6 ms·
Electromagnetism using geometric algebra versus components
- sgdpk 6y agoPersonally, an appealing part of GA is clarifying that the magnetic field is best viewed as an "oriented area", instead of a pseudo-vector [1], which is a concept that is frequently ill-defined. Usually, lecturers say that the magnetic field is essentially a vector, but to be careful that it flips directions when you mirror space. But how then can you check this by just looking at the usual three coordinates of the vector? With GA, you associate the magnetic field with an oriented plane element. Oriented planes have this flip-mirroring property. Because space is 3D, you have exactly one vector to which this plane element is perpendicular, so you can identify the field with a vector. This is called the Hodge duality, and this particular form is accidental to 3D space. If you need more convincing, the magnitude of the magnetic field is given by the cross-product, which calculates the area spanned by two vectors. You could argue that you don't need GA for this, only to use the exterior product instead of the cross product. But by using an algebra that contains both vectors and oriented areas, you can effectively sum the electric and magnetic fields. This will give you pretty compact and beautiful equations, which is the essence of this article. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pseudovector https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pseudovector
- aesthesia 6y agoYou still don’t need geometric algebra to combine the magnetic and electric fields, if you view them as differential forms on 4-dimensional spacetime. From what I can tell, this approach is basically equivalent to what this article does. You could directly translate everything into the language of differential forms, because the only geometric products here are in fact just exterior products.
- yiyus 6y agoThis "competition" between geometric algebra and differential forms makes me uncomfortable. As far as I see (and I'm not an expert), they are just different ways to express very similar concepts. They are still not exactly the same, since the geometric product is not defined in DFs, and there is no hodge star operator in GA, for example, but everything you can do using one formalism in practice can also be easily done using the other one. What am I missing?
- DreamScatter 6y agoYou're mistaken, GA does have a Hodge star, as I've explained many times before https://grassmann.crucialflow.com/dev/algebra https://grassmann.crucialflow.com/dev/algebra The exterior product can be derived from the geometric product, so differential forms occur in geometric algebra.
- yiyus 6y agoYou can easily define it, that's what I meant saying that you can do the same things in practice, but it's not usually defined (at least in the books and articles I've read), and certainly it is not so ubiquitous as in DFs texts. And, of course, the exterior product is contained in the geometric product. I guess that, in the same way, you could define a geometric product operator when using a DFs formulation. Would you then say that geometric algebra occurs in differential forms? In any case, you did not attempt to answer my original question. Are GA and DFs just different ways to define "equivalent" concepts or is there some more fundamental difference that I am missing?
- DreamScatter 6y agoNo, I would say differential forms occur in geometric algebra, not the other way around.
- yiyus 6y agoFair enough. I have seen some comments (not in this thread, it was some time ago) that suggested that DFs allow the same as GA in practice, and everything GA does is adding an unnecessary geometric product, but exterior products should be enough (not my opinion, I can try to find the original comment if you want). I do not know enough to have an own opinion. You obviously know more than me about this, so I will ask you a slightly different question: if I learn GA well enough and totally ignore differential forms, what will I miss?
- chobytes 6y ago
- bollu 6y agoFor anyone looking for a sane way to study this stuff, what finally made sense to me was (1) study discrete differential geometry from Keenan Crane's notes: https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~kmcrane/Projects/DDG/ https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~kmcrane/Projects/DDG/ ; (2) Read these notes on geometric algebra that formally lay down what the hell a GA space is and what operations one can perform on them: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1205.5935.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1205.5935.pdf (Geometric Algebra: Eric Chisolm)
- patrec 6y agoFor clicking convenience: https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~kmcrane/Projects/DDG/ https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~kmcrane/Projects/DDG/ (the link above is broken since HN includes the ]; in the URL).
- pastrami_panda 6y agoThis is also an excellent and interactive blog-post building up to the understanding of how rotors can replace quaternions in GA: https://marctenbosch.com/quaternions/ https://marctenbosch.com/quaternions/
- wwarner 6y ago+1 to this exposition!
- adamnemecek 6y agoYou should check out the bivector community https://bivector.net/ https://bivector.net/ dedicated to Geometric algebra. Join the discord https://discord.gg/vGY6pPk https://discord.gg/vGY6pPk. Check out a demo https://observablehq.com/@enkimute/animated-orbits https://observablehq.com/@enkimute/animated-orbits
- DreamScatter 6y agoRecently I made a video presentation about geometric algebra, including the formulation of Maxwell's equations in GA: https://youtu.be/7hlDRLEhc8o https://youtu.be/7hlDRLEhc8o Also, my implementation of geometric algebra in the Julia language, Grassmann.jl https://github.com/chakravala/Grassmann.jl https://github.com/chakravala/Grassmann.jl It helped me truly understand Maxwell's equations for the first time, understanding that it is not just some physical artifact but actually a natural foundational idea in pure mathematics applicable to physics.
- taliesinb 6y agoThat’s cool. What do you make of the algebra of the dihedrons? https://youtu.be/lqH4BLHGsFw https://youtu.be/lqH4BLHGsFw . It’s a “sister algebra” of the quaternions.
- jacobolus 6y agoThese “dihedrons” (which you might as well just call “2x2 matrices with real entries”) are isomorphic to the geometric algebra of the 2-dimensional Euclidean vector plane with signature (+, +), with 1 scalar component, 2 vector components, and 1 bivector component. Personally I find the basis 1, e₁, e₂, e₁e₂ and the notation of GA to be conceptually much clearer than the matrix entries and standard matrix sum/product to work with, but sometimes using a matrix representation is convenient in a computer. (2x2 real matrices are also isomorphic to the geometric algebra of the 2-dimensional pseudo-Euclidean vector plane with signature (+, -), under a different interpretation.) By comparison the quaternions are the even subalgebra of the geometric algebra of 3-dimensional Euclidean vector space with signature (+,+,+), consisting of only the 1 scalar and 3 bivector components. Or under a different interpretation are isomorphic to the full geometric algebra of the 2-dimensional vector plane with signature (-, -). They can be represented as Pauli matrices. For more on this see the papers and books of Garret Sobczyk, https://garretstar.com/secciones/publications/publications.html https://garretstar.com/secciones/publications/publications.h... ; for example the recent https://www.garretstar.com/sobczyk09-mar-2020.pdf https://www.garretstar.com/sobczyk09-mar-2020.pdf
- enriquto 6y agoNobody ever writes Maxell's equations using "components", the title sounds like a straw man argument. The rest of the text is well written, but hopelessly useless without a comparison with the typical way to write Maxwell's equations using differential forms (which turns out to be essentially identical to geometric algebra).
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoIf I understand correctly, Maxwell wrote Maxwell's equations using components. That's why they took 20 equations.
- enriquto 6y agoSure. My first sentence is missing the word "today".
- peter303 6y agoMaxwell wrote his equations using components. Heavyside create modern vector notation.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bawana 6y agoIf a point is the intersection of two lines, and a line is the intersection of two planes, then what structures intersect to give a plane? Two 3D spaces? And so the intersection of 2 4D spaces should give a 3D space? How do I express these ideas with GA?
- jbay808 6y agoTotal non expert here but your fascinating question got me thinking out loud. Two 3D volumes in a 3D space obviously intersect to give another 3D volume, unless they're tangent. So at first glance I'd be tempted to say no, but... Two overlapping polygons in a 2D space also define another 2D polygon. Two overlapping line segments in a 1D space define another line segment. You only get a reduced-dimension object at the intersection if they're intersecting in a higher dimensional space. Otherwise they can't intersect "at an angle". So I'd say purely by following the pattern that it must be that two 3D spaces intersecting "at an angle" within a 4D space define a plane by their intersection.
- bawana 6y agoThat's why I ask how to formally describe this problem. It's too 'squishy' to say two 3d spaces intersecting at an angle in a 4d space. I thought perhaps I could use time to untangle this visualization-defining a solid as the result of taking a plane and sweeping it through space. So, envisioning the 'growth' of a solid from a moving plane and imagining the intersection of the growing solid with the another growing solid from a different plane.
- Kliment 6y agoIt's not too squishy. The important thing to understand here is that a plane is an infinite object in a given subspace - just like a line is. Two infinite objects intersecting give you an infinite object in the subspaces they share, and a zero-sized object in the subspaces they don't share. The shared subspace of two planes in 2D is obviously the same plane. The shared subspace of two planes in 3D is obviously either zero (two parallel nonincident planes), a line (the intersection that they share) or a plane (two incident planes). So you get a null, a one-dimensional subspace, or a two-dimensional subspace, depending on how many shared subspaces you have between the objects. So a pair of three-dimensional infinite objects, in four-dimensional space, may either be disjoint, resulting in a null, incident, resulting in an infinite volume, or intersecting, resulting in an infinite plane. The source of confusion here is that we're mixing up (bounded) volumetric shapes, line segments, and planar polygons, with their infinite counterparts - the lines, points, planes, and infinite volumes. An infinite object has no shape - it is infinite in some dimensions and zero in all others - this is what gives us those clear well-defined intersection objects, which are either zero or infinite. A bounded object has a shape - it has a boundary that is not infinite. When you intersect such objects within their shared subspaces (two line segments on the same line, two polygons on the same plane, two volumes in the same space) you get either a null, or an object of the same type. This is obvious when you make one of the objects infinite - an intersection of a line segment with its line gives you the same line segment. So the reason you are having difficulty imagining two somethings that will intersect in a plane is that a plane is an infinite object, so only two infinite objects can intersect in a plane. So you need two infinite volumes, that pass through the same 4D space, but are not the same volume. These volumes share a two-dimensional subspace - the area of 4D space they intersect in is a plane. It's infinite in two dimensions, and zero-sized in two others.
- carapace 6y agoI found "Geometric Algebra for Electrical and Electronic Engineers" helpful: https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/6876131 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/6876131 ABSTRACT: In this paper, we explicate the suggested benefits of Clifford’s geometric algebra (GA) when applied to the field of electrical engineering. Engineers are always interested in keeping formulas as simple or compact as possible, and we illustrate that geometric algebra does provide such a simplified representation in many cases. We also demonstrate an additional structural check provided by GA for formulas in addition to the usual checking of physical dimensions. Naturally, there is an initial learning curve when applying a new method, but it appears to be worth the effort, as we show significantly simplified formulas, greater intuition, and improved problem solving in many cases.