 6y ago> have lasted several decades, and will likely continue functioning for many more Well yes - Light switches made in 1900 will probably still work today, but you obviously don't have the features of IoT like toggling it from across the house or turning on multiple light [switches] at once. There's always a trade-off and people seem to want to pay for the convenience, even if it means replacing it in as short as 5-10 years.
- danielnixon 6y agoSmartness is a zero-sum game http://www.roughtype.com/?p=6452 http://www.roughtype.com/?p=6452
- Shared404 6y agoInteresting read, thanks. I mostly agree with the article's premise, but I would add an exception for when you automate the solution yourself. You personally no longer need to solve the problem, but in the process of automation you'll have to learn more about the problem then you are likely to learn just through solving it manually.
- nazgulnarsil 6y agoThat's the sort of thing that sounds smart if you don't stop to think about it for 10 seconds.
- _alex_ 6y agoI like that. That’s a great little phrase.
- asddubs 6y agothat's why i do all my coding in notepad