3 ms·
The vaccine is great, but that seems like a one-off caused by throwing massive amounts of money at a critical problem. The rest seem less like breakthroughs an
by bawolff 6y ago
The vaccine is great, but that seems like a one-off caused by throwing massive amounts of money at a critical problem.
The rest seem less like breakthroughs and more just improvements as time marches on. Are these really the best examples of breakthroughs that the western world can come up with?
- wcoenen 6y agoIt wasn't a one-off, it has accelerated the development of mRNA vaccines. This is a new type of vaccine that will be applied to other diseases as well.
- bawolff 6y agoThe article primarily talks about the compressed timeline, not the fact its mRNA. I maintain the timeline is a one-off. The new technology is super exciting though, so lets give the article that. We're hardly so stagnant that a single technological breakthrough is unheard of in the last 50 years and signals an end of stagnancy.
- wcoenen 6y ago> The article primarily talks about the compressed timeline, not the fact its mRNA. I maintain the timeline is a one-off. I feel that you're splitting hairs here. The article mentions both in adjacent paragraphs. And the fact that the vaccine was developed faster was also not a one-off, this is a feature of mRNA vaccines. Future vaccines can be manufactured with the same blueprint by just swapping out the mRNA sequence.
- occamsrazorwit 6y agoHow does developing a vaccine two months faster have a lasting impact on daily life? The best case argument for having a noticeable impact is COVID, and we can't even use that because we split vaccine development into multiple tracks. It's possible that we would've had a traditional vaccine around the same time if we focused more resources on it and less on a novel technique.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoFocus on 'western world' might be a mistake? A lot of gamechanging science emerged from cold war. Not only did USSR produce some science, western scientists did not have to jump through hoops all day to get funding - politicians knew falling behind was not an option
- bawolff 6y agoOh definitely, but the article seems US-centric for some reason.