5 ms·
and one region on chromosome 9 that determines ABO blood groups. Rather than wasting many paragraphs talking about the Neanderthal connection, it would be vast
by DoreenMichele 6y ago
and one region on chromosome 9 that determines ABO blood groups.
Rather than wasting many paragraphs talking about the Neanderthal connection, it would be vastly more useful to determine exactly what these genes do and why they are a risk factor for the disease.
The disease significantly impacts the blood. If we can determine, for example, what blood groups it impacts the worst, that might be meaningful -- a lot more meaningful than "There's a Neanderthal connection."
- anonu 6y agoNice point. Would you argue that authors of this paper are incentivized to sensationalize the headline for eyeballs?
- DoreenMichele 6y agoMy general understanding is that studies like this tend to be a case of "We studied what we could get funded for, even if it wasn't exactly what we really wanted to know." Beyond that, I don't know and don't care about that end of things, really. I'm much more interested in this end of things where I have a smidgen of influence -- that being "What do we see as a priority in discussing the problem on HN?" because HN attracts a lot of brilliant and connected people, so I imagine if we come up with a better mental model for solving the problem here, it will proliferate.
- svara 6y agoThe last author Svante Pääbo's group has been working on Neanderthal genome sequencing for roughly two decades now. It's basic research into the evolutionary history of our species. They certainly didn't secretly want to work on infectious diseases all along. Besides, where do you get the idea that getting funded to work on the Neanderthal genome is easier than getting funded to work on an ongoing pandemic? Not that Pääbo needs it, as a Max Planck director he doesn't need to apply for grants. What's happening here is simply that the world's Neanderthal genome experts continue working on Neanderthal genomes, and when they find something that is related to the pandemic it ends up in Nature and the popular press.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoBesides, where do you get the idea that getting funded to work on the Neanderthal genome is easier than getting funded to work on an ongoing pandemic? I stated as clearly as I know how that it is my general understanding, not specific to this article or what is being studied here. I get the idea from my sister who worked at the CDC for many years and also had multiple rounds of cancer. And before life got in the way and she and I stopped being able to hang on the phone regularly, she used to routinely read the latest cancer research because she worked at the CDC and because she had cancer. And she used to routinely bitch to me about how "98 percent of it is some variation on the same thing because it's what is trendy and it's what you can readily get funding for. There's almost nothing actually new and interesting in breast cancer research." She was also patient zero in a cutting edge study and yadda. She was very much an insider in multiple ways and she and I were close at one time, before I was homeless and had no phone for a year or more and before she began working 16 hours a day and had no time talk to anyone regularly, not even our mother.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- _Microft 6y agoFrom the abstract of the paper it sounds like the connection with blood groups was known already [0] and that they actually discovered the link to Neanderthals [1] which makes it understandable that they want to talk about Neanderthals. If someone prefers their papers as PDFs, there is also one available on the website (I for one hate the mess that these "web papers" are): https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2818-3.pdf https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2818-3.pdf [0] "A recent genetic association study identified a gene cluster on chromosome 3 as a risk locus for respiratory failure after infection with severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2). A separate study (COVID-19 Host Genetics Initiative)2 comprising 3,199 hospitalized patients with coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) and control individuals showed that this cluster is the major genetic risk factor for severe symptoms after SARS-CoV-2 infection and hospitalization." [1] "Here we show that the risk is conferred by a genomic segment of around 50 kilobases in size that is inherited from Neanderthals and is carried by around 50% of people in south Asia and around 16% of people in Europe."
- kennywinker 6y agoOther studies have pointed to higher risk for A and B blood types / lower risk for O blood types. That's much easier data to gather, since you don't actually have to pinpoint specific genes, just do a blood type test on people who get severe covid. For this research - just because you've identified a gene linked to risk, doesn't mean you can say anything about why or how that happens. We likely don't know much about this area of the genome - how it's expressed, etc. and so they went with the angle we DID know - that it's inherited from neanderthal. No doubt more research in this area will be done now that they've found a region of interest.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- attractivechaos 6y agoYour quote is wrong. From the first paragraph, the sentence immediately following your quote: "the region on chromosome 3 is the only region that is significantly associated with severe COVID-19 at the genome-wide level". The chr9 region is not associated.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThe quote was grabbed because it said what that gene was associated with -- blood groups -- and the disease is known to impact blood. I am not finding anything in the article that explains what chromosome 3 does. If anyone can cast some light on what chromosome 3 does, that would be cool. (Maybe it's in the article and bad eyesight plus lack of sleep is causing me to miss it?) My main point was just: What do these genes actually do in the body? We should be looking at that. It's a much more important question than where these genes come from.
- attractivechaos 6y ago> The quote was grabbed because it said what that gene was associated with -- blood groups -- and the disease is known to impact blood. The sentence following your quote says a new study suggests genes determining blood groups are NOT associated with COVID severity. If you want to criticize the paper, at least quote something that the paper actually supports. As to your main point, others are working on the functional part. The authors just report a finding with their expertise. Not every scientific paper immediately solves a practical problem.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoMy intent was not to criticize the paper per se. And I focused on the thing I felt was relevant to my point, which I have already clarified.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- svara 6y agoYou're complaining about the world's Neanderthal genome experts [0] continuing to work on the Neanderthal genome ... There is no claim here of a novel finding of immediate biomedical significance; rather this builds on top of other people's biomedically relevant work, which is cited in the abstract. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Svante_P%C3%A4%C3%A4bo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Svante_P%C3%A4%C3%A4bo
- DoreenMichele 6y agoNo, not really. I'm more complaining about what the world chooses to focus on. When the pandemic started, there were numerous articles on the front page of HN about ventilators and how to build your own and nonsense like that and I was critical of that as well. And it soon turned out that ventilators weren't really a good solution. Neanderthal experts can study whatever they want to study, but their research is being connected to this pandemic and given that we are in lock down number two, I think we have more urgent issues than where these genes came from and I wish people in general -- the world at large -- would focus on that. Granted, I'm short of sleep and no doubt saying things somewhat ham-handedly.
- kennywinker 6y agoThis could be a useful piece of the puzzle, or it could be entirely useless, but we don't get to say that now - only time will tell. This is how research works. Computers came out of research into weaving and loom technology. If you had said we need technology to interconnect the globe, you wouldn't have funded research into weaving. Yet here we are.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI have a genetic disorder. I have been getting better for nearly two decades while the world attacks and dismisses me as a lunatic and teller of tall tales for the crime of talking on the internet about it sometimes. I got better by looking at what we know about how the genetic defect impacts cell function in my body and learning a lot about cell function and connecting the dots between the micro -- molecules misprocessed at the cellular level -- and the macro -- dysfunction in certain tissues and how the body handles and mishandles food, among other things. I'm not capable of setting aside twenty years of life experience in order to fit myself neatly into the Overton Window, especially when short of sleep. It never ceases to amaze me how much negative attention my comments get, like it's just incredibly important for people who think they know more about science than I do to quash my ability to give my 2 cents. My stellar credentials include being a homemaker for two decades and spending nearly six years homeless. Everyone on the planet is more than welcome to look at my comments, decide quietly to themselves that I'm an idiot who knows nothing, downvote it and move the fuck on rather than lecturing me about the crime of having thoughts about the pandemic and what I think we should be looking at if we actually want to solve it and not treat it like we are looky-loos at a zoo seeking entertainment in the deaths of our fellow human beings. Science also includes critical thinking, critique of what has been done, rigorous discussion and a whole lot of other things beyond just dicking around with exploring whatever catches our fancy for funsies.
- nobodyandproud 6y agoMany research scientists like to tie their research to something eye catching, or something generally interesting to the public. It’s the modern era’s equivalent of musicians and artists courting wealthy patrons, in order to keep funding flowing. Black holes, Dinosaurs, Neanderthals, ...